Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Law on MPs' speech threatens quality of lawmaking



Law on MPs' speech threatens quality of lawmaking

Law on MPs' speech threatens quality of lawmaking

While it may be hyperbolic to compare Article 5 of the speech law recently passed

by the National Assembly with the Khmer Rouge era, as Sam Rainsy did recently in

the Phnom Penh Post (September 8, 2006), the law should raise concerns. It reads,

"Members of the Parliament may not abuse this parliamentary immunity to harm

the dignity of others, the good customs of the society, law and order, and national

security."

Dangerously, the law fails to define either "law and order" or "national

security," and thus permits the government to prosecute virtually any type of

speech. As United States Ambassador Joseph A Mussomeli noted, a law of this

type is unique to Cambodia. However, the law should be recognized as problematic

for its relationship to Cambodian law and politics, not its international position.

Three relevant factors set Cambodia apart from other democracies:

• no other country affords the speech of its parliamentarians such broad protection;

• few other countries punish defamation as a crime; and

• no other country shares Cambodia's history.

The first factor ameliorates the danger of the law, while the latter two exacerbate

it.

As the Sam Rainsy Party has observed, the law may conflict with Article 80 of the

Constitution, which provides that "The accusation, arrest, or detention of a

member of assembly shall be made only with the permission of the assembly . . . ."

Most democracies shield parliamentarians from liability only for statements made

in the course of the assembly's business, but in Cambodia, this clause has been interpreted

to protect members of the assembly from all arrest, regardless of its relationship

to legislating. Cambodia thus affords far more protection to its parliamentarians

than do other nations, and so a weakening of this protection would bring Cambodia

more in line with other democracies.

However, two factors heighten the danger of this law:

• Few other democracies have the crime of defamation; in most states, the wrongdoer

may be liable to his victim, but he will not be imprisoned or fined by the government.

While the Cambodian government has recently begun to re-evaluate its criminal defamation

law, and while this law has been harshly criticized, it further serves to set Cambodia

apart. As long as the law remains on the books, assembly members face criminal punishment

for statements made during the course of legislative debate - a situation inconsistent

with democratic principles.

• The speech law must be examined in light of Cambodia's history. Past governments

have used the police and court system to persecute their enemies instead of prosecuting

wrongdoers. One need only open a newspaper to see the dangers of a politicized justice

system. This new law is problematic to the extent that it has the potential to become

yet another political weapon.

That this new law is unique to Cambodia is not itself objectionable: Cambodia is

a unique nation. What makes this law dangerous is its interaction with the criminal

defamation law and Cambodia's history of politicized prosecutions. If members of

the assembly must fear criminal prosecutions for statements made during the creation

of legislation, free debate will be stifled and the quality of lawmaking will decline.

Arie Rubenstein - The Center for Social Development, Phnom Penh

MOST VIEWED

  • Phnom Penh placed in two-week lockdown

    The government has decided to place Phnom Penh in lockdown for two weeks, effective April 14 midnight through April 28, as Cambodia continues to grapple with the ongoing community outbreak of Covid-19, which has seen no sign of subsiding. According to a directive signed by Prime Minister

  • Cambodia on the verge of national tragedy, WHO warns

    The World Health Organisation (WHO) in Cambodia warned that the country had reached another critical point amid a sudden, huge surge in community transmission cases and deaths. “We stand on the brink of a national tragedy because of Covid-19. Despite our best efforts, we are

  • Hun Sen: Stay where you are, or else

    Prime Minister Hun Sen warned that the two-week lockdown of Phnom Penh and adjacent Kandal provincial town Takmao could be extended if people are not cooperative by staying home. “Now let me make this clear: stay in your home, village, and district and remain where

  • Businesses in capital told to get travel permit amid lockdown through One Window Service

    The Phnom Penh Municipal Administration has issued guidelines on how to get travel permission for priority groups during the lockdown of Phnom Penh, directing private institutions to apply through the municipality's One Window Service and limit their staff to a mere two per cent. In

  • Vaccination open to foreigners in Cambodia

    The Ministry of Health on April 8 issued an announcement on Covid-19 vaccination for foreigners residing and working in Cambodia, directing the Ministry of Labour and Vocational Training and local authorities to register them. Health minister Mam Bun Heng, who is also head of the inter-ministerial

  • Ministry names types of business permitted amid lockdown

    The Ministry of Labour and Vocational Training singled out 11 types of business that are permitted to operate during the lockdown of Phnom Penh and Takmao town, which run through April 28. Those include (1) food-processing enterprises and slaughterhouses; (2) providers of public services such as firefighting, utility and