Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Refugees afraid to come back home

Refugees afraid to come back home

Refugees afraid to come back home

Jim Eckardt visits Huay Chang camp in Surin to report on the conditions of 18,000

of the 61,600 Khmers now living in refuge in Thailand, and asks them where they believe

their future lies.

Refugee camps can quickly gain a feeling of permanence the camps on the Thai border

that lasted from 1979 to 1992 were nearer city-states than camps. But the Huay Chang

camp in Surin, Thailand is different.

Only eight months old, it houses 18,000 mostly Funcinpec supporters in flimsy bamboo

huts. The whole idea is to abandon this camp in time for the July 26 elections. But

no one seems eager to go back to Cambodia.

At 10:40 on a Friday morning, March 6, clouds of red dust are churned up by earth

movers building a giant new reservoir. Desultory rolls of razor wire surround the

tents of the Thai Army communications center, the UN refugee registration team and

the hospital.

Trucks drop off baskets of dried fish, distribution overseen by Thai soldiers barking

into walkie-talkies. At the UNHCR tent, Salika, a cheerful Thai worker, observes

that there is no rush to the border after the announcement of Prince Ranariddh's

possible return home.

Camp chief Hang Yuth arrived in the camp via O'Smach after one of the shortest ever

terms in office as a second deputy governor of Siem Reap.

"I was formally sworn in as vice governor one day before the coup," he

says laughing.

During last July's coup he managed to contact his wife and told her to take their

son and daughter to the border.

When his camp at O'Smach was shelled last August he led 22,000 refugees, predominantly

Funcinpec supporters, across the border to Thailand.

Now he oversees a committee that has jurisdiction over the six sections of the camp,

each of which houses 2,000 to 4,000 people.

So far 4,000 people have returned to Cambodia, most with the assistance of the UNHCR.

But Yuth says the remaining people are reluctant to leave.

"The UNHCR interviews people three times a week, but most are waiting for peace

and real democracy in Cambodia.

"We would like to return to vote in the elections but will Hun Sen respect human

rights? This is the main point. Our position now is to wait and see."

Meanwhile the waiting is not comfortable.

Ly San, the camp security chief, says it has been hard setting up the camp.

"There are 20 of us on the committee in charge of health, sanitation, record-keeping

and so on.

"In the beginning, we had only tents and they were very hot. And the water wasn't

clean and we had a lot of dysentery. We still don't have enough good drinking water.

We have a problem with flies and keeping the latrines clean.

"Khmer, Thai and farang doctors staff the medical tent. Serious cases are sent

to the hospital in Surin."

He says people eke out a living weaving thatch or breaking stones for the new reservoir

at 50 baht a day.

The huts, adorned with laundry lines and tiny vegetable plots, slope down a dried

mud wasteland to a small reservoir.

In the late afternoon women and children squat in line to fill 20-gallon plastic

jugs with drinking water from the 20 stand pipes put in by the Red Cross.

Wells supply washing and cooking water.

Open concrete drains spill sewage down to the reservoir which is lined with concrete


Shops sell vegetables, fruit, meat, clothes, gold jewelry, beer and cigarettes. There

is a barber shop and a Buddhist temple.

The head of the camp's medical unit, Pis Pirapong, says: "We get malaria cases

from O'Smach. But there is not much malaria in the camp itself."

Not surprisingly, given the Funcinpec loyalties of the refugees, many are bitter

about their treatment by the government.

Chaaem Pet says he was forced to flee from Phnom Penh six months ago when the government

shut down the newspaper he worked for while a student.

"I would contribute articles against Hun Sen, for 5,000 riel a story, in order

to put myself through school."

After the papers closed he decided to take a more active role against the government

but it ended prematurely.

"Four months ago, I contacted General Nhek Bun Chhay by phone. Fifteen of my

friends fled with me. I made my way to Surin for a month, then I came down with malaria

at the Tatum base, and was sent here where I've become the clerk in the hospital."

He says he will not return to Cambodia under the present regime.

"Hun Sen is a very violent man. There is no democracy."

