Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Questioning Short's Agenda



Questioning Short's Agenda

Questioning Short's Agenda

Replying to Craig Etcheson's criticism (Phnom Penh Post 17-30 December, 2004) of

his book Pol Pot: The History of a Nightmare, Philip Short asserts that he had 'attempted

to offer a balanced picture of the extremely complex mix of factors that underlay

the murderous specificity of Khmer Rouge rule' (Phnom Penh Post, January 14 - 27,

2005).

But this is not what emerges from his book. Short has a hidden agenda.

As Etcheson observed, Short uses the dubious concept of 'national character' to explain

what the Khmer Rouge did. He states that they were the 'heirs to a culture' (p.282)

and quotes Bernard-Philippe Groslier who wrote in 1921 that 'beneath a carefree surface

there slumber savage forces and disconcerting cruelties which may blaze up in outbreaks

of passionate brutality' (p.208). Furthermore, he asserts that Cambodian society

continues to allow people to commit appalling cruelties (p.13) and draws a parallel

between Khmer Rouge atrocities and rich men's wives nowadays pouring acid over their

husbands' young mistresses (p.12).

To support his speculations about Cambodian culture, Short quotes Alexander Laban

Hinton. But he omits that Hinton wrote that Cambodian culture is not 'inherently'

genocidal and that culturally distinct models of face and honor exist in most societies.

But these Cambodian cultural models have not caused genocide in other historical

periods. They only lead to mass violence within a certain context of historical and

socio-political change. For genocide to take place, these changes must be accompanied

by a violent ideology that adapts traditional cultural knowledge to its lethal purposes.

This is what happened in Cambodia, Hinton wrote.

Short claims that when the Cambodian communists instituted a slave state, they were

not motivated by revenge against a particular class or group (p.292), that there

were no central directives from the party leadership to kill elderly and sick people,

to loot libraries and destroy western things (p.283). 'What occurred was rather a

dysfunction of the Khmer Rouge polity, one of many that prevented Pol's vision of

the future ever being carried out' (p.292). Dysfunction?

Short explains the system of forced labor in Democratic Kampuchea with the Khmer

peasants being indolent, producing only enough to feed themselves (p.296). He writes

that the CPK leadership 'faced a genuine and all but insurmountable problem, which

had defeated the French, defeated Sihanouk, and has defeated every Cambodian government

since. The problem was: how to make Khmers work' (p.294). But who produced the 490,000

tons which were exported in 1965?

Short's conclusion is that 'Democratic Kampuchea was not a fatal exception in an

otherwise kindly world.' More than half of all UN member states have, or have had,

prisons resembling S-21 (p.365), he asserts. But how many of them killed 1/5 of the

population?

Even democratic governments have tortured and murdered like the Khmer Rouge, Short

tells us, and supports this statement with the case of the French army in Algeria,

which set up torture centres and then killed prisoners to maintain secrecy, exactly

the same justification as was used in Democratic Kampuchea. 'Five thousand Algerian

prisoners were killed in this way in one interrogation centre alone. In the country

as a whole, the number of such deaths probably exceeded the 15-20,000 who died in

S-21' (p.364). Short conveniently forgets those tortured and killed in the many local

prisons in Democratic Kampuchea.

Why does Philip Short trivialize the crimes that Pol Pot & Co. committed?

Maud Sundqvist

Stockholm, Sweden

MOST VIEWED

  • Phnom Penh placed in two-week lockdown

    The government has decided to place Phnom Penh in lockdown for two weeks, effective April 14 midnight through April 28, as Cambodia continues to grapple with the ongoing community outbreak of Covid-19, which has seen no sign of subsiding. According to a directive signed by Prime Minister

  • Cambodia on the verge of national tragedy, WHO warns

    The World Health Organisation (WHO) in Cambodia warned that the country had reached another critical point amid a sudden, huge surge in community transmission cases and deaths. “We stand on the brink of a national tragedy because of Covid-19. Despite our best efforts, we are

  • Hun Sen: Stay where you are, or else

    Prime Minister Hun Sen warned that the two-week lockdown of Phnom Penh and adjacent Kandal provincial town Takmao could be extended if people are not cooperative by staying home. “Now let me make this clear: stay in your home, village, and district and remain where

  • Businesses in capital told to get travel permit amid lockdown through One Window Service

    The Phnom Penh Municipal Administration has issued guidelines on how to get travel permission for priority groups during the lockdown of Phnom Penh, directing private institutions to apply through the municipality's One Window Service and limit their staff to a mere two per cent. In

  • Vaccination open to foreigners in Cambodia

    The Ministry of Health on April 8 issued an announcement on Covid-19 vaccination for foreigners residing and working in Cambodia, directing the Ministry of Labour and Vocational Training and local authorities to register them. Health minister Mam Bun Heng, who is also head of the inter-ministerial

  • Ministry names types of business permitted amid lockdown

    The Ministry of Labour and Vocational Training singled out 11 types of business that are permitted to operate during the lockdown of Phnom Penh and Takmao town, which run through April 28. Those include (1) food-processing enterprises and slaughterhouses; (2) providers of public services such as firefighting, utility and