Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Avoiding the 'logic' of waste trafficking

Avoiding the 'logic' of waste trafficking

Avoiding the 'logic' of waste trafficking

Jim Puckett is Coordinator of the Basel Action Network (BAN), an international

alliance of activists working to prevent the globalization of the toxics crisis worldwide.

Here, he argues that, far from being resolved, the toxic waste case in Sihanoukville

may only be the beginning of Cambodia's troubles.

The United States, the country that produces the most toxic waste in the world, has

nominated a new Treasurer - Mr. Lawrence Summers.

This is the man who will be in charge of the finances of the richest country in the

world. It will be his name that will be scrawled on all American bills. But Mr. Summers'

name will also forever be inextricably linked to some words he penned in 1991 which

sent shock waves around the world.

At that time, Mr. Summers, then Chief Economist of the World Bank, wrote in an internal

memo, "I think the economic logic behind dumping a load of toxic waste in the

lowest wage country is impeccable and we should face up to that."

While the world expressed its outrage at these words after they were leaked to the

global press, the real, lasting outrage is that these words are frighteningly true.

Hazardous waste if left to free market forces, will, inevitably flow on a path of

least resistance from rich, heavily industrialized countries to poorer countries.

Six months ago Cambodia was rudely introduced to the "impeccable logic"

of the international trade in hazardous waste with the dumping of 3,000 tonnes of

mercury contaminated industrial wastes by one of the world's largest chemical companies.

The dumping was far more than a mere insult to an already beleaguered nation. It

was injury.

As a result of the chemical violence by the rich arrogant company from a far-away

land, Cambodian citizens became ill and died, Cambodian property was destroyed, others

died in the panic that ensued, soil was contaminated, businesses suffered, governments

and armies mobilized, many were arrested, and great monetary expense incurred for

the parties involved.

While the cause and effect relationship of the deaths and illnesses will likely remain

unproved, only a fool would claim that these events would have happened if Formosa

Plastics Group (FPG) had taken responsibility for their own wastes at home rather

than dump them on an unsuspecting nation.

Today, the toxic waste has been returned to Taiwan, persons have been arrested, and

all is normal again along the white beaches of Sihanoukville. Newspapers now report

on other troubles and life in Cambodia goes on.

But if Cambodians are at all numbed into forgetting the occurrence at Sihanoukville,

or are tempted to dismiss it as an anomalous, one-time event, they do so at their

own peril.

After all, the economic logic is impeccable. And the toxic waste mountains around

the world are growing - particularly in Asia.

Indeed the repetition of this unwanted free trade in hazardous wastes to the shores

of Cambodia should be considered inevitable unless Cambodians take the necessary

steps to minimize the opportunities that might be available to unscrupulous waste


Cambodia has already taken one of these steps, but two steps are necessary:

First, Cambodia must ban the import of all hazardous wastes into the territory of

Cambodia. We understand that a solid waste sub-decree has just been signed that accomplishes


We applaud the passage of this sub-decree and hope that it provides for no exceptions

and has sufficient "teeth" in stiff penalties for those caught profiting

from the import of toxic wastes.

Second, Cambodia must now accede to the Basel Convention and ratify the Basel Ban

Ammendment to that Convention, which bans all exports of hazardous wastes from the

29 richest, most highly industrialized countries - the member states of the Organization

of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), to the rest of the world.

After all, the Basel Convention is the global response to Mr. Summers' "impeccable

logic." The Basel Convention applies legal constraints to contain the obvious

abuses inherent in a free trade in hazardous wastes.

Already the Basel Convention has over 120 members. Remaining non-member countries

like Cambodia are in the clear minority and will be seen as targets by waste traffickers.

The Basel Ban Amendment which dramatically strengthened the Basel Convention by placing

the burden for prevention on the countries which produce the vast majority of the

world's toxic waste, will go into the force of international law after it receives

the necessary 62 ratifications.

