Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Juvenile justice: suffer the little children?

Juvenile justice: suffer the little children?

Juvenile justice: suffer the little children?

Everyone agrees that children are deserving of special care and protection by adults

- be that through individuals such as parents and teachers, or through governmental

and non-governmental organizations. Children are especially vulnerable, and so we

are particularly affected when we see children suffering as the victims of war, poverty,

or disability.

However, when a child is accused of committing a crime, that sympathy and understanding

may evaporate. Yet children caught up in the legal system still need protection and

special treatment: first, they are often from the most disadvantaged backgrounds,

socially and economically; and second, the impact upon a child in the criminal justice

system may be extremely damaging.

Recognizing the special needs of children and their particular vulnerability, the

United Nations drew up the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC). The Cambodian

Government ratified the CRC on 14 November 1992, and is therefore bound by its provisions

and obliged to protect and uphold children's rights, by acting in the best interests

of the child.

The CRC sets out the safeguards which must be in place to protect children accused

of a criminal offense. It specifies that the arrest, detention or imprisonment of

a child shall be used only as a measure of last resort and for the shortest appropriate

period of time; that children in detention should be separated from adult detainees;

that children in custody have a right to contact with their families; and that all

children held in custody should be treated with humanity and respect, and in a manner

which takes account of the needs of a person of their age. The aim of the legal system

must be to facilitate the reintegration of the child into society.

The CRC also requires State parties to establish laws, procedures and institutions

specifically applicable to children accused or found guilty of criminal behavior,

and stipulates that a variety of dispositions - such as care, guidance and supervision

orders, counseling, probation, foster care, educational and vocational training programs,

and other alternatives to institutional care - shall be available.

Content image - Phnom Penh Post

How far has Cambodia honored those obligations in its treatment of juveniles in the

criminal justice system?

Last year, the Court Watch Project of the Center for Social Development (CSD) monitored

trials in six courts in Cambodia, including the cases of 137 juvenile defendants

(aged 13-18). CSD found that 87% of juvenile defendants were held in custody awaiting

trials, and that 82% of those in pre-trial detention had been held beyond the legal

time-limits (two months maximum for those under 18).

The conviction rate for juveniles was 95%. Of those convicted, 97% were given an

immediate custodial sentence, with just four children receiving a suspended sentence.

In a typical case, four minors were sentenced to five years' imprisonment for stealing

three chickens.

Right now, Cambodia is plainly not complying with the CRC. Pre-trial detention is

the rule rather than the exception, often beyond the prescribed time limits. There

are separate detention facilities for juveniles on remand, but once convicted, children

and adults serve their sentences together. This puts the child at risk and exposes

the child to more sophisticated and hardened criminals. Conditions are poor in most

jails, with overcrowding exacerbating deficient hygiene and sanitation. A prison

sentence means a hiatus, if not a complete halt, in education.

When concerns are voiced about the treatment of juvenile defendants, the issue of

"Bong Thom" gangs is often raised. Certainly, gangs of teenage boys involved

in street robberies and other violence may pose a real threat to law and order. However,

the appropriate response to such problems is for the government to work with youth

organizations to devise more effective strategies and legislation which complies

with the CRC, not to demonize all juvenile defendants and to violate children's rights.

One problem is that there is no alternative to custody. Many accused persons await

their trial in custody because there is no bail regime, under which stringent conditions

could be placed upon defendants to ensure their attendance at court, such as financial

bonds, regular reporting to the police, or a requirement of residence at a particular


In the case of a convicted juvenile, the court has no options other than an immediate

custodial sentence or a suspended prison term. The alternatives to custody required

under the CRC simply do not exist in Cambodia, and realistically will not materialize

until there is a solid infrastructure of social services and child care facilities

in place - which will not happen overnight.

In the meantime, more can and must be done to protect the vulnerable children who

are exposed to all manner of dangers and influences in Cambodia's jails.

Ideally, separate youth courts, with distinct powers and specially trained staff

and officials, should deal with juvenile cases, but for now, specific training for

judges and prosecutors to raise awareness of children's rights and their special

needs is essential, and achievable.

A bail system for juveniles must also be implemented to ensure that juveniles accused

of crimes reside, wherever possible, with their families or at an approved hostel

awaiting trial.

Finally, alternatives to custodial sentences must be explored as a matter of urgency.

The sophisticated multi-agency provision of services envisaged within the CRC may

not be attainable in Cambodia yet, but basic community penalties, such as performing

unpaid work in the community as a means of direct reparation for the crime, would

be relatively simple to implement and oversee.

Some positive efforts have been made by the government, notably the committee on

juvenile justice spearheaded by the President of Kandal Provincial Court, Khieu Sameth.

Improvements in the treatment of minors in the legal system are needed urgently,

and not simply because Cambodia must comply with the CRC. Children are the country's

future, and a legal system which treats children humanely, and encourages them to

turn away from crime and to reintegrate into society, is to everyone's benefit.

Zoe Nield, CSD Consultant

Ang Udom, CSD Legal Unit Head

The Voice of Justice column is a regular feature of the Phnom Penh Post. Both the

column and the logo are expressions of the Center for Social Development which bears

full responsibility for the opinions expressed. The CSD Voice of Justice logo depicts

a Cambodian figure pushing aside the black curtains of a repressive past, as s/he

yearns to enter a world of freedom of expression and democracy, represented by the

blue of the inner circle. The scales of justice above the figure show the supremacy

of law, and are in gold, which according to Cambodian mythology stands for strength,

rooted in the earth. The Constitution is placed in front of the figure to represent

the protection it affords. The logo is encircled in pale blue to symbolize peace,

whilst the two golden naga motifs, which appear on the CSD logo, identify the Voice

of Justice as a program of CSD.


  • US think tank warns of China's 'ulterior motives'

    A US think tank on Tuesday warned that spreading Chinese investment in the Indo-Pacific follows a pattern of leveraging geopolitical influence at the expense of the nations receiving investment, including Cambodia. The report looks at a sample of 15 Chinese port development projects, noting that the

  • More than three tonnes of ivory reportedly bound for Cambodia seized in Mozambique

    A total of 3.5 tonnes of ivory reportedly bound for Cambodia was seized by authorities in Mozambique late last week, according to the NGO Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES). CITES' information was based on a report from the

  • Defence Ministry denies weapons in smuggling case came from Cambodia

    After a Thai national was arrested last week for allegedly smuggling guns from Cambodia to Thailand, Cambodia's Defence Ministry has claimed the weapons seized during the arrest are not used in Cambodia, despite the fact that both types of rifle seized are commonly found in

  • Shipwreck found off coast of Koh Kong

    Royal Cambodian Navy researchers are working to identify a decades-old shipwreck found earlier this month off the coast of Koh Kong province. Divers found the 70-metre-long wreck on April 4 about a mile from Koh Chhlam island, according to Navy officials. Deputy Navy Commander Tea Sokha,