Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Chorus of criticism follows Prince's trial

Chorus of criticism follows Prince's trial

Chorus of criticism follows Prince's trial

NUMEROUS legal observers have criticized Prince Norodom Ranariddh's conviction as

part of a "show trial" and a "politicized farce".

Neither Ranariddh nor his co-defendants Nhek Bun Chhay and Thach Suong were represented

in their absence.

Resistance commander Bun Chhay said a trip to Phnom Penh would be more dangerous

than staying on the malaria-ridden battlefields of O'Smach.

The fact that the trial was held at a building in the Ministry of Defense, rather

than at the military court house "brought to mind the words show trial",

according to one Western legal observer, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

"It wasn't a fair trial. I don't think anyone expected it to be," said

one rights worker. "The interesting thing is that they wanted the world to witness

an unfair judicial procedure."

He said that many within the international community had accepted from the beginning

that Ranariddh should be tried, convicted and pardoned.

"The fundamental right to be presumed innocent until proven otherwise was conspicuous

only by its absence...

"The lamentable weaknesses of Cambodia's judicial system are well known. This

situation is not going to improve if people simply accept that every judicial proceeding

is simply something to be got through then ignored."

Many pointed out that those implicated in serious rights violations - such as grenade

attacks and executions - are never brought to court.

"The only trials which proceed promptly are those for which there is a political

agenda. It is one more example among many of the lack of judicial independence. What

kind of message does this send to the Cambodian people?"

Kingdom of Cambodia Bar Association President Say Bory said: "You know yourself

that it is all prepared.... I don't think there will be any surprises."

Bory, who represented Rana-riddh's half-uncle, Prince Norodom Sirivudh in a similar

1996 trial that was also labeled a "politically-motivated farce", was one

of many who suggested that a conviction was certain before the trial even began.

Others said they expect a similar conviction at the Prince's next court date March


Bory refused the military court when it asked him to designate one of his lawyers

to defend the Prince. "The Prince specifically said he did not want one,"

he said.

Other legal observers said that the judges seemed to come to conclusions that did

not seem certain given the evidence.

No evidence was given that the prince actually bought the weapons or that he personally

transported them into Cambodia, nor that he moved them once in Cambodia, said one

foreign lawyer.

"Technically, [Ranariddh] is innocent. They all are," he said. "From

a legal standpoint, the evidence does not correlate with the charges and with the

conviction. They were convicted of buying and transporting illegal weapons. I didn't

hear anything that established that they bought these weapons in Cambodia. I didn't

hear anything that established that they were involved in transporting...weapons

to [Sihan-oukville].

"Those movements were all authorized [after the initial seizure].

"The only unauthorized movement were the weapons moving in Cambodian waters,"

he said of the weapons which originated in Poland.

"They weren't doing it themselves.... These are legal technicalities but this

is the law. The law doesn't prohibit implication."

He also noted the intimidating presence of Gendarmes and other military officials

in the court room. "You saw all those beige shirts there. I believe they did

not choose to be there. They were ordered to be there."

Testimony from the most anticipated witness - Ranariddh's former military adviser,

General Tum Sambol, who was absent with the judge's permission - came in written


Observers said it was impossible to know whether Sambol - who reportedly lived in

Ranariddh's residence for several months after the fighting - had actually written

the letter himself, or what might have convinced him to testify against his former


Bory - who says he received death threats on the eve of the Sirivudh trial in which

he did not put up a defense - said: "We can imagine all kinds of things. We

don't know what kind of testimony there might be. When there is a total absence of

defense, they can do what they want.

"If you think there is a chance that the court will be fair, you defend [but]

the Prince would know. If he says it isn't fair, why should he take part?"

Sambol - who was alternately rumored to have moved to the CPP's side on July 7 after

his life was threatened, or to have been a CPP-mole for many months before the July

coup - could not be reached abroad in Australia, but was expected to return to Cambodia

before the next trial.

