Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Experts wary as Kingdom mulls private prison plan




Experts wary as Kingdom mulls private prison plan

A guard watches over the gate outside Prey Sar prison in 2009.
A guard watches over the gate outside Prey Sar prison in 2009. Tracey Shelton

Experts wary as Kingdom mulls private prison plan

As Cambodia moves towards opening its first privately run prison, international experts have warned the government may have misunderstood the concept and cautioned that privatisation likely isn’t the best way to tackle chronic overcrowding in prisons.

At a speech last week, Interior Minister Sar Kheng revealed plans for the first privately built and run prison in the Kingdom, which has more than 17,500 inmates in a penal system with the capacity for 8,500.

Kheng, who cited the use of such facilities in Australia, said upscale lodging at the complex could be rented out to wealthy inmates to generate state income.

However, University of Canberra School of Law and Justice associate professor Lorana Bartels yesterday noted a user-pays system was not how private prisons in Australia and other countries worked.

Private prisons in theory are supposed to save taxpayers’ money, as for-profit owners have an incentive to seek efficiencies.

But in Australia, Bartels said opaque contracts between service providers and the government made it difficult to assess whether private prisons were in fact more efficient than their public counterparts.

“We know that money is changing hands, but we don’t know how much… there’s no way of really saying whether they are achieving this goal,” Bartels said.

“It’s problematic to get on board with a policy initiative where the evidence base is shaky to say the least.”

Dating back to the 16th century, according to one study, for-profit, privately run prisons in their modern form began appearing in the US in the 1980s.

Roughly 10 per cent of American inmates now reside inside private prisons.

The UK and Australia keep the highest percentage of their prisoners in privately run facilities – about 19 and 20 per cent respectively – according to an Australian expert and UK government data.

Private or semi-private models are also used in several other countries, including South Africa, Brazil, Japan and Chile.

The Philippines last year invited bids to build its first private prison and Thailand has reportedly conducted feasibility studies into penal privatization.

In a 2005 paper for Duke Law Journal, Sharon Dolovich, faculty director for the University of California Los Angeles’s Prison Law and Police Program, argued the companies’ profit motive could lead to poor services.

“Absent effective checks, efforts on the part of private prison administrators to cut operational costs could thus lead to decisions that deprive inmates of basic human needs, a hallmark of inhumane punishment,” she writes.

A 2015 study by US research Anita Mukherjee, from the University of Wisconsin, found that prisoners in private facilities were detained longer, with operators able to achieve greater profit when holding more prisoners.

Australia National University criminology professor Roderic Broadhurst pointed to moral concerns over whether private companies should control an individual’s punishment, particularly if wealthy prisoners could pay for better treatment.

“What effect might this have on deterrence?” Broadhurst wrote, via email. “The better approach is to… see if you can divert low risk offenders away from costly prisons and try to reduce sentence length via early release schemes such as parole.”

Cambodian prisons offered squalid living conditions to those without the ability to pay for comforts, according to a report by rights group Licadho last year, which noted the “inordinate” use of pre-trial detention.

Human rights lawyer Keo Bunthea said the government should fulfill its own responsibility to prisoners in Cambodia before it thinks of farming out the service.

“They need to provide adequate services for all inmates, not just the wealthy,” Bunthea said.

MOST VIEWED

  • Body of woman killed in Bangkok returns

    The Cambodian embassy in Thailand is working to repatriate the body of a casino dealer who was shot dead in Bangkok on Monday night. Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation spokesman Kuy Kuong told The Post on Wednesday that officials are preparing paperwork to

  • Chikungunya hits 15 provinces, says gov’t

    Ministry of Health spokeswoman Or Vandine said on Thursday that the chikungunya outbreak in the Kingdom has spread to 15 provinces. Some 1,700 people are now suspected to have the disease. Vandine urged people to prevent its further spread by eliminating shelters for the Aedes aegypti mosquitoes

  • Gov’t exempts visa A and B holders from Covid fees

    Airline passengers who are diplomats and officials of international organisations holding Type A and B visas for travel to Cambodia are exempted from paying Covid-19 testing fees, said the Ministry of Health in its latest adjustment of rules on Wednesday. Health Minister Mam Bun Heng

  • Bill covering dress code draws ire

    Ministry of Interior secretary of state Ouk Kim Lek responded on Tuesday to criticism concerning a draft law that would ban women from wearing overly revealing clothing, saying that input from all parties will be considered as the law moves through the promulgation process. Several

  • Passing the test: Is Cambodia’s education system failing its people?

    The Kingdom’s education system needs to grow its people but some flaws might stifle​ this growth Coming from the Khmer Rouge occupation, with the loss of many scholars and academicians and a collapsed government, the education system had to be reconstructed from scratch – one

  • What’s the deal with Cambodia and China’s FTA?

    Cambodia’s Free Trade Agreement (FTA) with China kicks off a series of FTAs in future but for now, critics wonder what else the parties could bring to the table apart from what it already has to date By the end of this year, Cambodia