Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Ao An request to drop charges denied

Ao An request to drop charges denied

Ao An, an ex-Khmer Rouge official, is photographed during a 2011 interview. DC-CAM
Ao An, an ex-Khmer Rouge official, is photographed during a 2011 interview. DC-CAM

Ao An request to drop charges denied

A request by Ao An’s defence team to annul investigations and charges stemming from the Tuol Beng execution site ultimately fell flat at the Khmer Rouge tribunal due to a disagreement between international and national pre-trial judges, according to a court document made public last week.

The redacted document, which is addressed to An’s lawyers and names him on one occasion, calls for crimes against humanity and premeditated murder charges related to Tuol Beng to be dropped, and for the investigation into the Wat Angkuonh Dei crime site to be annulled. Ao An stands accused of several other crimes against humanity at other sites, including genocide.

But, following a pattern of marked division between Cambodian legal teams and their international counterparts at the court, the judges were not able to reach the four votes needed to have those charges dismissed.

While the three national pre-trial judges – Prak Kimsan, Ney Thol and Huot Vuthy – agreed the investigations into those sites “must be annulled” because Ao An was not a senior leader or one of those most responsible for the crimes of the regime, their international counterparts Olivier Beauvallet and Kang Jin Baik maintained those zones fell “squarely within the scope of the judicial investigation”.

An’s defence had claimed certain sites were not included in the scope and were thus “procedurally defective”.

In the document, international prosecutor Nicholas Koumjian urged the judges to dismiss An’s request, saying that An’s right to a fair trial had not been breached, and that “even if existence of procedural defect and harm were established, under the circumstances of this case, annulment would be a drastic and disproportionate remedy”.

MOST VIEWED

  • Hun Sen asks Cambodians to believe in government

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on Monday asked citizens and investors to trust that the government will overcome the challenges brought about by Covid-19 and the loss of the EU’s Everything But Arms (EBA) scheme. Speaking to reporters at the Peace Palace in Phnom Penh,

  • Westerdam passenger ‘never had’ Covid-19

    The US Centres for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) said the US citizen that allegedly tested positive in Malaysia after travelling on the Westerdam was never infected with Covid-19 in the first place. In an article published in the newspaper USA Today on Friday, CDC

  • ‘Ghost staff’ found, $1.7M returned to state coffers

    The Ministry of Civil Service said more than seven billion riel ($1.7 million) in salaries for civil servants was returned to the state last year after it discovered that the books had been cooked to pay ‘ghost officials’. This is despite claims by the Ministry of

  • Tragedy as four lions devour teenager in Pakistan safari park

    In a horrifying incident at an animal park in the Pakistani city of Lahore, four lions killed a 17-year-old grass reaper. However, how Muhammad Bilal Hussain managed to get near the lions was yet to be ascertained. Safari officials said Hussain climbed a 3.7m high

  • Woman wanted for killing own son

    Police in Phnom Penh’s Meanchey district are on the lookout for a woman who allegedly hacked her son to death on Sunday in Stung Meanchey III commune. District police chief Meng Vimeandara identified the son as Chan Sokhom, 32. “The offender can’t escape forever.

  • H5N1 also poses deadly threat, ministry warns

    The Ministry of Health’s Communicable Disease Control (CDC) department has called on citizens to excise caution over H5N1 or bird flu that is spreading in the southern province of Vietnam. In a Facebook post, the department announced that it has made a series