Pen Vuthy, a former army major, is one of the camp committee members. He says he

arrived after being driven north by the fighting. "I hated the Hun Sen coup,"

he says.

"On July 5, 1997, I left Soi Sanon district to fight against Hun Sen. We were

pushed back to O'Smach and now I'm here."

Vuthy looks back to 1993 and says he would like to see an international solution

to Cambodia's problems.

"The world community, the ASEAN troika and the United Nations have to put pressure

on Hun Sen to control the situation.

"There are a lot of dramatic happenings right now. Officials of Funcinpec and

the BLDP are being killed. We need an authority like UNTAC to separate the parties.

"The Japanese plan to organize elections between Fun-cinpec and the CPP has

come very late. Four months to election is a short time."

Dr Sam Sareth, a former district officer of Samrong, in Oddar Meanchey province,

and Naek Sony, former Secretary General of Funcinpec Battambang, say they do not

see themselves resuming their official duties soon.

"I'm afraid of Hun Sen's soldiers," Naek Sony says simply.

Dr Sam Sareth, camp chief assistant, is the record keeper. He says that 4,300 huts

shelter some 3,767 refugee families, plus groups of unattached people.

Men and boys number 10,147; women and girls 7,853.

Thirty percent of the refugees fled from Siem Riep, 20% from Battambang, 40% from

Oddar Meanchey - all provinces close to the northwestern border. Ten percent came

from other provinces.

The UNHCR says that, as of the end of February, there were 14,838 people in Surin

and, in two camps in Trat, 34,993 and 11,778 people respectively.

Sareth became a medical doctor in 1960. After working in a hospital in Phnom Penh

until 1967, he transferred to Battambang.

He labored in the fields during the Pol Pot era, then resumed work at Battambang

hospital after the Vietnamese invasion. He was sent for further study in China in

1986 for two years.

After the 1993 elections, he became a brigadier-general in the medical corps, and

then district officer of Samrong.

After the July coup, he fled with his wife and daughter to the border. Five other

children live with a relative in Cambodia under assumed names.

"I'm afraid to go back," he says.

"It's no secret who I am, and I will die.

"I would like to return for the elections but only if there's peace. If there

are too many 'accidents', I can't go. I just have to wait and see.

"We'd all be happy to leave here, but only if there is peace."

And he says it is no longer simple to just return.

"The CPP has confiscated my house for example. Other people here have lost their

houses and many are poor.

Naek Sony was a student in Battambang when the Khmer Rouge seized power.

After the usual stint in the fields, he became an information officer in Battambang

under the Vietnamese-installed Heng Samrin regime.

In 1986, he defected to the Sihanouk resistance forces. After the 1993 elections,

he became Funcinpec secretary-general in Battambang.

"When the coup started, the police and soldiers of the Hun Sen regime tried

to find me," Naek Sony recalls.

"They remembered my face. I drove to Poipet, then walked to O'Smach with my

wife. Two children are still in Phnom Penh. I hope to go back to Cambodia if there

is freedom and peace and democracy.

"What I would like is a political situation like Thailand," says Sony.

"I would like a strong king, like the Thai king. I know the spirit of Hun Sen.

When I was with the communist government, I studied for six months in Saigon. The

communist ideology we were taught was for an army without a king. The Vietnamese

wanted to combine the whole region under communism."

For many of the residents this is not their first experience of life in a refugee


"I came here on August 27, 1997, and I'm afraid to go back," says Boon

Sakon. "I was a housewife in Samrong district where my husband was a captain

in the army and in charge of the military hospital.

"He is fighting in O'Smach now. My four children are with me," she said.

Boon Sakon is part of a yo-yoing generation of border refugees.

She came to Surin in 1979 when she fled with her family to Site B after the Vietnamese


She returned to Cambodia in 1992, then fled back to Thailand after the coup.

"All my friends were afraid and came here," she says. "I want to go

back and vote if there is peace and good government, but I'm not sure when that will


She says even if it is stable enough for her to return for the elections the results

will decide if she stays or not. "If the elections choose Hun Sen, I will run

away again."

