Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - The mutineers: united by lost jobs and rotting logs

The mutineers: united by lost jobs and rotting logs

The mutineers: united by lost jobs and rotting logs


UNHAPPY Pol Potists sacked from their posts, opportunists looking for better business

prospects and war-weary guerrilla veterans. These are the chiefs of the Khmer Rouge


While the ordinary folk of Anlong Veng may want to escape Ta Mok's strictness and

have the freedom to sell bananas, chickens and pigs, analysts suggest that the rebellion

leaders will be expecting far more from the government.

The loose coalition of senior, or formerly senior, cadre who spurred the revolt were

likely united by one thing - the promise of money and semi-autonomy - political and

KR observers suggested.

As with the earlier KR breakaway in timber- and gem-rich Phnom Malai and Pailin,

"I think we should see the Anlong Veng split in the perspective of business,"

said one Phnom Penh-based analyst. "What is the business in the area - it's

wood, it's logging."

With Ta Mok controlling the purse strings since last year's coup against Pol Pot,

he was almost certainly not dishing out much money to senior cadre who were formerly

close to the deposed Brother No 1, the observer said.

Many of the mid-to-higher ranking Anlong Veng defectors - who ironically were being

called Pol Pot "hardliners" not so long ago - had been stripped of their

positions and replaced by Mok loyalists.

"It's logical that when these people found themselves becoming poorer and poorer...

they became the basis of the [breakaway] movement," the observer commented.

"It's not ideology. It's not 'we want reconciliation.' Sure, no-one wants to

fight any more, but it has most likely to do with business, and Ta Mok's way of doing

business. Some people were excluded."

A critical issue, some suggest, is Thailand's efforts - under considerable international

and Cambodian pressure - to stem the flow of logs from Anlong Veng across the border

in the past two years.

"They haven't been getting logs across, I know that for sure," said American

journalist Nate Thayer, a witness to Pol Pot's trial last July who has visited Anlong

Veng several times. "I saw the [stockpiled] logs, for one, and they were also

begging me for answers on how to get the logs out."

Thayer said: "It's a serious situation in which millions of dollars of logs

are literally rotting away. It means a big incentive to defect, if they're given

a piece of the pie.

"The logging routes can open up if the Cambodian and Thai governments agree.

If those areas come under government auspices, there's no reason why a deal can't

be done for that to happen."

Several defectors last week confirmed difficulties in trading with Thailand. "It's

very difficult to sell timber to the Thai side," one low-ranking soldier said.

"Even to bring rice into Anlong Veng became difficult - we had to hide it under

piles of dirt in trucks." Asked the reason for the obstacles, he replied: "Because

the Khmer Rouge are outlawed - the government asked Thailand to stop the trade."

 Although no one doubts that Ta Mok is rich - breakaway leader Ke Pauk said Mok had

claimed, after deposing Pol Pot, to have 600 million Thai baht ($17 million) stashed

away - defectors complained that his wealth had not been spread to them.

Another key factor, analysts speculated, is the example of Pailin and Malai - which

have retained virtual autonomy over economic, social and military matters since their

breakaway while benefitting from the peace and security of integration with the government.

"Certainly, many in Anlong Veng would have been looking at them and thinking

'Hmm, that's a better deal than having to fight the government every dry season',"

said one observer.

Any active role by Pailin and Malai leaders in supporting the split from Ta Mok is

denied by the Anlong Veng mutineers. Representatives of Pailin leader Ieng Sary and

Ta Mok met for talks after Pol Pot's overthrow, according to independent sources,

but the content of their discussions is unknown.

Also uncertain is whether there was contact between the Anlong Veng defectors and

their Pailin counterparts before the split. Certainly, they wasted little time in

renewing old acquaitances afterward: Pailin Governor Ee Chhean was spotted in Siem

Reap at the same hotel where Ke Pauk stayed a few days after the breakaway.

What is clear is that the Anlong Veng deserters closely followed the Pailin/Malai

model, and are seeking semi-autonomy. "The same as Pailin," said Pich Chheang,

a senior defector, when asked what kind of system was wanted in Anlong Veng.

The decision to join the uprising was probably not a difficult one for people who

were historically close to Pol Pot such as Chheang, the KR deputy minister of defense

and an Anlong Veng deputy commander until he was sacked by Ta Mok.

"When Ta Mok toppled Pol Pot, people were surprised." remarked Chheang.

"The people knew that Pol Pot was the top leader and had protected the Democratic

Kampuchea movement for many years, so when he was charged with being a traitor, no-one

believed it."

Ke Pauk, who said he held no KR post since 1990, agreed that many people "did

not like Pol Pot's trial. They thought that even though he made some mistakes, he

was a good leader. People found out that Ta Mok was stricter."

