Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - MoU tweak ‘likely irrelevant’

MoU tweak ‘likely irrelevant’

Cambodia’s representative to the UN in Geneva, Ney Sam Ol, at the UN’s Human Rights Council in September, where Cambodia drew criticism for delays in renewing its MoU with the UN’s OHCHR. Photo supplied
Cambodia’s representative to the UN in Geneva, Ney Sam Ol, at the UN’s Human Rights Council in September, where Cambodia drew criticism for delays in renewing its MoU with the UN’s OHCHR. Photo supplied

MoU tweak ‘likely irrelevant’

Touted by the government as marking an end to “interference” in Cambodia’s internal affairs, observers say the much-debated wording of a new memorandum of understanding with the UN’s Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) has, in fact, no legal implications at all.

The OHCHR’s MoU lapsed in December a year ago and was not renewed until Tuesday afternoon, just 10 days before the government had threatened to eject the human rights office if a new memorandum had not been signed.

The sticking point for these past 12 months had been the government’s insistence on the inclusion of an explicit reference to Article 2, Paragraph 7 of the UN Charter, which states that nothing within the charter authorises “the United Nations to intervene in matters which are essentially within the domestic jurisdiction of any state”.

The government has long regarded OHCHR pronouncements on human rights issues as an intrusion on Cambodia’s sovereignty; it believes that Paragraph 7’s prohibition on UN intervention in domestic matters also prohibits those pronouncements. Legal and human rights experts, however, said the government had misunderstood the principle of non-intervention.

“That language is, I assume, an effort to push OHCHR to refrain from criticism, but it has no legal value,” International Commission of Jurists regional director Sam Zafiri said. “The notion that human rights monitoring violates sovereignty has been rejected conclusively years ago.”

A 1986 ruling by the International Court of Justice found that for an action to violate the principle of non-intervention, it must include an element of coercion, such as the use of force.

Contacted yesterday, Foreign Ministry spokesman Chum Sounry refused to explain the government’s interpretation of non-intervention, but previous outbursts by government officials over OHCHR’s “interference” have come in response to statements given to the media.

Andrea Giorgetta, of the International Federation of Human Rights, said via email yesterday that while the government had “played hardball” over the MoU, “It knew full well that kicking the UN out of Cambodia would have been counterproductive.”

He called the reference to Paragraph 7 a “face-saving solution” that allowed the government to “reiterate its absurd claim that UN human rights monitoring impinges on Cambodia’s sovereignty”.

“In practice, this clause is likely to be irrelevant although one can expect Phnom Penh will invoke it from time to time.”

Ear Sophal, author of Aid Dependence in Cambodia: How Foreign Assistance Undermines Democracy, went one further, describing Tuesday’s signing as “a win for OHCHR”, noting this was far from the first time the government had threatened to shut down the country’s human rights office.

“If the goal was to get rid of them, epic fail,” Sophal said in an email. “It was a game of chicken and all they got was this little clause? Looks to me like OHCHR lived to fight another day.”

A Geneva-based spokesperson for OHCHR said in an email yesterday that the MoU “was the result of a mutually acceptable agreement that takes into account the position of both sides” and that “the agreement reached involves no compromise on our mandate”.

MOST VIEWED

  • Research key to Kanitha’s rep for expertise

    Sok Kanitha is used to weighing in on controversial issues using a confident approach that signals expertise and authority, and a recent video she made was no exception. Her “Episode 342: The History of NATO” video went live on January 16, 2023 and immediately shot to 30,000 likes and 3,500

  • Cambodia maintains 'Kun Khmer' stance despite Thailand’s boycott threat

    Cambodia has taken the position that it will use the term "Kun Khmer" to refer to the sport of kickboxing at the upcoming Southeast Asian (SEA) Games, and has removed the term Muay from all references to the sport. Despite strong reactions from the Thai

  • Knockout! Kun Khmer replaces ‘Muay’ for Phnom Penh Games

    Cambodia has decided to officially remove the word Muay from the programme of the 32nd Southeast Asian (SEA) Games 2023 in May. “Kun Khmer” will instead be used to represent the Southeast Asian sport of kickboxing, in accordance with the wishes of the Cambodian people. Vath

  • Artificial insemination takes herd from 7 to 700

    Some farms breed local cows or even import bulls from a broad for the purpose of breeding heavier livestock for meat production. One Tbong Khnum farmer has found a more efficient way. Hout Leang employs artificial insemination to fertilise local cows. Thanks to imported “straws”

  • Chinese group tours return to Cambodia starting Feb 6

    Cambodia is among 20 countries selected by Beijing for a pilot programme allowing travel agencies to provide international group tours as well as flight and hotel packages to Chinese citizens, following a three-year ban. As the days tick down until the programme kicks off on February 6,

  • Capital-Poipet express rail project making headway

    The preliminary results of a feasibility study to upgrade the Phnom Penh-Poipet railway into Cambodia’s first express railway indicate that the project would cost more than $4 billion and would take around four years to complete. The study was carried out by China Road and