Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - American Bar Association slams trial of Ny Chakrya

American Bar Association slams trial of Ny Chakrya

Election official Ny Chakrya speaks to the media as he is escorted through Phnom Penh’s Appeal Court in August.
Election official Ny Chakrya speaks to the media as he is escorted through Phnom Penh’s Appeal Court in August. Heng Chivoan

American Bar Association slams trial of Ny Chakrya

The American Bar Association has slammed the September defamation conviction of former Adhoc staffer Ny Chakrya, saying the trial was “marred by significant irregularities in violation of the right to a fair trial”.

Chakrya, who is now the deputy secretary-general of the National Election Committee, was convicted in September of allegedly defaming two Siem Reap court officials and attempting to “unlawfully coerce judicial authorities”, sentenced to six months in prison and fined 6 million riel (about $1,460) by Phnom Penh judge Khy Chhai in a case widely seen as judicial harassment of the rights group.

The case stemmed from criticisms by Chakrya – aired during a press conference – of the Siem Reap investigating judge Ky Rithy and deputy prosecutor Sok Keo Bandith for arresting two villagers in relation to a high-profile land dispute in the province.

In a trial-observation report released yesterday, the American Bar Association’s Center for Human Rights found Chakrya’s trial to be riddled with elements of procedural negligence, including the court’s apparent presumption of guilt and the absence of the complainants. Both Rithy and Keo Bandith skipped the trial, as they had an earlier hearing in July.

“Given the failure of the complaining parties to appear, it would seem reasonable to request a dismissal of the charge or in the alternative a continuance to force their attendance,” the report reads.

The report also noted that “the Prosecution in this case basically presented no evidence”, and furthermore criticised the lack of reasoning for the ruling provided by judge Chhai – who took only 15 minutes to deliberate the merits of the case.

“[Chhai] did not respond to concerns raised by the defense counsel about the failure of the prosecution to maintain its burden of proof, the right to confront witnesses or the claim the statement made by the defendant was true,” the report reads.

The report also concludes that Cambodia’s defamation statute itself is deeply flawed, and likely violates the Kingdom’s international legal obligations.

Sam Sokong, who represented Chakrya, agreed with the report’s assessment, adding that the inability to cross-examine the complainants had hurt his defence. “This was a challenge for me as a defence lawyer,” he said. “With this report, I hope the Appeal Court will organise hearings [more] carefully so that they are not criticised.”

While the “public defamation” charge on its own does not hold a prison sentence, legal expert Sok Sam Oeun said it was the frequent coupling of defamation with other serious offences – in Chakrya’s case criticism of the court – that enabled the prosecution to push for jail time.

“With only defamation, defendants will not be scared,” he said. “They [prosecution] will choose other charges so that they can send you to jail.”

With regards to Cambodia’s lethargic attempts at judicial reform, Sam Oeun said the lack of qualified legal experts at the Ministry of Justice and the government’s rigid rejection of criticisms of the court prevented any kind of change.

“The government has to understand that these reforms are needed,” he said. “But then if you criticise the judiciary, you go to jail.”

Last year, the International Bar Association released a highly critical review of the Cambodian judiciary, calling it ridden with endemic corruption, bribery and political influence.

While corruption and bribery were found at every level of the court, the report also pointed to three laws meant to regulate the judiciary passed in 2014 as having cemented the executive branch’s control over the courts.

Kingsley Abbot, senior international legal adviser at the International Commission of Jurists, said any improvements made to ensure better trial procedures were overshadowed by the government’s extended control over the judiciary.

“The real issue is the extent to which judges are able to conduct their work free from government interference, particularly in politicised cases,” he said.

Chakrya is currently in pre-trial detention for a bribery case related to opposition leader Kem Sokha’s alleged sex scandal along with his former Adhoc colleagues – Yi Soksan, Lim Mony, Ny Sokha and Nay Vanda. That case is also widely believed to be politically motivated.

Additional reporting by Niem Chheng

MOST VIEWED

  • Rainsy stopped in Paris from boarding Thai flight

    Airline officials at Paris’ Charles de Gaulle airport on Thursday prevented Sam Rainsy from boarding his flight to Bangkok ahead of his announced return to Cambodia on Saturday. Prime Minister Hun Sen had earlier in the day assured Phnom Penh residents that there would be

  • Analyst: Rainsy blocked from boarding flight 'an excuse'

    THAI Airways not allowing Sam Rainsy on its route from Paris to Bangkok on Thursday is being used as an excuse to keep his standing among fellow coup plotters and his uninformed supporters as flights to non-Asean countries are available, an analyst said on Friday.

  • Rainsy lands in Malaysia

    Cambodian opposition figure Sam Rainsy arrived in Kuala Lumpur airport on Saturday afternoon after boarding a flight from Paris, where he has been living for more than four years. Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation spokesperson Koy Kuong said on Saturday that Cambodia respected

  • Touch: Rainsy will never return

    Sam Rainsy, the “acting president” of the Supreme Court-dissolved Cambodia National Rescue Party (CNRP), has claimed it has achieved 70 per cent of its struggle to find a solution to the current political situation in the Kingdom. Just before boarding a plane at Charles de Gaulle

  • Sokha continues call for dropping of charge after bail conditions reduced

    Not satisfied with having his bail conditions reduced, allowing him to travel freely in Cambodia, Kem Sokha says he wants his charge totally dropped. “As an innocent man who has been in detention for two years even without being found guilty, I continue to demand

  • MEPs' call for Rainsy's safety not European Parliament position

    The European Parliament said on Friday that a statement by 56 Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) calling for guarantees of Sam Rainsy’s freedom and safety should he return to Cambodia did not represent its position. Delphine Colard, the European Parliament’s press officer told