The odd man out in the Anlong Veng insurrection is perhaps the main player, former

Div 980 commander Yim Phanna, who seemed to have every reason to be a Mok loyalist.

Phanna said he was a distant relative of former KR defence minister Son Sen, whose

murder on Pol Pot's orders last June that sparked Mok's seizure of power.

"I cannot say how much," Phanna replied when asked whether he was upset

at the execution of Son Sen and his entire family. "I was very, very angry."

Phanna, promoted to be a regional commander after Mok took control, added: "I

suggested to Ta Mok that Pol Pot be sent to an international court. Ta Mok did not

agree. He kept saying that if they sent Pol Pot to the international court, they

should send Hun Sen too.

"But a lot of people were very happy to see Pol Pot put on trial [in Anlong

Veng]. Ta Mok, he understood that the people wanted to send Pol Pot to a court."

Among a dozen or so senior- and lower-level defectors spoken to by the Post, opinions

differed on Pol Pot; some were happy to see him banished, while others expressed

sympathy for him. However, as one remarked in a comment echoed by virtually everyone:

"After he overthrew Pol Pot, Ta Mok said the people would have freedom, peace

and reconciliation. I was very happy. That's what Ta Mok said, but it was not true."

Several people said that their hopes for some kind of peace were raised - particularly

in the period when Funcinpec was negotiating with Anlong Veng in the month between

Pol Pot's overthrow and the July 5-6 fighting in Phnom Penh - but then dashed by


Did the new KR leader ever have any intention of seeking peace and integration, at

least in name, with the government? Yim Phanna, his former loyalist, claimed that

he did.

"Ta Mok spoke of reconciliation," said Phanna, who suggested that Mok realized

he had to deal with his arch-enemy Second Prime Minister Hun Sen. "As I understood

it, one part of Ta Mok's policy was reconciliation with Hun Sen.

"Yes, they are words I heard from Ta Mok with my own ears. One day I had a conversation

with Ta Mok about Hun Sen; he said that Hun Sen is a Khmer, so we have to deal with


So what changed? "After the events in Phnom Penh on July 5 and 6, Ta Mok joined

with the [Funcinpec] resistance forces," replied Phanna. "He changed his

beliefs about Hun Sen. After July, Ta Mok got stricter and stricter and wanted to

fight. But the commanders, the soldiers and the people, they didn't want war any


The will to fight, as one military observer suggested, had been replaced by other

desires a long time ago.

"From the military point of view, they were nearly inactive," the observer

said of Div 980 and most of the others around Anlong Veng. "They were there

to cut wood. There was no strategy to gain military benefits; that was not their

interest any more."

Phanna, meanwhile, got a taste of what continuing the war meant: earlier this year

he stepped on a home-made mine near Phnom Kulen - laid by the Funcinpec resistance,

he said with a wry grin - and was lucky not to lose his leg.

Why did he turn against the man who promoted him? Phanna replied: "The reason

I decided that Ta Mok was a bad man is that he kept on fighting this war."


  • Massive stingrays may live in Mekong’s deep pools

    US scientists have suggested that unexplored deep pools in the Mekong River in an area of Stung Treng could potentially be home to significant populations of giant freshwater stingrays, one of the world’s largest freshwater fish species. This comes as a fisherman hooked a 180

  • CCC team off on US business trip

    The Kingdom’s leading economists and private sector representatives have called on the US to renew its tax preferential status for Cambodian exports, as a Cambodia Chamber of Commerce (CCC) delegation departed for a weeklong business visit to the US, where they will meet with

  • PM takes time to meet, greet Cambodians living in the US

    After landing in the US ahead of the ASEAN-US Special Summit, Prime Minister Hun Sen was received by over 1,000 Cambodian-Americans including political analysts who welcomed him with greetings, fist bumps and selfies. Hun Sen also met with analyst Mak Hoeun, who had allegedly spoken ill

  • Khmer cinema classics back on big screen for free at WB Arena’s outdoor movies series

    On a recent Saturday evening at WB Arena, Bunsong was enjoying a tasty BBQ meal with his family after work on the long tables that had been arranged out in front of the restaurant as they watched a Khmer action movie on a big outdoor

  • PM heads to Washington for ASEAN-US special summit

    Regional and international issues and how to bring the ASEAN-US partnership to another level will be discussed at length as Prime Minister Hun Sen and his ministers arrive in Washington, DC, for a special summit on May 12-13. During the trip, Hun Sen and ASEAN

  • National Assembly refutes EU resolution

    The National Assembly (NA) has hit back at a European Parliament resolution condemning the political and human rights situation in Cambodia, calling it another display of the Parliament’s “double standards”. Key points of the resolution include a warning that the Parliament could exclude the