Lee Chan Too was a shopkeeper in Sisophon. She followed her husband to O'Smach, where

for the past two years he has worked as a Thai translator with the customs department.

She set up another shop in O'Smach but it was flattened during artillery shelling.

She wants to return home but only if the fighting stops.

Yoon Chan Too is the wife of a Funcinpec official, a district officer in Bavel district,


Her husband, formerly with the Lon Nol army, has been with Ranariddh's forces since

1979. "My house has been confiscated by the CPP," she says, "but I

still want to go home and vote. I think Prince Ranariddh has a chance to win. If

he says to go back for the elections, I will.

"But there will still be danger and I'll still be afraid. Ask Hun Sen not to

shoot and kill people but to help the poor."

The stories soon become all too familiar - camp section chief Chan Song was a provincial

Funcinpec chief in Svay Rieng province. He says he came to the camp after a number

of attempts on his life.

"Before the coup, I escaped three assassination attempts.

"After the coup, I was lucky that I wasn't killed like the 44 Funcinpec officials.

"Who will find the killers of these men?

"My wife and five children are still in Svay Rieng. I don't know how they are

doing now. I would like to go back to fight for democracy again but one by one, step

by step, Funcinpec is being destroyed.

"I'm familiar with the Japanese plan to make the country calm again.

"I will go back to Cambodia only after a new government wins the election. If

Hun Sen wins, I will never go back."

"You have to understand Cambodian society," Hang Yuth says philosophically.

"Khmers have been killing Khmers for the past twenty years. We look at each

other as the enemy and we try to destroy each other.

"People die in battle and then we want to take vengeance.

"The UN report by Thomas Hammarberg showed that 44 Funcinpec officials were

murdered in the coup.

"But nobody has discovered anything about this. Whatever Hun Sen does is legal,

because he is the government.

"So people in this camp are frightened. If we go home, we must die. Some people

have returned from the camp to Cambodia but they are the common people. They can

keep their ideology a secret.

"If you look normal and ordinary in Cambodia, you will have no problem. But

if you were a big official, everybody knows you.

"It's very difficult to go back. Can the Friends of Cambodia control Hun Sen?

"Who can bring to trial the murderers of the 44 Funcinpec officials?

"If we go back, we will die for no reason.

"It's one thing to die for democracy, but to die for no motive - no trial, just

a massacre - is to die like a domestic animal."


  • ‘Education’ a priority traffic-law penalty

    A top National Police official on June 21 neither rejected nor confirmed the authenticity of a leaked audio message, which has gone viral on social media, on a waiver of fines for a number of road traffic-related offences. General Him Yan, deputy National Police chief in

  • Siem Reap’s $18M zoo said to educate public, help wildlife

    Angkor Wildlife and Aquarium Co Ltd has invested $18 million in a zoo in Siem Reap province, which will be opened in October to educate and promote animal conservation as well as attract national and international tourists. Currently, the Angkor Wildlife and Aquarium is building the

  • Volunteer scheme to foster ‘virtuous’ humanitarian spirit

    A senior education official said volunteer work contributes to solidarity and promotes a virtuous humanitarian spirit among the youth and communities. Serei Chumneas, undersecretary of state at the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport, made the comment during the opening of a training programme called “

  • Chinese firms unveil preliminary results on metro, monorail for capital

    Minister of Public Works and Transport Sun Chanthol and representatives from China Road and Bridge Corp (CRBC) and its parent company, the state-owned China Communications Construction Co Ltd (CCCC), met on June 24 for talks on results of the firms’ preliminary study on a potential metro

  • Nestle’s debut may spur dairy market

    Leading confectionery manufacturer Nestle plans to invest in Cambodia by setting up an operation in the near future, a move majorly hailed by local dairy farmers as a means of boosting the fresh milk market in the Kingdom. During a visit by a delegation led

  • ACLEDA, WU to enable global money transfers

    Cambodia's largest commercial bank by total assets ACLEDA Bank Plc and global money transfer firm Western Union (WU) have partnered to offer customers cross-border money transfers to 200 countries via “ACLEDA mobile” app. In Channy, president and group managing director of ACLEDA, said the June 22 agreement