Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Buddhist nuns face uphill battle for recognition

Buddhist nuns face uphill battle for recognition

Buddhist nuns face uphill battle for recognition

For a nun to achieve equal status with a monk she must be ordained a ëBhikkhunií by another Bhikkhuni, but there are none in Cambodia, and prejudice against ordaining women is deeply ingrained.

Millions of women across the world will unite on March 8 to celebrate International

Women's Day. Cambodia too will be in full swing, with myriad events bringing women

onto the streets to champion their cause and keep the torch burning for gender equality.

But 78-year-old Soun Sommet, one of the country's forgotten women, will not be joining

them. Nearly everyone in her family was killed by the Khmer Rouge. With nobody to

provide for her and no income in her old age, Sommet had little choice but to look

elsewhere for the support she needed to survive. In 1980, she became a nun at Phnom

Penh's Wat Lanka.

Propping up her tiny, frail body on a small bed in her living quarters, the temple's

head nun explains why she and the white-robed women around her gave up their everyday

lives to devote themselves to serving Buddha.

"The people who come here are the people who suffer in life," she whispers.

"Women come here to prepare to die. They want to ask for peace from the Buddha.

"Seven of my children and my husband died during the Pol Pot regime. I have

no one to look after me. The children I had left were very poor so I did not want

to put the burden on them."

Seventy-three year old nun Soam Keuon tells a similar story.

"I came here because life is not stable and I have no children," she explains.

"The only thing I can depend on is Buddha."

Sommet and Keuon are typical of nuns in Cambodia - they are commonly over 50 with

neither husband nor children to support them. They constitute one of the most marginalized


Shunned by society and stuck in a subservient role in a rigid religious hierarchy,

nuns face an uphill battle for recognition in the male-dominated environment of the

Buddhist temple.

Thida Khus, executive director at capacity building NGO Silaka, says the problems

run deeper than simply a dearth of social support structures for the elderly.

"Society believes that women do not have a role as spiritual leaders,"

she explains. "[Women] are expected to cook, to be the household person, to

help in the temple, not to get involved in spiritual affairs ... A lot more needs

to be done, but we face tremendous problems because of social obstacles."

The lack of social support means that domestic violence and problems in the home

are important factors driving women to a life in the monastery.

"For nuns right now, the majority seek refuge, need shelter, seek protection

from abuse, problems at home," says Khus. "Very few would seek it because

of a spiritual nature."

The traditional belief is that older women join the monastery to remove the burden

of care from their children. A young woman would only take the vows if she had disgraced

her family.

"Society thinks that [young women] join the temple if they have a love affair,"

says Khus. "It is a disappointment with life and not because of the wish to

be spiritual."

For decades, this perception that only the aged, desolate and disgraced become nuns

has deterred young women from donning the white robes and committing themselves to

the nunhood, says Peou Vanna, project coordinator for Association of Nuns and Lay

Women of Cambodia (ANLWC).

"The culture of Cambodia said that if women had love problems they went into

the monastery," she says. "It is not true. This culture affects our ladies

and girls and they are afraid to be ordained."

It is not just social stigmas that prevent young women from following a spiritual

path. Practical barriers such as lack of access to education, and expectations to

follow the more conventional path of wife and mother are holding back young women

who might otherwise seek a religious life.

Dr Hema Goonatilake is the country director of the Heinrich Boell Foundation, a German

political organization linked to that country's Green Party. A Buddhist scholar,

Dr Goonatilake has been working with ANLWC since 1996.

"Conditioning is such that born a woman you have to become a wife and a mother,"

she explains. "In Cambodia they became nuns only in old age after they had finished

their duties as a wife and a mother."

Ingrained prejudice within the Buddhist religion also holds women back.

"Buddhism only recognizes educated people," she explains. "You have

to read and write, it is the main requirement. It is a very elitist religion."

The disparity between education rates for boys and girls bears witness to part of

the problem. Only 5 percent of girls make it to upper-secondary education. Less then

half of the country's women can read and write.

Many young men gain their education by joining the monkhood and taking advantage

of the schooling offered at pagodas; such opportunities simply do not exist for young


Another impediment for girls attending higher education is the lack of facilities

near their homes. Boys can stay at the numerous monasteries while they study, but

girls have a choice of only two nunneries.

"To be born a girl means we are weak in strength," says Wat Langka's Soun

Sommet. "As a woman we are not only weak in physical strength, but we do not

get access to knowledge."

