Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Death and the Communist Party

Death and the Communist Party

Death and the Communist Party

death.jpg
death.jpg

Stephen Morris: "Mass killing is the history of Communism. People were killed for their class position but also to set an example - kill some to discourage the rest; create a state of fear and obedience to the regime. You do have cases of racism in Communism - the Chams - it is a normal part of extreme communism. In North Korea, if you're caught with a Bible then you are executed, but that's not genocide."

A Western scholar who studied the archives of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union,

author Stephen Morris frames the "genocide" debate in a larger historical

context.

Rarely does Cambodia get a mention in the international media without a few stock

phrases about Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge "genocide."

For academic Stephen Morris, author of Why Vietnam Invaded Cambodia, published in

1999, the prevalence of the term genocide "reflects the fact that Vietnam initiated

and maintained control of the debate over the Khmer Rouge," he says. In the

1980s Morris visited the Khmer Rouge zones of Cambodia where he met many of the senior

KR figures, including Ieng Sary, who now face charges in the KR tribunal.

During the 1990s Morris gained access to the archives of the Communist Party of the

Soviet Union, becoming the only western scholar to read secret Russian-language documents

concerning the history of Vietnamese Communism, the American intervention in Vietnam

and the eventual Vietnamese invasion of Cambodia that ousted the Khmer Rouge. Morris'

work attempts to examine the Cambodian experience in light of international Communist

history.

Back in Cambodia recently to research a new book, Morris spoke to the Post's Cat

Barton about Vietnam, Cambodia, and Pol Pot's psychology.

Does Democratic Kampuchea have to be seen in light of international Communist

history to be understood?

It was a totalitarian state, like Nazism, the Taliban, and various Communist regimes,

which are the most common way this has manifested. I have written about Vietnam's

ambitions to Cambodia. Vietnam did have and always had ambitions regarding Cambodia,

but evidence suggests that they were not trying to subvert the regime. Pol Pot had

paranoid personality disorder - all great Communist leaders have this. There are

two key points on this: first, the relevant political culture is inherently paranoid;

second, all tyrants feel they are attached to this system. Some people who are attracted

to regimes or movements are already disturbed personalities: Kim Il Sung, Stalin

and Mao. Or tyranny can result from personality disorders - like Pol Pot. You can

find examples of the phenomenon in the Communist world. Stalin and Mao felt they

were always in a state of disturbance and fear, always looking for secret enemies.

How was Democratic Kampuchea similar to these other regimes?

During Stalin's great terror a famous slogan was, "The mark of a good Communist

is his ability to unmask the class enemy, no matter how well he may be hidden."

This was the guiding principle for denunciation in Stalin's society at the height

of the terror. This was how innocent people got denounced for anything. What we saw

in Stalinist Russia and China during the 1950s and 1960s under Mao's personalized

tyranny was repeated in a condensed form and time period in Cambodia under the Khmer

Rouge. It was not just condensed because the regime had less time - they didn't know

that would be the case - but the speed they moved at was unprecedented. They wanted

to show they were purer Communists - partly as they were frightened that if they

didn't implement a system of total domination as soon as possible they would be overthrown.

How important is Vietnam in terms of understanding Cambodian Communism?

Cambodia had an inferiority complex regarding their big powerful neighbor who had

exploited them for centuries. Politically conscious Cambodians, especially Communists,

had a bad dose of this. It came from their experience of dealing with Vietnam. Pre-1970

the Khmer Rouge was isolated. Pol Pot and his group were not anti-Vietnamese before

1970. From late 1971 the Khmer Rouge decided Vietnam was the main enemy. This was

not objectively true; the Khmer Rouge was weak. Their prospects of gaining power

rested on help from the Vietnamese. They couldn't have done it alone. The Khmer Rouge

depended on North Vietnam during 1970 to 1972.

What do you think about the use of the term "genocide" ?

The Vietnamese initiated the use of genocide in 1978 - no one had ever used it before

them. The term was embraced by the supporters of Hanoi. In the political culture

of the West the use of this term spread. But no one thought about it, they equated

"horrible thing" with genocide. But not everything horrible is genocide.

A lot of mass killings have nothing to do with genocide. It was an attempt by the

Communists to disassociate from the Khmer Rouge to say "what happened under

the Khmer Rouge had nothing to do with Communism." But it has everything to

do with Communism - just a Cambodian version. Not every Communist regime is identical

but there are similar patterns of behavior. Fundamentally, the Khmer Rouge followed

a Stalin/Mao pattern, not a Nazi pattern. Yes, there was talk of the "Khmer

Race" but it was for motivational reasons. Why did they turn the whole kingdom

into a giant concentration camp? Mao. Thirty five million starved to death during

the "great leap forward" and what Pol Pot did was the same as Mao. Is Mao

accused of genocide? People of the far left have an interest in maintaining a separation

between the Khmer Rouge and Communism.

So what relation does mass killing have to Communism?

Mass killing is the history of Communism, people were killed for their class position,

but also to set an example: kill some to discourage the rest. Create a state of fear

and obedience to the regime. You do have cases of racism in Communism, the Chams.

It is a normal parts of extreme Communism. In North Korea, if you're caught with

a Bible then you are executed, but that's not genocide. What Pol Pot was doing followed

in the tradition of Communist history, Stalin and Mao and the Great Leader.

When did you go to Cambodia?

I went to the Khmer Rouge zones in 1983 to see Meas Muth. [son in law of notorious

KR leader Ta Mok]. I met Ieng Sary then and Keat Chhon. He was not high ranking in

the entourage.

What do you think about the Khmer Rouge Tribunal?

The government has confirmed that the tribunal can try "senior leaders and those

most responsible," but they won't get to the real killers. Duch is the only

one who's actually admitted to the killings. The others deny it. The KRT won't accept

that the whole system was rotten. They take the Vietnamese view that the Pol Pot

clique usurped power and from 1978 onwards they were denouncing the Pol Pot section

of the regime. ... At the village level there were huge atrocities. In Germany they

went to the roots of Nazism, pursued by the Israelis and other Western governments.

In Cambodia they have to find all those who massacred at the village level and district

level. But they've been defined out. Why? They still have positions of power and

influence in the country. This is a reasonable suspicion. The killers live among

us. All Western countries regard Nazi atrocities - from the top to the guy who pulled

the trigger - as guilty .... Here it is not being done. The excuse is that it will

create social instability. Western governments accept this, they don't want instability.

MOST VIEWED

  • US think tank warns of China's 'ulterior motives'

    A US think tank on Tuesday warned that spreading Chinese investment in the Indo-Pacific follows a pattern of leveraging geopolitical influence at the expense of the nations receiving investment, including Cambodia. The report looks at a sample of 15 Chinese port development projects, noting that the

  • More than three tonnes of ivory reportedly bound for Cambodia seized in Mozambique

    A total of 3.5 tonnes of ivory reportedly bound for Cambodia was seized by authorities in Mozambique late last week, according to the NGO Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES). CITES' information was based on a report from the

  • Defence Ministry denies weapons in smuggling case came from Cambodia

    After a Thai national was arrested last week for allegedly smuggling guns from Cambodia to Thailand, Cambodia's Defence Ministry has claimed the weapons seized during the arrest are not used in Cambodia, despite the fact that both types of rifle seized are commonly found in

  • Shipwreck found off coast of Koh Kong

    Royal Cambodian Navy researchers are working to identify a decades-old shipwreck found earlier this month off the coast of Koh Kong province. Divers found the 70-metre-long wreck on April 4 about a mile from Koh Chhlam island, according to Navy officials. Deputy Navy Commander Tea Sokha,