Cambodia's ratification will not only hasten this process but will send a signal

to the entire world that Cambodia is off-limits and is serious about cooperating

to end this global scourge.

The advantages of joining the Basel Convention and Ban are compelling and include:

* Once the Basel Ban Amendment enters into force, the OECD countries, which

produce an estimated 90% of the global load of toxic waste will be forbidden from

exporting their wastes to Cambodia and all other non-OECD countries. Cambodia's ratification

will hasten this process.

* By becoming a Party to the Basel Convention, non-Party states such as Taiwan

will be forbidden by international law from trading their wastes with Party States

(such as Cambodia).

* All Basel Parties will be required to recognize Cambodia's import ban, and

forbid export of hazardous wastes to Cambodia.

* The Basel Convention obligates all Parties to consider illegal traffic in

hazardous wastes a criminal offence. As such it will in most cases be punishable

by jail time rather than mere fines.

* The Basel Convention is in the process of adopting a special protocol on

liability and compensation which will ensure that in the future, companies such as

FPG will be liable for their illegal dumping and be forced to pay compensation to

the victims and country of Cambodia.

Cambodia will be eligible for technical assistance regarding domestically produced

hazardous wastes as well as training for customs officials to identify hazardous

waste cargo, from the regional cleaner production centers of the Basel Convention.

Cambodia can ill afford to indulge in wishfully thinking that the Sihanoukville crisis

was an anomaly. As was stated by T.J. Wu of the Green Formosa Front in Taiwan, "I

think this situation will happen again in Cambodia, Burma, Laos, Vietnam." And

her statement refers to the stockpiles of Taiwanese hazardous wastes alone.

When one realizes that Taiwan is but one of over 30 heavily industrialized countries

with a huge economic incentive to export their problems rather than solve them at

home, it becomes obvious that without safeguards, Cambodia will surely be victimized

again and again. For that reason the Cambodian Parliament must move now to ratify

the Basel Convention and the Basel Ban Amendment.

As horrible as the Sihanoukville dumping tragedy has been, the greater tragedy would

be a lesson unlearned - a country's failure to take the simple, practical steps to

counter the "impeccable logic" of the toxic waste trade and say "never



  • Municipal hall releases map detailing colour coded Covid risks by commune

    Phnom Penh municipal governor Khuong Sreng released an official map detailing the red, yellow and dark yellow zones within the city under the new lockdown orders for Phnom Penh announced on April 26. The designation of red, dark yellow and yellow corresponds to areas with high,

  • Inter-provincial travel ban lifted; Phnom Penh and Takmao not exempted

    The government on April 25 decided to lift the inter-provincial travel ban and the closure of tourist attractions across the country, effectively immediately. The travel ban and closures of all resorts were imposed on April 6 and 17 respectively in a bid to curb the spread of Covid-19,

  • Phnom Penh unveils rules for post-lockdown transition

    The Phnom Penh Municipal Administration issued a set of detailed guidelines for the seven days to May 12 after the capital emerges from lockdown at the onset of May 6. In the 14-page document signed by municipal governor Khuong Sreng released on the evening of May 5, the

  • Phnom Penh, Takmao lockdown extended for another week

    The government late on April 26 announced an extension of lockdown in Phnom Penh and adjacent Takmao town in Kandal province for another seven days – or longer if residents do not comply with Covid-19 preventive measures and the community outbreak does not subside – until May 5. According

  • Gov't mulls extension of Phnom Penh, Takmao lockdown

    The Inter-ministerial National Commission for the Control and Enforcement of Lockdown held a video conference meeting on April 25 to review a draft document on the extension of lockdown in Phnom Penh and adjacent Kandal province’s Takmao town. The meeting was chaired by Minister of

  • Gov’t issues guidelines as lockdown nears end

    The government has issued a five-page set of instructions to be enforced when the three-week lockdown of Phnom Penh and adjacent Takmao town in Kandal province ends on May 6. According to an announcement signed by Prime Minister Hun Sen on May 4, the instructions cover a