Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - EU council condemns crackdown but stops short of concrete action




EU council condemns crackdown but stops short of concrete action

Federica Mogherini, the high representative of the European Union for foreign affairs, speaks to the media yesterday before attending the EU Foreign Affairs Council meeting. European Union
Federica Mogherini, the high representative of the European Union for foreign affairs, speaks to the media yesterday before attending the EU Foreign Affairs Council meeting. European Union

EU council condemns crackdown but stops short of concrete action

The Foreign Affairs Council of the European Union yesterday adopted a set of conclusions condemning “recent worrying political developments and the continuing deterioration of democracy” in Cambodia, though some politicians expressed regret about a missed opportunity to take concrete measures.

The conclusions, passed by the European Union’s foreign affairs ministers, warn the Cambodian government that the council could consider “specific targeted measures” if the political situation does not improve.

They also demanded the release of jailed opposition leader Kem Sokha, as well as the reversal of the forced dissolution of his Cambodia National Rescue Party.

Sokha was arrested in September on charges of “treason”, despite his parliamentary immunity, based on a publicly available speech he gave several years ago in Australia in which he told supporters he had received US assistance in planning his political career. The Cambodian government has claimed the video is evidence the CNRP was fomenting a foreign-backed “revolution”.

In its conclusions, the council invites the European Commission and the EU’s high representative for foreign affairs, Federica Mogherini, to “closely monitor the situation” in Cambodia and “continue a thorough and comprehensive assessment of development cooperation programmes”.

With regards to Europe’s “Everything But Arms” agreement with Cambodia, which contains human rights clauses that can trigger a suspension of the preferential trade agreement in cases of abuse, the council “invites the Commission to enhance the monitoring of the situation and to step-up the engagement with Cambodia”.

The conclusions also welcome the decision by the European Commission to suspend financial support for Cambodia’s National Election Committee, while requesting the commission expand its support for human rights defenders and civil society.

The council further demands the Cambodian government not misuse the judicial system as an instrument to intimidate political opponents, civil society, and labour and human rights activists.

Phay Siphan, Council of Ministers spokesman, said yesterday that Cambodia was a sovereign state committed to democracy. “They [the EU council] don’t really support democracy, but they like Cambodia to be their token . . . in geopolitical interest,” he said, appearing to allude to Cambodia’s much publicised pivot away from the West and towards Beijing. “They panic [about] China.”

The dissolution of the CNRP and banning of 118 of its politicians “doesn’t mean absence of democracy in Cambodia”, Siphan added.

But Barbara Lochbihler, vice chair of the European Parliament’s Human Rights Committee, said on Friday in a press release that although it was a step in the right direction that the council had acknowledged the “dramatic” negative developments in Cambodia, further steps were needed.

“Targeted sanctions such as travel restrictions for high-ranking government officials would be an urgently necessary signal to the Cambodian government that its human rights violations are not acceptable,” she said.

In an email yesterday, Lochbihler added there was “nothing new in the conclusions”. “How long does the Council intend to wait for the situation to improve?” she asked.

Frithjof Schmidt, a German parliamentarian who had welcomed his government’s ending of preferential visa treatment for high-ranking government officials’ private travel, agreed that the council could have done more. “I would have hoped that the council already [yesterday] decided on stricter visa restrictions against Cambodian government members. Unfortunately that didn’t happen,” he said.

Political analyst Ou Virak said that he hadn’t expected anything else.

“I am not surprised. The language is quite vague and it appears [the council] is trying to send a ‘warning’ to Cambodia of potential economic consequences, particularly in relation to the EBA,” he said. “I think the EU understands how important the EBA is to Cambodia and it’s likely the only language or scheme that matters.”

The reason for the vague language, he said, lay in the nature of the bloc itself.

“Well, it’s the EU. It’s not a single political entity and decisions will always be slow and largely unpredictable,” he said. Inquiries into the EU’s response to the situation have continued.

European Parliamentarian Ramon Tremosa i Balcells has asked the European Commission in a parliamentary question whether the EU had considered freezing assets and visa grants “to the family of Prime Minister Hun Sen or, alternatively, to declare the Prime Minister, in power for 33 years, ‘persona non-grata’”.

He also asked whether the EU had demanded access for journalists and diplomats to attend Kem Sokha’s trial, or if it was “putting on hold other existing forms of support to the Cambodian Government”.
The commission has to reply in writing within a few weeks.

MOST VIEWED

  • CDRI poll: Most happy but disappointments still exist

    A survey has found that over 70 per cent of Cambodian youths and adults approve of the direction the country is headed in, with the majority of respondents saying they had been doing better financially over the past five years. However, more than half said they

  • Drugs raid on Miami Night Club, 50 held

    Anti-drugs police raided a club in Chamkarmon district’s Boeung Keng Kang I commune in Phnom Penh early on Thursday, arresting some 50 people and confiscating drug-producing equipment and suspected illegal substances. Deputy National Police chief Mok Chito said on Thursday that police conducted the raid

  • Phnom Penh: The street food you adore, but given a refined twist

    There is no shortage of street food vendors scattered across Phnom Penh, but what is far rarer is finding a place that also has comfortable seating, good hygiene and parking. This is where Jing Ling and her five friends step in. With the concept of

  • Battambang court releases minor who shot boy

    The Battambang provincial court on Thursday released a 14-year-old boy who had been detained for accidentally firing a home-made gun and killing a nine-year-old boy in Samlot district on Tuesday, provincial court spokesman Tieng Sambor said. Sambor told The Post on Thursday that following the