Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Judges prodded on detention

Judges prodded on detention

Two handcuffed men are escorted to a hearing at Phnom Penh Municipal Court this month
Two handcuffed men are escorted to a hearing at Phnom Penh Municipal Court this month. Licadho believes pre-trial detainees account for more than 60 per cent of the Cambodian prison population. Pha Lina

Judges prodded on detention

With pre-trial detainees adding to an already-overcrowded prison population, the government yesterday called on the judiciary to rethink the widespread practice of jailing suspects long-term before trial.

In opening remarks at the two-day conference, co-organised by the Ministry of Justice and the Bar Association, with support from the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), Justice Minister Ang Vong Vanthana called for a “transparent and effective” approach to pre-trial detentions.

“Judges have a very supreme power. [They] have enforced their law, but their enforcement is not comprehensive.… When they leave or graduate from school, they have some gaps in their decision making,” he told the audience of about 70 judiciary members, donors and government officials at the Cambodiana Hotel.

“Judges are [now] required to give proper arguments and justifications for pre-trial detention,” he said, explaining that the days of simply being able to tick boxes when deciding whether to detain a suspect before trial are numbered.

In January, the Ministry of Justice sent a new form – which senior judges helped to pen – to all Cambodian courts, requiring judges to call an adversarial hearing with all parties ahead of any decision.

Yesterday’s event sought to convince judges that, as per law, “In principle, the charged person shall remain at liberty.”

Licadho prison consultant Sharon Critoph said this is far from what is happening at the moment.

“Whilst pre-trial detention should always be the exception not the rule, as things stand, suspects, including pregnant women and juveniles, are rarely spared prison time even for the most minor offences,” she said by email yesterday.

According to Licadho, pre-trial detainees, including those awaiting final verdict or appeal, now represent more than 60 per cent of the entire Cambodian prison population.

“[They] are often held in worse conditions than convicts.

“They are unlikely to be offered work opportunities or vocational training and therefore have less out-of-cell time,” Critoph said.

High numbers of detainees also add to prison overcrowding. According to Justice Ministry figures, in December there were 14,691 inmates filling 8,500 places.

Under the new rules, the judge will only be able to order pre-trial detention for a set period, the maximum of which is one year for suspects over 18 who have committed a felony.

While wide-scale implementation is yet to happen, organisers yesterday stressed the importance of the change.

A speech read on behalf of OHCHR representative Wan-Hea Lee said the reform represents “human rights protection against arbitrary detention”.


  • Bareknuckle champion wants Kun Khmer fighter

    Dave Leduc, who is the current openweight Lethwei boxing champion in Myanmar, has announced that he will travel to Cambodia this year to challenge SEA Games gold medallist Prum Samnang any time that is convenient, after their planned match later this month in Slovakia was

  • Five-year-old Hanuman dances his way into hearts of Cambodia

    A young talent from a new-established settlement has emerged, captivating the online world with his mesmerising performances of the traditional Cambodian monkey dance. Roeun Kakada is a five-year-old prodigy who has taken the social media sphere by storm with his exceptional dance skills and dedication

  • Fresh Covid warnings as Thai hospital fills

    A senior health official reminds the public to remain vigilant, as neighbouring countries experience an increase in Covid-19 cases, with the latest surge appearing to be a result of the Omicron XBB.1.5 sub-variant. Or Vandine, secretary of state and spokeswoman for the Ministry of Health,

  • Honda shutters Siem Reap football club

    Japanese football legend Keisuke Honda, the owner of Siem Reap football club Soltilo Angkor FC, has been forced to shut the club down, after it failed to attract sponsorship for the upcoming season. Honda, the former manager of the Cambodia men's national football team, said

  • Hun Sen warns of regional tensions

    ASIA is becoming a dangerous geopolitical hotspot, with several countries announcing that they intend to send naval vessels towards Southeast Asia and on to the South China Sea, warned Prime Minister Hun Sen. “Heated geopolitical issues can easily escalate, namely to war. I am not

  • PM declares ASEAN Para Games open

    The 12th ASEAN Para Games officially kicked off on the evening of June 3 at Morodok Techo National Stadium in Phnom Penh, with a spectacular opening ceremony featuring fireworks and performances by some of the Kingdom’s most accomplished talents. Tens of thousands of sports fans