Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Judge unconvinced by rapist’s excuse

Judge unconvinced by rapist’s excuse

Content image - Phnom Penh Post
Hem Hai (centre) is serving a seven year sentence for raping a minor. He claims he only confessed due to police intimidation. Kim Sarom

Judge unconvinced by rapist’s excuse

A supreme Court judge labelled a 72-year-old man’s excuse that police threats were the reason he confessed to raping a minor in Kampong Chhnang province in 2013 as “unreasonable”.

Hem Hai, who was ordered by the provincial court to serve a seven-year sentence for the crime, is appealing to the Supreme Court for a lower sentence.

On Wednesday, he told the Supreme Court that he and the victim lived about 100m from each other in the same village in Kampong Leng district. The child’s grandparents were his in-laws, and the young girl often went to his house to play with other children.

He said on the day of the incident in August 2013, his children and the victim were only watching TV together at his house.

“I filed an appeal to the Supreme Court because I want the court to provide me justice. I did not rape the girl as accused. I only confessed to raping her because I was forced to [by police],” he said.

However, presiding Judge Kim Sathavy was unconvinced by his claims of police intimidation.

“Your testimony claiming you confessed due to police threats and intimidation seems unreasonable. You cannot use this as an excuse to protect yourself,” he said.

Defence lawyer Tith Lay said the lower court’s initial verdict was entirely based on his confession, which he claimed was given under duress.

He said the victim’s testimony was inconsistent and cited medical examinations which indicated that the child’s genitals were undamaged.

“Sometimes the victim said she was raped five times . . . sometimes she said she was raped only once. His wife also lived in the same house where the alleged attack occurred, so how did he do it?” he asked.

Lay said his client had already served over five years of his seven-year sentence, and that if Hai had raped the victim, he would not bother filing a complaint to the Supreme Court at this late stage just to restore his reputation.

Prosecutor Chum Samban said the Appeal Court upheld the provincial court’s initial verdict based on Hai’s confession to both the police and the judge.

“The suspect said he was intimidated by the police, but then why did he make the same confession to the judge? I ask the Supreme Court to uphold the Appeal Court’s verdict,” he said.

Judge Sethavy said he will hand down his verdict on January 30.

MOST VIEWED

  • CNRP supporters rally in the streets of Tokyo

    Supporters of the Supreme Court-dissolved Cambodia National Rescue Party (CNRP) on Monday rallied on the streets of Tokyo, demanding Prime Minister Hun Sen’s resignation and urging the Japanese government to “save democracy in the Kingdom”. Some 400 protesters in the rally, which was organised by

  • GMAC makes EU plea to consider job losses

    In a statement set to be published on Monday, the Garment Manufacturers Association in Cambodia (GMAC) said the EU’s possible withdrawal of Cambodia’s Everything But Arms (EBA) access would harm 750,000 workers and three million families. The GMAC statement, seen by The Post on

  • Four dead in Preah Sihanouk, Ratanakkiri flooding

    At least four people have died and thousands of families affected by flooding in Preah Sihanouk and Ratanakkiri provinces following recent heavy thunderstorms. Preah Sihanouk provincial spokesperson Kheang Phearum said on Sunday that a Cambodian husband and wife were killed on Thursday when a concrete

  • LPG gas explosion injures 13 people, including foreigners, in Siem Reap

    An explosion on Wednesday at a liquid petroleum gas (LPG) car and tuk-tuk refuelling station in Siem Reap city has left 13 people, including an American and a Briton, suffering burns. The seven most severely burned, including a provincial police officer, were sent to a Thai