Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Caught in the crossfire

Caught in the crossfire

Caught in the crossfire

General Un Sokunthea found herself in the middle of an international row in December.

The "rescue" of 84 girls working as karaoke and massage hostesses at Chhai

Hour II hotel was followed by a dramatic breakout a day later, assisted by a mob

from outside.

Sokunthea, the head of the government's Department of Anti-Human Trafficking and

Juvenile Protection, was officially warned by her superiors for conducting the initial

raid, prompting the United States Embassy and others to leap to her defense. She

spoke to Liam Cochrane on February 17 about a variety of issues.

Post: In April last year, you were very optimistic about the role of this department

in the fight against human trafficking. In 2004, how many raids occurred and how

many arrests?

Sokunthea: There were 393 cases that we took action on in 2004; 53 cases of sexual

transactions, 276 cases of rape against children, 31 cases of human trafficking and

22 cases of pornography. The figure of perpetrators who were arrested in 2004 increased

a small amount because in 2004 we [had] 5 cases [involving people] to be put in prison.

Seven perpetrators were put in prison last year. I would like to add that the number

of perpetrators increased [by] 173 perpetrators comparing to 2003; and we helped

and freed 552 victims [which] comparing to 2003, is an increase of 136 victims. So

the number of perpetrators and the number of victims increased because of the intervention

of police crackdowns.

Post: I understand that the condition of this interview is that I don't ask about

the Chhay Hour II case, but following that incident you were given a stern warning

from your boss and head of national police, Hok Lundy. How secure is your position


Sokunthea: If I don't speak, as you can see, I am still sitting here. I still lead

the work here so if I don't say anything, you can see for yourself.

Post: When will the inter-ministerial report on the ChhayHour II case be released?

Sokunthea: I don't know either because I am not the one on the committee.

Post: Do you think the findings will be free from political interference?

Sokunthea: I don't know what to say because I don't know who is the boss of the committee.

Post: After the controversy of this case amongst the international community, what

will the future hold for anti-trafficking efforts in Cambodia?

Sokunthea: This issue is bigger than the tsunami; it surprised the world even though

it didn't kill any human beings. My department has so far intervened in three cases

in cooperation with IJM [International Justice Mission] to have two perpetrators

put in prison and 42 charged.

Post: What lessons did you learn from the ChhayHour II case?

Sokunthea: There's a Khmer expression which says: "People make mistakes. One

should worry about those who refuse to accept [responsibility for] them and correct

their behavior. Those who do will become good persons."

Post: When the Post spoke to you in April 2004, you said, "Until now I'm very

proud to never have been accused [of corruption] by an NGO or from the public, because

since the establishment of this department there has been no corruption." Is

there corruption in the department now?

Sokunthea: Until now, we have not found anyone in the department who is corrupt.

We have just heard from the outside, but we have not yet found evidence to show someone

is corrupt. I ask that you get back to me if you know anything, because you are journalist,

so you may know more than us. Please inform us because in getting rid of corruption,

not only us but also journalists can participate. After establishing the department,

we already told you once that we are making efforts to overcome all difficulties

including being accused of having someone taking money. I try to educate and advise

the officers. Now, I believe we have some but the number is small.

Post: What would you do if you found out about corruption within the department?

Sokunthea: I would like to tell you that we have regulations in the police force.

The regulations of the police force include identifying those involved, suspensions,

and dismissals.

Post: At about 2 p.m. on September 3 last year, police from your department conducted

a simultaneous raid on four karaoke shops in Kampong Speu. The police accused them

of selling sex and arrested the owners and staff, taking them to your headquarters

in Phnom Penh that evening. Some girls were released after allegedly giving police

their jewelry, others were sent to Afesip. The owners were each asked to pay approximately

$3,000 to your police or else their businesses would be closed down. At least 20

police officers were directly involved and the bribery occurred in this building.

What do you know about this?

Sokunthea: I would like to thank you for telling me about this. If you tell me, you

are my good partner.

