A man convicted of having sexual intercourse with a 14-year-old girl in Phnom Penh in 2017 requested an Appeal Court judge to reduce his sentence on Tuesday.
His lawyer maintained the sex was consensual and his client didn’t know her age.
At the hearing, Van Kanan, 27, told the judge that he and the victim lived in the same village and he had known her for four to five months.
He said they would frequently have romantic conversations and he never asked about her age. The victim allegedly told him that she was in the 10th grade at Santhomuk High School. He said she had a big body and was 1.6m tall.
Kanan allegedly invited the victim to his rented room in Por Sen Chey district’s Chaom Chao commune to take care of him because he felt unwell. At that time, Kanan said she agreed to have sex with him.
Kanan said: “I filed a complaint to the Appeal Court to lower my punishment to six months because I truly had [consensual] sex with her.”
Reading the Phnom Penh Municipal Court’s original report at the appeal hearing, presiding Judge In Vanvibol said on February 1, 2017, at 2:30 pm, the victim went to the suspect’s room, where he raped her.
The report said on February 2, 2017, the victim told her mother, who then filed a complaint to the police to detain Kanan.
The municipal court later changed its charge of aggravated rape to sexual intercourse with a minor under 15.
Kanan was sentenced to four years imprisonment and ordered to pay 20 million riel ($4,857) to the victim as compensation.
Kanan filed an appeal because he deemed the punishment and fines to be excessive, Judge Vanvibol said.
“The court required the victim to be present at the hearing [on Tuesday]. The answer of the victim made the suspect go to prison, but the victim is absent,” said Judge Vanvibol.
Prosecutor Chea Met said the victim also filed a complaint to the Appeal Court because she believed she received too little compensation.
Met said: “The lower court’s decision was right. I would like the court to uphold its original judgment. Medical examinations proved that Kanan raped the victim,” he said.
The victim’s lawyer Sin Sovorn said: “The evidence sent to the police was a broken button and a broken pants zipper. The forensic evidence also showed that it was rape,” she said.
Sovorn said her client did not agree to the 20 million riel compensation and asked for 40 million instead.
Kanan’s lawyer who declined to be identified said it was wrong to consider the crime as juvenile rape.
He said the victim used to tell Kanan that she was 16 years old. Furthermore, she only told her parents about the alleged rape when they questioned her.
“My client is not a sex offender. He had sex with the girl under mutual agreement. May the court please lower the punishment,” the lawyer appealed.
Judge Vanvibol said he will announce his decision on July 13.