Soun Sommet, 78: ìAs a woman we are not only weak in physical strength, but we do not get access to knowledge.î

But Dr Goonatilake says things are looking up: not long ago nuns were considered

mere 'temple-slaves', their main duty being first and foremost to fulfill the wishes

of the monks.

"They always played a sub-servient role," Dr Goonatilake explains. "They

were maids of the monks. They had no time to develop their own spiritual needs, they

were always sweeping and cleaning."

But with the formation of ANLWC in 1996, the NGO's 10,000 members in 14 provinces

have taken the initiative to prove their capabilities and raise their standing in

the community, while helping others to combat social ills.

"Before the association was established they came to the temple and just served

the monks," says ANLWC's Peou Vanna. "Now they know the value of their

role in society. They have empowerment. They have equality in society."

The NGO's main initiative is its 'training of trainers' program.

"We select nuns and train then at a center in Udong four times a year,"

says Vanna. "After training they return to their provinces.

"The subjects are para-legal training, peace building, conflict resolution,

HIV prevention, domestic violence, trauma counseling ... through the nuns we can

provide training to other women."

The Heinrich Boell Foundation helps to fund the initiative, which Dr Goonatilake

describes as "small but beautiful".

"The beauty of the project is that here is a whole community of mature women

whose lives are so full so they could share their experiences and knowledge with

others," she says. "They have experience of life. They get training and

then they share their knowledge."

The past three years has also seen an encouraging rise in the number of young women

becoming nuns, says Dr Goonatilake. She attributes this to a variety of social trends,

such as the difficulties women have in finding a husband and heightened awareness

of gender issues.

"More and more educated women are entering the monastery," she says. "They

are not married, they don't have children, just a spiritual calling."

Despite this progress, it is unlikely that nuns will ever be regarded in the same

light as monks, say those working in the field, as prejudice runs through all aspects

of Buddhism in Cambodia.

In order to reach equal status with monks, a position known as Bhikkhuni, a nun needs

to be ordained by another who has already become a Bhikkhuni. There is no such nun

in Cambodia, creating a Catch-22 situation.

Because of this, nuns are not believed to wield the same power as fully ordained

monks, and are consequently not invited to attend events that would give them much-needed


"The monks all live off the temple support," says Silaka's Khus. "They

are able to raise money to support their family. Monks are invited to events, to

bless at funerals, at weddings. But nuns are not."

And although this situation is slowly changing - since the formation of ANLWC nuns

have gradually eked out a more accepted role in society - the country still has a

long way to go until the nuns obtain any real recognition.

"They don't have formal status in the religious hierarchy," says Dr Goonatilake.

"[Ordained nuns] will never happen in Cambodia. They are not ready for that.

Not in our lifetime."



  • Cambodia unveils new quarantine regulations

    The government has modified Covid-19 quarantine requirements, shortening the duration for, among others, Cambodian officials, foreign diplomats and delegations, investors and inbound travellers in general. According to an official notice signed by Minister of Health Mam Bun Heng late on October 16, quarantine length for Cambodian

  • Cambodia sets new Covid-19 quarantine rules

    The government has modified Covid-19 quarantine requirements, shortening the duration for, among others, Cambodian officials, foreign diplomats and delegations, investors and inbound travellers in general. According to an official notice signed by Minister of Health Mam Bun Heng late on October 16, quarantine length for Cambodian

  • Hun Sen: Cambodia set to fully reopen

    Prime Minister Hun Sen concludes that the October 5-7 Pchum Ben public holiday, during which many people either flocked to their hometowns for family reunion or gathered at tourist attractions across the country, has not caused an outbreak of Covid-19. In a special address to

  • Will Evergrande change the way Chinese developers do business in Cambodia?

    China’s property sector policy has exposed the grim financial condition of real estate developers including those operating in Cambodia, which raises questions over the viability of their projects and business going forward The dark blue netting draping over one of Yuetai Group Co Ltd’

  • Cambodia resumes issuance of tourist visas

    The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation has announced the resumption of its tourist visa and visa exemption programme after a long hiatus due to the Covid-19 pandemic. In a letter dated October 20 and addressed to foreign embassies and consulates, foreign minister Prak Sokhonn

  • S’ville set to turn into ‘second Shenzhen’

    The Ministry of Economy and Finance has awarded a master plan consultancy contract to top Chinese institute for the development and transformation of Preah Sihanouk province into a “Model Multi-Purpose Special Economic Zone”, Southeast Asia’s next logistics and resort hub and innovation centre. The