Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - The amnesia of Brother No 2

The amnesia of Brother No 2

The amnesia of Brother No 2


As the most senior surviving leader of the Khmer Rouge, experts see "substantial

and compelling evidence" linking Nuon Chea to the purges and execution

policies of the Pol Pot regime.

Former Khmer Rouge leader Nuon Chea, 82, at his home in Pruhm village near the Thai border. Among other denials, Brother No 2 said on December 16, "I never heard of prison called Toul Sleng."

In 2004, authors Stephen Heder and Brian Tittemore named Nuon Chea as the first of

seven candidates "most responsible" for the crimes committed between 1975

and 1979. Yet Nuon Chea is a free man. And after 28 years of impunity, Brother No

2 expresses little concern for consequences - be it at the hands of the courts, karma

or the Cambodian people.

He lives 23 km from Pailin, in the small village of Pruhm, just steps from the Thai

border. It's a pleasant setting for an 82-year-old retiree: modest, comfortable and

well tended. His stilt home, weathered and wooden, is fronted by the flowers and

fruit trees planted by his wife. Until recently, his next door neighbor was Khieu


Nuon Chea stands at the top of seven steps. He wears a hooded Champion sweatshirt

over a sarong. The man known as Uncle Nuon in Angkar - "the Organization"

- doesn't shake hands. He smiles, and offers a sampeah, but does not bow his head.

Nuon Chea spoke to Stephan Haselberger, reporter for Berlin's Der Tagesspiegel,

about his role in the mass killings of the Khmer Rouge, and what he plans to tell

his grandchildren about the past. Here are excerpts from that December 16 interview.

Under the Khmer Rouge an estimated 1.7 million lives were lost. Do you accept

responsibility for the mass executions and deportations, forced labor and famine?

I do not have exact figures regarding lives and deaths available. But I ask you:

How many people died during the Lon Nol regime backed by the United States of America?

How many died when Vietnam invaded Cambodia? Did you consider these deaths when talking

about the 1.7 million cases? We would not have succeeded in our five-year-long fight

against the Americans if we had killed our own people.

Did I get this right: There were no mass murders or executions under the Khmer

Rouge regime?

It may have happened in particular cases, but it was not us who killed our people.

Our enemies killed them.

Who were these enemies?

They were foreign intelligence representatives who were hidden in our villages.

There must have been a lot of agents. How many do you think there were?

I am not able to give an estimate.
After the Khmer Rouge's reign, thousands of mass graves were discovered. Having

been Brother No 2, how could you not know about this?

Those photographs with skulls now being presented do not mean a thing. Modern technology

can do this. Skulls of Vietnamese and US soldiers are being lined up and photographed.

This does not mean that I do not want to take responsibility. But it was Cambodian

people who started my party. Why should we have killed our own people? I do not see

a reason.

You are saying all these people were brought to death either by foreign intelligence

agents or the Lon Nol regime during the war?


So, let's talk about Tuol Sleng then, the secret torture prison known as S 21.

Back then I did not know a prison operating under this name. I learned about it only

after the Vietnamese invasion.

Documents prove that you were at least informed of the murders in Tuol Sleng.

I did not know about this. I never heard about Tuol Sleng. If these documents existed,

they were manipulated. Because everyone wants to blame it on the People's Republic

of Kampuchea, this would not be difficult.

How could it happen that, as Brother No 2, you were not aware of such a prison

operating in front of you?

There was no S 21 at this time. If it had existed, I would have been informed. But

I never heard about it.

But you do remember Comrade Duch, the former head of the jail?

Mr Duch was with the Ministry of Defense and internal security then. Son Sen was

accountable for the ministry, not me.

Mr Duch says, among other things, that in 1978 he had, by order of you, a directive

to kill 300 Khmer Rouge soldiers without interrogation.

I have not the faintest idea. I was not accountable for internal security and did

not have the capacity to interfere or issue orders. At that time we strictly followed

the principle of task-sharing. Mr Duch blamed many things on me. I was a high-ranking

politician then. I was responsible for parts of our policies, but there are limits.

For internal security, it was the Military Commission that was liable.

So the commission is responsible for mass murders?

I do not know whether there were killings or not. Murders may have happened. But

mass murders? Some worked against our party, and then one solved this problem.

Did mass murders happen or not?

Maybe there were mass killings, but we did not know about them. That is what we are

accountable for. It was our failing that we did not look after people locally. This

is where we were responsible.

So, if there were mass murders, the party did not know anything about them and

they were beyond the party's control?

If this happened, it was unintentional. The party leaders really fought. We gave

our lives for our country. We needed a labor force. We would have lost labor, had

we had our people killed. For the time being, I do not want to say more about this.

If I will be put on trial I'll be talking.

Do you expect to be charged?

[Laughing] Yes, probably. The tribunal is concerned with me because I was called

Brother No 2. This won't be a problem. If I am summoned, I will go and tell what


Do you regret that your regime brought your country misery?

I do think about what my country is to be lacking. But, you know, I always lived

close to the people. I participated in the revolution because I wanted to do something

for my country. Basically, I look ahead rather than back. The past is teaching us

a lesson to avoid future failures.

What lessons did you learn?

One great lesson is that we wanted too much, too fast. We aimed too high. Our requirements

for the people were too high. We thought we had to develop the country very quickly.

Vietnam had a population of 70 million, Thailand of 60 million people. We thought

we had to be quick or remain at the bottom. We wanted to push the population to 20

million in five years. We thought that people would benefit from our program. This

was an error.

What was the result of your error?

The result that can be seen now.

What do you mean?

We did not succeed. We wanted a clean, illuminating and peaceful regime. At least

we maintained the country, the nation, as a whole. That's a point from where to start.

What will you say when your grandchildren ask why your Khmer Rouge has brought

so much pain to Cambodia?

I will tell them they should make up their own mind.

During this interview you were laughing a lot. Are you a happy person?

[Laughing]. I live a normal life. It's like in everybody's life: sometimes you are

happy, sometimes not. I don't care much. I just stay normal.


  • Government denies claims former Thai PM Yingluck issued Cambodian passport

    Government officials on Thursday denied claims that a Cambodian passport was issued to former Thai Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra, who reportedly used it to register a company in Hong Kong. The Hong Kong-based English language South China Morning Post (SCMP) on Wednesday reported Hong Kong

  • Diplomatic passports issued to foreigners to be annulled

    The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation will move to annul diplomatic passports issued to those not born in Cambodia. Analysts say the move may be in relation to reports that former Thai prime minister Yingluck Shinawatra used a Cambodian passport to register as

  • Hun Sen warns Irish MP of EBA ‘mistake’

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on Saturday told former Irish premier Enda Kenny, still a member of the EU nation’s parliament, that the 28-nation bloc should not make a “third mistake” regarding Cambodia by using the preferential Everything But Arms (EBA) agreement to “take 16 million

  • The hairy little heroes saving many lives in rural Cambodia

    IN RURAL Siem Reap province, rats dare to tread where no person will, as these hairy little heroes place their lives on the line each day for the good of the local community. The rodents are the most important members of a special team, leading