Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Junta using migrants as scapegoat, analysts say

Junta using migrants as scapegoat, analysts say

Junta using migrants as scapegoat, analysts say

Analysis

Fearing the Thai military junta, more than 166,000 Cambodian workers have spilled across the Poipet international checkpoint over the past two weeks, overwhelming aid officials and straining relations between the two countries.

Officially, the Thai Foreign Ministry blames rumours, especially about shootings and military perpetrated violence against workers, for scaring mainly undocumented Cambodian migrants from the country.

“The [government] does not have any policy to accelerate arrests and crackdowns of foreign workers,” General Prayuth Chan-ocha said in an official order on Monday.

“[The] regularisation … at the current moment is controlling foreign workers, by ordering employers and entrepreneurs … to prepare lists of foreign workers under their employment for further inspections,” reads an unofficial translation of the statement made public yesterday.

But analysts say that harsher statements previously delivered reveal the junta is using illegal migrants as a scapegoat to distract from a flagging economy and to further assert its authority.

“By cracking down on so-called irregular or undocumented Cambodian migrant workers, the military junta could be seen to be in control and, at least on the surface, attempting to improve Thailand’s social and economic problems,” said Kevin Mcgahan, a political science professor at the National University of Singapore.

Prayuth’s order on Monday came less than a week after an army spokesman threatened all “illegal foreign workers” with arrest and deportation, and spelled the situation out in distinctly xenophobic terms.

“We see illegal workers as a threat, because there [are] a lot of them and no clear measures to handle them, which could lead to social problems,” spokesman Sirichan Ngathong said last Wednesday.

Ou Virak, chairman of the Cambodian Center for Human Rights, believes the junta is using the deportations to push a message of nationalistic politics.

“[The military government is] finding a shared external enemy to divert attention from the polarised nature of Thai politics,” he said.

But if the nationalistic rhetoric is to blame for the Cambodian workers’ mass exodus, it hasn’t caused a universal response among all migrant workers.

“Burmese migrant communities are also experiencing raids every day, but we have so far not received news on Burmese migrants leaving on the scale experienced by Cambodian migrants,” said Reiko Harima, regional coordinator for the Mekong Migration Network.

While the reasons for the discrepancy between migrant groups is not obvious, suggested rationales include the socio-political situation each community would face upon returning home, as well as cultural susceptibility to fear of arrests.

“Many of [the Cambodian] migrant workers will be the children of Khmer Rouge soldiers and, or victims,” said GDM Wijers, an expert in migration studies. “A medical team working with the witnesses of the Khmer Rouge tribunal has brought forward again how traumatised first-generation survivors can transfer their fears, inadvertently, to the second generation. This could make the Cambodian workers more susceptible to panic in fear of violence by the Thai regime.”

The Thai junta’s less-than-warm reception of Cambodian migrant workers specifically could in part stem from diplomatic repercussion of Hun Sen’s strong ties with ousted Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra.

“Thailand sees the migrant workers as a security concern, they [are from] a country that has openly supported Thaksin and the ‘red shirts’,” said Kem Ley, an independent analyst.

Such “dangerous politics” aren’t expected to benefit either country in the long run, he added.

Thai businesses are already reporting feeling pinched by a shortage of cheap labour, and even the junta acknowledged that the policy was hurting “works, business entities and the overall national economic system”.

Cambodia, which stands to lose several million dollars in remittances because of the returned labourers, had until yesterday stayed temperate in its response.

“I think the current Thai junta leader must be responsible for the problems happening, including the loss of lives,” said Minister of Interior Sar Kheng, referring to traffic accidents that have killed 10 Cambodians en route to the border.

For now, Cambodian Foreign Ministry spokesman Koy Kuong vows that relations between the countries have not deteriorated over the sudden shock of more than a hundred thousand unemployed Cambodians streaming back into the country, but political analyst Kevin Hewison warned that the situation is a ready fuse.

“I fear that another border dispute could easily be manufactured by the military junta, and that this could play into its current emphasis on nationalism as a way to ‘unite’ Thais,” he said. “This is a potentially dangerous situation. Watch the border.”

ADDITIONAL REPORTING BY CHHAY CHANNYDA

MOST VIEWED

  • Draft law on state of emergency pending finalisation

    Prime Minister Hun Sen will lead a top-level meeting on Tuesdays to review the draft law on imposing a state of emergency. Meantime, he has decided to close all casinos in Cambodia effective April 1. In the press conference after the National Assembly met today, Hun

  • State of emergency on table amid pandemic

    Prime Minister Hun Sen, his deputy prime ministers and legal team will meet on Tuesday to review the draft law on declaring a state of emergency, as Covid-19 cases rose to 107 in the Kingdom on Monday. Speaking at a press conference after a parliament meeting

  • Stranded passengers petition UK for help

    Some 10,521 people have signed an online petition calling on British Prime Minister Boris Johnson and relevant officials to fly nearly 200 passengers out of Cambodia. The petition is targeted at 15,000 people. Most of the passengers are British nationals, who are stranded in Cambodia after airlines cancelled

  • Many in limbo as tension heightens

    As the Kingdom restricts travel and prepares for a state of emergency, some foreigners in Cambodia are scrambling for a way home. Foreign embassies in Phnom Penh are making efforts to get their citizens out, but cancelled flights have become common due to the coronavirus

  • Covid-19 Pandemic: Force majeure and legal consequences

    Is the Covid-19 pandemic considered an event of force majeure? The World Health Organisation declared the novel coronavirus (Covid-19) outbreak a pandemic on March 11. Following this declaration, the Ministry of Health and other ministries have taken various legal and administrative measures to prevent the rapid

  • PM set to mend ties with US

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has responded to US Congressman Ted Yoho, saying he is ready to improve Cambodia-US relations, and not take up issues of disagreements which have become a barrier between the two countries’ bilateral cooperation. His response to Yoho came after the congressman