His letter read, in part: "On May 25 I was ordered by [Prince] Ranariddh to

go to Sihanoukville port with General Nhek Bun Chhay to pick up weapons. On May 26,

Nhek Bun Chhay and I went to Sihanoukville by chopper. At that time all the military

equipment was being examined by the mixed inspection committee... After the negotiations,

the military equipment was sent to Phnom Penh."

An undisclosed number of the 78 crates of weapons - reportedly ordered from Poland

on Feb 3, 1997 - were later turned over to Bun Chhay after he came to an agreement

with the co-Defense Ministers to hold onto, but not use, the guns, Ney Thol said.

When the fighting erupted in July, many of the weapons were purportedly taken into

battle by Bun Chhay's forces.

Bory said the real trial, that of international opinion about the court case, would

take place through the airwaves and in newspapers as the government attempted to

convince people of the Prince's guilt. "I think that the role of the media is

what is important," he said.

Khmer media had already been busy on the eve of the trial.

All six Khmer-language television stations showed videotaped footage - reportedly

on government orders - of Funcinpec troop activities in the capital in early July.

The tapes appear to have been broadcast as part of a campaign to prepare public opinion

for a verdict of guilt. TV commentators claimed the tapes were proof of Ranariddh's

conspiracy to overthrow its coalition partner, the CPP.

Members of the opposition and several diplomats, unimpressed by the footage as evidence

of the Prince's guilt, said that the showing en masse of the videotapes on the eve

of the trial only proved that the government had full control of the airwaves as

well as the courts.

Faxed statements and electronic mail transmissions from Funcinpec members around

the world, opposition leader Sam Rainsy suppporters and human rights groups flowed

into Phnom Penh to debunk the first of two trials before the Prince was convicted.

One typical Funcinpec statement denounced Hun Sen's "political games geared

toward his dictatorship", while other statements from a pre-trial media counter-offensive

included verbal attacks from as far away as Bangkok, the US, France and Australia.

Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch Asia both issued pre-trial statements

saying that the Prince would not receive a fair trial in the present political climate

of harassment and murder.


  • PM imposes nationwide Covid restrictions, curfew over Delta scare

    Prime Minister Hun Sen late on July 28 instructed the municipal and provincial authorities nationwide to strictly enforce Covid-19 measures including curfew for two weeks from July 29 midnight through August 12 to stem the new coronavirus Delta variant. The instruction came shortly after he issued a directive

  • Two luxury hotels latest quarantine options for inbound travellers

    The Inter-Ministerial Committee to Combat Covid-19 has designated two luxury hotels as alternative quarantine options for travellers who wish to enter Cambodia through Phnom Penh International Airport – Sokha Phnom Penh Hotel & Residence and the Courtyard by Marriott Phnom Penh. In a notice detailing guidelines issued

  • Provinces on Thai borders put in lockdown amid Delta fears

    The government has decided to place several border provinces in lockdown for two weeks in a bid to prevent the new coronavirus Delta variant spreading further into community. According a directive signed by Prime Minister Hun Sen late on July 28, the provinces include Koh Kong,

  • Delta spreading in Kingdom

    Cambodia has so far detected more than 200 cases of the highly contagious coronavirus Delta variant, with 109 found on July 31 and August 1. The Ministry of Health has expressed deep concerns that the variant may have already reached communities and be spreading as some of the cases

  • China denies Mekong hacking

    As the US and its allies joined hands last week to expose what they allege to be China’s Ministry of State Security’s malicious cyber activities around the world, the attention also turned to Cambodia with the US Department of Justice claiming that four

  • US' Johnson & Johnson Covid-19 vaccines arrive

    The first batch of 455,000 doses of the Johnson & Johnson Covid-19 vaccine donated by the US touched down in Phnom Penh on the morning of July 30. They are part of the total 1,060,100 doses the US has pledged to provide to Cambodia through the World Health Organisation-led (