Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Headaches for Khmer Rouge Trials

Headaches for Khmer Rouge Trials

Headaches for Khmer Rouge Trials

Recent events, as well as problems involving logistics, language difficulties and

unresolved legal restrictions, are proving potential obstacles for the fledgling

Khmer Rouge Trials (KRT), legal experts and KRT officials have told the Post.

Battered by the July 20 death of potential key Khmer Rouge defendant Ta Mok, and

subsequent calls for an accelerated judicial process, officials of the Extraordinary

Chambers of the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC) are now balancing the weight of expectations

with an impending sense of urgency and outcome.

"We are racing against time," said Michelle Lee, deputy director of the

ECCC. "And we cannot sacrifice justice."

With the $56.3 million budget securing only a three-year window of operations -including

time to sift through 30 years of research documents and an adequate appeal process

- legal analysts are concerned that the scope of the prosecution may not even reach

the unofficial recommendation that five to 10 senior leaders of the former Democratic

Kampuchea and those "most responsible for committing serious crimes" be

tried by the ECCC.

"Talk of delay is rampant," said Helen Jarvis, chief of public affairs

for the ECCC. "We are painfully aware of it this week. Time is running out.

I'm thinking of the mortality of human beings - not just potential defendants but

also potential witnesses and those Cambodians still waiting to see justice achieved."

One senior legal expert with ties to the ECCC told the Post on condition of anonymity

that in three years "two to three cases are a realistic figure" and "it

would be a great challenge to try more than three or four."

The expert said two factors would affect this assessment - the quality of defense

counsel and its determination to forestall court procedures and, conversely, the

possibility of trying more than one defendant at a time.

"We're not thinking about the quantity of the trials, we're thinking about the

quality," said Reach Sambath, ECCC spokesman. "The trials will prosecute

the highest leadership and those most responsible. So far, there is no identification

of the KR leaders who will face trial. It is approximated that we will try five to

ten people. We need quick justice, but we cannot be reckless."

But co-prosecutor Robert Petit, who has extensive experience in international criminal

law, said that a limited timeframe is to be expected for a judicial process such

as the ECCC and that extension of the budget is possible.

"A three-year mandate is nothing new; all these trials have a shelf life,"

Petit said on July 27. "There's a target date and you have to be conscious of

time limits, but hopefully we'll be allowed to deliver the measure of justice we're

here to do."

Further complicating the progress of the ECCC is the Law on the Bar, adopted by the

National Assembly in 1995. The law, designed to regulate the legal profession in

Cambodia, states in its Article 4 that "Apart from those lawyers who are members

of the Bar Association, no one may perform this profession." Article 5 of the

same charter simply states "Foreign lawyers may not represent clients."

"The prohibition of the Law on the Bar would influence significantly the ability

of the ECCC to meet international fair trial standards in two distinct ways,"

said Theary Seng, executive director of the Center for Social Development by e-mail.

"First, a fair trial, in part, requires the defense and the prosecution to have

'equality of arms.' Failure to allow full participation by international defense

counsel will put this fair trial element at risk. Second, a fair trial is marked

by the ability of the accused individual to choose his or her own counsel."

According to Seng, the current structure of the ECCC now has both domestic and international

prosecutors, but only private Cambodian defense counsels. British barrister Rupert

Skilbeck, the principle defender for the ECCC, is responsible for ensuring proper

defense counsel.

"I met with Rupert Skilbeck about four weeks ago; he is concerned about the

role of foreign lawyers in the Khmer Rouge Trials," said Cambodian Bar Association

President Suon Visal. "CBA law states that foreign lawyers cannot practice law

in Cambodia. They may only assist Cambodian lawyers. The Khmer Rouge Trials are very

important and must be done to international standards. They have foreign judges and

prosecutors so without foreign lawyers it would be an injustice to the suspects."

Without providing details, both Visol and the ECCC's Jarvis expressed confidence

that the legal requirement could be circumvented.

"If we do not amend the law to allow foreign lawyers to practice law for the

KRT it would be a shame for Cambodia and the UN," Visol said. "But I think

that is impossible. The ECCC will consider all the laws."

The CBA has been deadlocked with internal dispute for nearly two years.

According to Jarvis, another problem slowing the ECCC is language. The court counts

English, French and Khmer as its three official languages, and none of the international

judicial officers speak Khmer.

"The huge wealth of documents we have is in Khmer. It is unrealistic to translate

it all into French and English," Jarvis said. "The other aspect is just

people working together. What language everybody is going to be using is unclear

at this point."


  • Prince injured, wife dies after accident

    THE wife of former First Prime Minister Prince Norodom Ranariddh, Ouk Phalla, 39, died while the prince was “severely” injured following a road accident in Preah Sihanouk province’s Prey Nub district on Sunday morning, officials said. Rananriddh, who is also the president of the Funcinpec

  • Former opposition leader tells soldiers, Cambodians to unite to fight CPP

    Former Cambodia National Rescue Party (CNRP) President Sam Rainsy has called for a popular uprising after the July 29 national elections to force a change of government. He called on the armed forces and people to stand united to fight the ruling Cambodian People’s Party-led

  • Bun Heang mocks US, threatens its citizens in scathing open letter

    After being hit with sanctions from the US Department of Treasury, Cambodian General Hing Bun Heang said he would retaliate against any US national who does not respect his country’s sovereignty, has ambitions to invade Cambodia or incites “traitors” in the Kingdom to do

  • Police warn boycott FB group involved in the “Clean Fingers Campaign”

    Police said on Tuesday that they will pick up members of a Facebook group involved in the “Clean Fingers Campaign” that promotes a boycott of next month’s national elections. However, police merely planned to “educate” the group for now, but warned that if the