Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Cyber bill raises concerns

Cyber bill raises concerns

An internet user reads political commentary on a website in Chamkarmon district
An internet user reads political commentary on a website in Chamkarmon district. Scott Howes

Cyber bill raises concerns

Cambodia's highly secretive draft law on cybercrime, which has never been released publicly, seeks to criminalise online content that “slanders or undermines” government agencies, ministries or officials or affects “political cohesiveness”, a copy obtained by the Post reveals.

The law, which was first announced in May 2012 to the trepidation of many netizens, is supposed to be passed this mandate. But the government has thus far ignored calls from civil society groups to release a draft for consultation.

Article 19, the London-based freedom-of-expression advocacy group that obtained an English-language version of the draft law, said that it falls “well below international standards” on freedom of expression, information and privacy, and if passed could see “Cambodia’s currently free online space [backsliding] into the country’s deep-seated culture of secrecy and self-censorship”.

Article 28 of the 16-page draft law, labelled “draft V.1” and developed by the Cybercrime Law Formulation Working Group of the Council of Ministers, stipulates offences related to online content and publications.

It proposes criminalising content that is deemed to “hinder the sovereignty and integrity” of Cambodia; publications that “incite or instigate the general population that could cause one or many to generate anarchism”; publications that “generate insecurity, instability, and [affect] political cohesiveness”; and any publication deemed “to be non-factual which slanders or [undermines] the integrity of any government agencies [or] ministries”.

All these offences are punishable with one to three years in prison and a fine of between two million and six million riel ($500 to $1,500), the draft law stipulates.

More than four million Cambodians were using the internet, including on mobile telephones, as of December 2013, according to government data, an increase from 2.7 million in late 2012.

“The Draft Cybercrime Law has been formulated behind closed doors for far too long. With a version of the Draft Law released, the authorities can no longer deflect the legitimate concerns of the national and international human rights community,” Thomas Hughes, Article 19’s executive director, said in a statement.

The provisions in Article 28 of the draft law, which also address “publications deemed damaging to the moral and cultural values of society”, need to be entirely removed, because they are “extremely vague and open to abuse”, the group said.

Council of Ministers spokesman Phay Siphan yesterday said he would not comment on an “unofficial document” in order to avoid “manipulating anything”.

“Once they pass it, after it’s been reviewed in the Council of Ministers and passed by the cabinet and then sent down to the National Assembly, then we can talk,” he said. “You remember this is an illegal document. So [we] don’t touch it until it comes up.… It is government property [and] it’s not official yet.… It’s a problem if people leaked this to you. It’s not supposed to be leaked to anyone.”

Siphan added, however, that a number of offences listed in the draft cyber law were based on existing offences in the criminal code.

When the law was announced in May 2012, Council of Ministers spokesman Ek Tha said it would be designed to “prevent any ill-willed people or bad-mood people from spreading false information [and] groundless information”.

Minister for Information Khieu Kanharith has stated several times, including in February, that despite social media being “complex” for the government to deal with, there were no plans to restrict access.

He did not respond to requests for comment yesterday.

Chem Sangva, director of the inspection department at the Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications, referred questions to Minister Prak Sokhon, who could not be reached.

The provisions in the draft law were “extremely worrying” for freedom of expression, Cambodian Center for Human Rights executive director Chak Sopheap said yesterday.

“It’s not hard to imagine how terms such as ‘political cohesiveness’ may be used to silence anyone who disagrees with the government and ruling party, and stand directly against the constitutional guarantees of free speech,” she said.

The draft law, if passed, would see the establishment of a National Anti-Cybercrime Committee, with senior officials from its general secretariat given judicial police powers to investigate and make arrests.

Given that the committee will predominantly be made up of high-ranking government officials, “the lack of adequate definitions and preciseness in the law is especially concerning”, Sopheap said.

Aside from online content, other offences listed in the draft law include child pornography, illegal access to systems – which encompasses hacking, data theft and espionage – and computer-related fraud.

The past year has seen a surge in cyberattacks in the Kingdom, with Anonymous Cambodia, the local chapter of the global “hacktivist” collective, defacing several government websites following the July election.

According to Article 19, some penalties under the draft cyber law are harsher than their criminal code equivalents.

“Offences conducted online should not carry heavier penalties than that of crimes conducted offline,” the group said in its statement.

It also notes that prosecutors are “granted extremely broad powers to order the preservation of computer data or traffic data” from internet service providers under the draft law, which is “very worrying given the intrusive nature of such measures and that prosecutors lack the independence necessary for the proper balancing of the various interests involved”.

Included in its provision for content deemed damaging to moral and cultural values, the draft cyber law states that any “drawings, pictorials, or pixilation that [are] deemed to slander or defame human beings or commoners of the state performing activities unbecoming, with animals of any species” are punishable with imprisonment and heavy fines.

“[Members of the government] are angry with [people who insult them online],” lawyer Sok Sam Oeun, head of the Cambodian Defenders Project, said.

“In our society, they don’t like mocking; you can see in the Press Law it’s also the same. We cannot use cartoons for example, so now, mostly people from outside [the country] do that.”

A number of overseas-based pro-opposition blogs and websites that often contain commentary ridiculing senior Cambodian People’s Party figures and lambasting political influence from Vietnam in derogatory terms have been occasionally targeted by the government in recent years.

Perhaps in line with this, the draft law stipulates clearly that its scope includes offences committed outside Cambodia that affect individuals within Cambodia and the “interests” of the Kingdom.

Prominent blogger and social media consultant Kounila Keo yesterday said the “sinister ambiguity of provisions” in the draft law relating to online content would “create a chilling effect for freedom of speech and expression” if they remain when the law passes.

“If there is any truth to the provisions that [I have seen], we are clearly heading on the path towards increasing government control over thought and speech,” she said.



  • Companies listed on CSX receive 50% deduction on income tax

    Tax incentives are granted to companies that have listed their shares or issued debt securities on the Cambodia Securities Exchange (CSX), whether they are small to medium-sized enterprises or large companies. The nine stock listed companies on the CSX – with seven listed on the Main

  • Siem Reap drain canal now ‘mangrove’ promenade

    A more than half a kilometre long stretch of canal in Siem Reap has been covered and turned into a promenade to attract visitors, said Ly Rasmey, secretary of state at the Ministry of Land Management, Urban Planning and Construction, on September 16. The new pedestrianised

  • Cambodia mourns over UK’s Queen Elizabeth II

    Cambodia has joined other nations around the world to mourn the passing of Queen Elizabeth II, with King Norodom Sihanomi, Prime Minister Hun Sen and National Assembly president Heng Samrin extending their condolences in separate letters. In his letter to the late Queen’s son –

  • Final verdicts for Khmer Rouge leaders ‘vital’ for next generation

    Nearly a decade after the commencement of Case 002/02 against Khieu Samphan back in 2014, the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC) is now set to deliver its final verdict for the former Khmer Rouge head of state. The Supreme Court Chamber of the ECCC,

  • Angkor wildlife, aquarium park still to open October

    The Angkor Wildlife and Aquarium complex about 30km southeast of Siem Reap town with initial total investment of more than $70 million is reportedly still on track for an end-October opening. The park is located on a 100ha plot along National Road 6 in Kbon village, Khchas

  • Railway project studies proceed

    The transport ministry is exploring options to expedite preliminary studies on key public railway infrastructure projects, especially the conversion of the Northern Railway Line that links to Thailand into high-speed rail. Railway freight and passenger transportation has been pinpointed as a major potential engine of