Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Hun Sen has change of heart to UN

Hun Sen has change of heart to UN

Hun Sen has change of heart to UN

In the first meeting between Prime Minister Hun Sen and a United Nations High Commissioner

of Human Rights since 2002, Hun Sen pledged on May 18 to make himself more accessible

to UN officials working in Cambodia, according to his personal secretary, Eang Sophalat.

"Louise Arbour, the UN's High Commissioner for Human Rights, came to Cambodia

to improve the relationship between the UN human rights office and the government,"

Sophalat told the Post.

"She met Samdech Hun Sen and asked for his cooperation on the issue of human

rights and he agreed. Now, if there are human rights institutions of the UN that

do things to impact the government, Hun Sen or one of his representatives can meet

with the UN commissioner."

The meeting comes against a backdrop of criticism from human rights groups and stands

in contrast to the legacy of bitter disputes between Hun Sen and the last three UN

Special Representatives of the Secretary-General for Human Rights in Cambodia, most

recently Kenyan human rights lawyer Yash Ghai.

Last month Hun Sen was quoted as saying, among other derogatory remarks, "I

don't like Ghai... " and "I am leaving [Ghai] a message... I refuse to

meet you, I refuse to meet you for ever."

The verbal broadsides came in response to Ghai's first country report that stated

"I have been quite struck by the enormous centralization of power, not in the

government but in one individual. I have talked to judges, politicians and all sorts

of people and everyone is so scared... Everything depends on one individual and this

is not really a precondition under which human rights can flourish."

In a May 18 phone interview from Bangkok, Anselmo Lee, executive director of the

Asia Forum on Human Rights and Development, said the international rights community

is hoping for a positive outcome but wary of Hun Sen's history of diplomatic legerdemain.

"I believe there were two issues on the table today: the Khmer Rouge Trial and

the relationship between the government and the UN office on human rights in regard

to the harsh criticism of Yash Ghai," said Lee.

"It is our hope that the outcome is positive and Hun Sen will agree to meet

Yash Ghai. His role is to assess and advise on human rights issues, it is a benefit

for the government. But [Hun Sen] is not willing to talk to people who criticize


Lao Mong Hay, senior researcher at the Asian Human Rights Commission, echoed Lee's

assessment of Hun Sen's reaction to criticism.

"Attacking, threatening and arresting critics or opponents are Prime Minister

Hun Sen's well-known hallmark, especially when he has not gained full international

legitimacy," Mong Hay wrote in response to written questions.

"When criticisms touch sensitive issues that can affect and erode his powers,

he normally jumps and uses abusive language in his verbal attacks But these attacks

and the abusive language used simply reflect his lack of full self-confidence, his

intolerance of freedom of expression, his monopoly of truth, and also his lack of

proper education when young."

But Cambodian People's Party parliamentarian Cheam Yeab defended Hun Sen and said

the UN did not understand the human rights situation in Cambodia.

"They [the UN] have never gone to the provinces. They have just come to Phnom

Penh and made the report about the human rights situation," Yeab said. "Ghai

saw Cambodia as a very dark country."

Yeab said Hun Sen had been working hard to improve the human rights situation in

Cambodia, and was angry about Ghai's unflattering report on Cambodia's human rights


Om Yen Tieng, chairman of the government's human rights committee and an adviser

to Hun Sen, said the government's dissatisfaction was directed at Ghai specifically

and not the UN.

"Cambodia is a member of the UN and a sovereign nation. We aren't going to talk

about a good or bad relationship [with the UN]," he said. "We aren't happy

with the human rights report which was done by one individual. Yash Ghai is not the


Hun Sen's assurance has some rights activists worried that the cycle of empty threats

followed by equally empty promises will be prolonged and little will be done to improve

the condition of human rights for Cambodian citizens.

Mong Hay said Arbour would have more power to influence Hun Sen if she had more backing

from Cambodia's donor countries; however, in the past donor countries had continued

to support Cambodia with financial aid in spite of its poor human rights record.

"Donors are more concerned about stability than human rights, democracy and

the rule of law in Cambodia," Mong Hay said.

"They would prefer to reform the government through amicable dialogue rather

than confrontation.

"But they are divided, and their representatives have changed regularly resulting

in the loss of consistency and continuity in their stands on the issues of human

rights, democracy and the rule of law.

"Donors seem to feel that when Cambodians are economically better off thanks

to this aid, they will demand and exercise their human rights more.

"But this approach may not work in Cambodia, as it has not in Singapore or Malaysia.

"In Cambodia power politics control every aspect of government from the King

down to village chiefs."

A spokesman for the UN High Commissioner said Arbour was too busy to speak to the