Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Intriguing rhetoric



Intriguing rhetoric

Intriguing rhetoric

I was intrigued by some points made or implied in the piece by Mr Tonkin,

in the PPPost (Vol 9, No 2).

As I have not read the Observer article incriminated, I will only respond, briefly

to some of the 'internal' evidence in the PPPost article itself. My critiques follow

the order of the points referred to. Double quote marks obviously indicate quotations

from the Tonkin piece.

First: if concerns about "breach of humanity" are "deeper" than

"Realpolitik concerns" about "breach of sovereignty" (and this

has apparently become the official view in Britain among others), then a choice between

the two isn't (or shouldn't be) such a difficult "dilemma", and the contrast

between the two types of concern hardly seems to lead to the conclusion that accepting

the Vietnamese-backed administration was "even less acceptable" than recognising

a "cobbled-together" coalition "dominated by the Khmer Rouge"

- thereby putting sovereignty above humanity. (By the way, what a clever ploy to

say that the pressure to establish this coalition was exerted "not least by

China and Asean": this avoids saying who else might have been heavily involved

... or have encouraged Asean to pursue that course).

Second: if the "peoples of the world" found Western policy puzzling or

worse, whereas "the international community" considered it "the lesser

of two evils", we might wonder what exactly the fabled "international community"

could represent, and whether that shibboleth actually refers to anything more than

a "cobbled-together" assortment of leaders from select (not 'rogue') countries,

their cronies and spin doctors, and allied (or clientelised) media. But this international

community is certainly not the expression of the feelings of the "peoples of

the world," if we are to believe the author!

Third: does the phrase "first ever," in a newspaper article, published

in a frontline state moreover, prove that the KPNLF had never before cooperated with

the Khmer Rouge, ... however many times the phrase "first ever" was repeated?

(Indeed, a point too often repeated smacks of the urge to persuade, or the need to

persuade oneself).

Fourth: the "canard" according to which the S.A.S. created a sabotage battalion.

How can this be true when these elite soldiers merely trained the Cambodians who

then set up that battalion? Obviously these S.A.S (or were they recently retired

S.A.S?) could not have been further removed from any responsibility in whatever the

battalion later accomplished. Therefore the British government, the employer of those

innocent babes, was not involved in any later damage, 'collateral' or otherwise,

wrought by the battalion : how very convincing! As for the punch line "Not exactly

a massive military intervention", it seems to refute an extravagant point, but

this is a point which, judging from evidence in Tonkin's article, has not been made

... a typical, age-old rhetorical trick.

Equally hallowed (or is it hollowed?) is the string of "is it remotely possible"

(not unrelated to another classic: "Every schoolboy knows") which is supposed

to prove how "illogical" the claim is that Britain acted as a subcontractor

of the U.S. Of course, such theories are only likely and logical when the alleged

perpetrator is "our" enemy. "We" never do such things: how could

anyone be so paranoiac as to imagine it ... and why therefore would we have to use

logic rather than rhetoric, rather than sophisms, to prove such a self-evident point?

One last point: British policy is apparently vindicated (this is actually a slightly

earlier point in the article) by its supposed result: "the principles of democracy,

the rule of law and progress towards a market economy" have become the "ideals

and objectives" of those in (and out of) power in Cambodia. This seems a rather

wild claim ... and besides, do the purported aims (or the supposed results) of a

policy justify that policy, given that the policy involved (at very least) giving

"support and comfort to the K R"... with the ensuing ascertainable results.
Philippe Hunt, Brussels, Belgium

MOST VIEWED

  • Municipal hall releases map detailing colour coded Covid risks by commune

    Phnom Penh municipal governor Khuong Sreng released an official map detailing the red, yellow and dark yellow zones within the city under the new lockdown orders for Phnom Penh announced on April 26. The designation of red, dark yellow and yellow corresponds to areas with high,

  • Inter-provincial travel ban lifted; Phnom Penh and Takmao not exempted

    The government on April 25 decided to lift the inter-provincial travel ban and the closure of tourist attractions across the country, effectively immediately. The travel ban and closures of all resorts were imposed on April 6 and 17 respectively in a bid to curb the spread of Covid-19,

  • Phnom Penh unveils rules for post-lockdown transition

    The Phnom Penh Municipal Administration issued a set of detailed guidelines for the seven days to May 12 after the capital emerges from lockdown at the onset of May 6. In the 14-page document signed by municipal governor Khuong Sreng released on the evening of May 5, the

  • Phnom Penh, Takmao lockdown extended for another week

    The government late on April 26 announced an extension of lockdown in Phnom Penh and adjacent Takmao town in Kandal province for another seven days – or longer if residents do not comply with Covid-19 preventive measures and the community outbreak does not subside – until May 5. According

  • Gov't mulls extension of Phnom Penh, Takmao lockdown

    The Inter-ministerial National Commission for the Control and Enforcement of Lockdown held a video conference meeting on April 25 to review a draft document on the extension of lockdown in Phnom Penh and adjacent Kandal province’s Takmao town. The meeting was chaired by Minister of

  • Gov’t issues guidelines as lockdown nears end

    The government has issued a five-page set of instructions to be enforced when the three-week lockdown of Phnom Penh and adjacent Takmao town in Kandal province ends on May 6. According to an announcement signed by Prime Minister Hun Sen on May 4, the instructions cover a