​Defenders tackle police brutality | Phnom Penh Post

Defenders tackle police brutality


Publication date
04 April 1997 | 07:00 ICT

Reporter : Imran Vittachi

More Topic

UNLESS the powers-that-be get in the way, a defenders group will take the rare step

of prosecuting Cambodian law enforcers allegedly implicated in the 1996 death of

a rice farmer in Kompong Cham.

Cambodian Defenders Project (CDP) is taking on a criminal case in which eight Kroch

Chhmar district policemen stand accused of taking part in the illegal arrest, detention,

torture and manslaughter of citizen Liv Peng Arn.

Arn, 42, died Jan 13, 1996 while in their custody. Police claim he committed suicide

in a cell.

"We believe it's a very clear case of police brutality," said Juan Pablo

Ordonez, a legal advisor with CDP. "We hope to send them the message that if

you keep abusing civil society, you will be punished for it."

Arn's widow, Chheng Kim Srean, has pressed charges against the eight and appealed

a recent judgment handed-down on one of his interrogators, police inspector Rong

Vu, who is back at work.

On Feb 24, at Kompong Cham town courthouse, Vu was given a two-year suspended sentence

and put on five-years probation for the illegal arrest and detention of Arn.

No charges of torture or manslaughter were filed by the state prosecutor who maintains

that, with no witnesses, there isn't enough evidence.

But Srean, who kept vigil outside the Kroch Chhmar police precinct in the slow hours

before her husband's death, insists she heard her husband screaming for mercy at

the hands of his interrogators.

"I could hear them beating him," she recalled. "I recognized my husband's

voice crying out: 'please, don't torture me'."

She points out that when she rushed into Arn's cell after she was told he committed

suicide by hanging himself, she found him there, his head swollen, bruised, and bleeding,

his legs still shackled to the floor.

There is also physical evidence taken from an Aug 27 inspection of Arn's exhumed

body by local authorities who were pressed by human rights agencies to act. The exhumation

revealed six broken ribs.

Srean says she is not satisfied with Vu's punishment for a misdemeanor and the 2

million riel ($727) compensation awarded to her by the court. On Mar 27, in Kompong

Cham, meeting with CDP lawyers and provincial justice officials, she made the decision

to seek posthumous justice for her husband.

To this end, CDP is planning a two-fold strategy: they will appeal the Rong Vu sentence

in Phnom Penh; and, since charges of torture and manslaughter were never filed against

Vu and the others, they will press ahead with those charges in Kompong Cham to determine

the degree to which each was involved in Arn's alleged illegal arrest, detention,

torture, and death.

"We will ask the Appeals Court in Phnom Penh to increase Vu's punishment, put

the person back in jail, and increase the compensation awarded to the plaintiff,"

Ordonez said.

CDP will build their case on forensic and testimonial evidence gathered by human

rights NGO Licadho and the UN Center for Human Rights.

According to CDP, the case hangs on proving that Arn was beaten in order to confess

to the April 1995 murder of a relative of provincial governor Hun Neng, who is the

Second Prime Minister's elder brother.

The CDP case is connected to another case currently being appealed by a separate

defenders group, Legal Aid of Cambodia (LAC).

CDP will argue that Arn was picked-up by police at a local rice-mill on Jan 11, 1996,

the morning after Sun Lai Huort, 24, was forced under police custody to confess to

having conspired with Arn in the slaying of Ms. Tun Sok Heng, 37. According to sources,

she was married to Hun Neng's cousin.

CDP alleges that when Arn was arrested police also tried to forcibly extract a confession

from him, but went too far.

LAC's appeal for Huort - condemned Aug 10 to 15 years in prison along with a medical

student who allegedly contracted the hit on Heng - has been stalled, according to

LAC sources, partly because the Kompong Cham governor has leaned on the case.

"Sok Heng's husband asked the court to postpone any decisions," a LAC defender


According to another LAC source, during the August trial in Kompong Cham, Hun Neng's

bodyguards made their presence felt at the courthouse.

So Nath, the province's Third Deputy Governor, confirmed that the slain Heng was

related to his boss, but denied that the governor's office was harassing court proceedings

in both the LAC and CDP cases.

"The governor has ordered the court to verify all reports they received about

these cases in order for [both] trials to proceed in a just way," Nath said.

"But the governor's office cannot put any pressure on the judge."

To CDP's Ordonez, the case marks a "huge policy change".

"We are now representing not only the poor, but also other powerless and disenfranchised

people who have to confront those in power."

Ordonez expects there will be stiff resistance to CDP's move. He believes justice

officials will try to blur Liv Peng Arn's alleged responsibility in the cold-blooded

death of Tun Sok Heng with Arn's allegedly being denied a fair trial.

According to Ordonez, whether Arn did conspire to kill her has no bearing on the

CDP case.

"Even if the guy is the worst murderer, even if he committed the most heinous

crime, it still is absolutely wrong to illegally arrest, detain, torture, and kill

the person," he said. "It could be Pol Pot, or it could be Nixon and Kissinger,

but still they have the right to a fair trial."

But, Ordonez conceded, the entire case rides on whether the state prosecutor finally

files charges of illegal arrest, detention, torture, and arrest against the eight


As for the prosecutor in question, Ouk Touch didn't seem convinced that CDP and their

client, Arn's widow, have much of a case.

"At the moment, we don't have sufficient evidence," Touch said. ""We

have questioned the four men who interrogated Arn, but none of them saw him being


The prosecutor conceded that Arn's broken ribs constitute strong evidence that he

was beaten.

He suggested that the possibility the dead man's relatives dug-up the corpse and

broke some bones, to alter the evidence before the August exhumation, should not

be overlooked.

Contact PhnomPenh Post for full article

Post Media Co Ltd
The Elements Condominium, Level 7
Hun Sen Boulevard

Phum Tuol Roka III
Sangkat Chak Angre Krom, Khan Meanchey
12353 Phnom Penh

Telegram: 092 555 741
Email: [email protected]