Post: Twenty officers would account for more than 10 percent of your department.

What do you know about this case?

Sokunthea: The issue in Kampong Speu, I have heard about it and I also worked on

it. The police who received orders [to conduct the raid] included provincial police

and our departmental police. You say there were 20 police, it may be more than that

in the operation. I order that all cases be sent to the court. So the case has been

sent to Kampong Speu court. I am also investigating this problem and I also educated

[police officers] once already. I also heard that some police took money but not

as much as $3,000.

Post: Where did you hear about this?

Sokunthea: I just heard someone tell me about that and after hearing about it I called

the police who were directly involved in the case, to ask whether it was true or

not. If it is true, I will submit a report to the top level.

Post: What sort of report?

Sokunthea: It's not necessary for me to tell you about our investigation. But I would

like to tell you that I also heard the same as you and have not found any evidence

yet, so I have my force investigating the case [to decide] whether it is true or

not, and what level [the alleged corruption] is at.

Post: Who is in charge of this investigation?

Sokunthea: I don't want to mention any details.

Post: Before this raid, undercover officers went into each karaoke shop to try to

find evidence. One police officer reportedly had sex with a woman, then arrested

her and took her to Phnom Penh with everyone else. Once inside your department's

headquarters, he allegedly paid this woman $20 for the sex. Is this standard police


Sokunthea: Even when journalists get information from somewhere, they also may operate

under another guise. I would like to ask you as a journalist: if you want the facts,

what do you do?

Post: Well, if I was writing a story about prostitution, I don't think it's necessary

to sleep with a prostitute. It's a question of ethics. Is this acceptable ethics

in this department?

Sokunthea: The investigation [techniques] of police are the same in every country.

But sometimes some investigators go too far. For that, I do not know.

Post: Were did you work before taking this position?

Sokunthea: I was the deputy chief of the department of economic and financial planning

[within the Ministry of Interior] before I came here. I have a Bachelors degree in


Post: Did you also work for the Cambodian Red Cross?

Sokunthea: I would like to tell you that I am a member of the board of directors

of the Red Cross of which [the Prime Minister's wife] Bun Rany Hun Sen is the president.

Post: What is your relationship with Bun Rany?

Sokunthea: In the committee, all relationships are concentrated on serving human

needs. I would like to tell you a little bit about Bun Rany Hun Sen. Even though

she is the prime minister's wife, she works on everything to serve humanity and she

always stays close to natural disaster victims.

Post: Do you mean close physically or in her heart, to victims of disaster?

Sokunthea: If I talk about her good actions, you might think that I am on her side

as my president. I believe that you may know yourselves as a journalist that all

her actions show that she always stays close with her citizens. I would like to tell

you that everyday I wish all Cambodian women had the mind and will of Bun Rany Hun

Sen because she is a good mother, sister and a good family leader.

(Translation by Sam Rith)


  • Diplomatic passports issued to foreigners to be annulled

    The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation will move to annul diplomatic passports issued to those not born in Cambodia. Analysts say the move may be in relation to reports that former Thai prime minister Yingluck Shinawatra used a Cambodian passport to register as

  • Hun Sen warns Irish MP of EBA ‘mistake’

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on Saturday told former Irish premier Enda Kenny, still a member of the EU nation’s parliament, that the 28-nation bloc should not make a “third mistake” regarding Cambodia by using the preferential Everything But Arms (EBA) agreement to “take 16 million

  • The hairy little heroes saving many lives in rural Cambodia

    IN RURAL Siem Reap province, rats dare to tread where no person will, as these hairy little heroes place their lives on the line each day for the good of the local community. The rodents are the most important members of a special team, leading

  • PM warns EU and opposition on 34th anniversary of his rule

    HUN Sen reached the milestone of 34 years as Cambodian prime minister on Monday and used the groundbreaking ceremony for a new ring road around Phnom Penh to tell the international community that putting sanctions on the Kingdom meant killing the opposition. “Please don’t forget