Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Road to Thailand one of hope, despair

Road to Thailand one of hope, despair

Road to Thailand one of hope, despair

THEY sell their cows and pigs, and borrow more money. They cross the border, paying

the middlemen who promise them jobs in Bangkok. They are convinced they will return

home richer. A few do, but the others end up in Suan Phlu detention center before

being packed off back to Cambodia, penniless and in debt.

"My family thought I was dead," says Koy Suon, who last year spent six

months in Thailand - 27 days working as a construction laborer and five months in


Suon, a farmer, is one of thousands of Cambodians who go to Thailand to try to earn

a relative fortune. Many, caught as illegal immigrants, pay a heavy price.

"Twenty-seven days after we started to work on the construction site, the police

arrested us," he recalls.

"They had no uniforms on, otherwise we could have fled. They arrived about 5pm

when we were having baths. They put us in handcuffs and pushed us. We stayed five

months in jail."

Suon, 39, had lost so much weight by the time he returned to his home of Chom Nom,

Battambang province, that his wife barely recognized him.

He had also lost all that he earned in his brief employment and now, back at home,

has to repay his neighbors who lent him money to go to Thailand.

He was unlucky but others - such as Ra, a fellow farmer from Chom Nom - are more


In three months of carting bags at a Bangkok warehouse, Ra earned $400 - far more

than he could in Cambodia. When his next rice crop is harvested, he says, he'll go

back to Thailand to work.

About 100,000 Cambodians are working illegally in Thailand, according to Thai authorities.

About 1,000 a month cross into Thailand, the Cambodian Embassy in Bangkok estimates.

They cross in groups - ten, 20, 30 or many more people - in the evening, helped by

middlemen on both sides of the border.

Thousands later get caught and sent back - 3,600 so far this year. The majority of

those came from Battambang and Banteay Meanchey provinces, which border Thailand.

During the Pol Pot regime and the later State of Cambodia, there was a similar situation

as Cambodians tried to reach refugee camps within Thailand.

"The crossing points the illegal workers use today are the same as the ones

used in the 1980s," says a Battambang social worker who spent time in the camps.

"The middlemen are the same too."

Most of the illegal crossings occur around the border town of Poipet, where seasonal

immigration - such as Khmers crossing over in the daytime to work in sugar cane fields

near Aranyaprathet and then back to their homes in Cambodia at night - has occurred

for years.

"Today, the immigration is a typical economic problem between rich and poor

countries," says the aid worker. "Thailand attracts everyone who wants

to win a bit more money."

While the Cambodian immigration office in Phnom Penh says most of the immigrants

remain around the border area - with only about five percent going to work in Thai

cities or ports - Suon and Ra tell a different story.

Suon tried his luck with Hom Hun, his son-in-law.

"The guide used to come very often to our village to offer to take me across

the border. He said over there, you are going to earn a lot of money."

"The hunger pushed me to go," he says. "I have four children and my

rice fields were flooded.

"I sold two pigs and two cows and borrowed 1,500 baht ($60) from my neighbors."

Suon and Hun left Chom Nom at 7am on a moto trailer which picked up other people

along the way.

"We arrived in Poipet around 6pm. There we paid the middleman. Both of us paid

him 4,000 baht ($160).

"We were a group of 17 people, plus the middleman. We started to walk along

the canal. Then we crossed. We reached Aranyaprathet at 11pm where the Thai middleman

was waiting for us. We hid in a cattle truck and drove all night on the small roads."

The next morning the group reached Bangkok. The middleman took them to a construction

site and negotiated with the company boss.

The following day all 17 Cambodians drove all day before reaching somewhere near

the sea, and slept the night on a beach. The next morning, a boat took them to an

island where there was a construction site.

Suon still doesn't know where he was in Thailand, or the name of the island, but

the group worked there for 27 days.

They signed a contract. The working hours were 7am-noon, and 1-5pm. They were given

free food and slept in small rooms, three people to each.

"The Thais said we should get 1,950 baht ($78) every two weeks but in fact they

only gave us 820 baht ($32) . They told us that the money had not arrived yet,"

explains Suon.

Then the police came and arrested them, after a tip-off from Thai workers on the

island, he believes.

"We were sent in front of a judge. I understood we were condemned to one and

a half months in jail. Actually we spent five months there, without going out."

The jail was Suan Phlu detention center in Bangkok. The 17 men were initially put

into one small cell but, after three days, five were moved to another cell.

"During the five months, I never saw the sun's rays. We didn't have a mosquito

net, we didn't have a mat. When we got a fever, we didn't have any medicine.

"We tried to ask why we stayed more than the one and a half months we had been

sentenced to, but the guards wouldn't answer us," Suon says.

Visitors to the center confirm the conditions are poor. One regular visitor said

the inmates were packed in "like animals."

The Cambodian Embassy in Bangkok claims to have got all Cambodians out of the center,

and sent back home. The last convoy of Khmers sent home, earlier this month, included

268 people.

"Today, I can say that no more Cambodians are being detained. But tomorrow some

will arrive again. New people arrive every day," said Heng Vuddhara, First Secretary

at the embassy, on June 6.

"We have to dissuade them from coming," he said. "Tell them not to

come. For the illegal workers, it is hell here. They have to pay about 3,000 baht

[to cross the border] and then they go to jail."

He noted the story of one man who entered Thailand three times and was sent back

three times.

The Thai Embassy in Phnom Penh agrees the problem is big, but wouldn't confirm any

widespread involvement of Thai firms.

"Thai companies need labor from neighboring countries, and some Thai companies

may try to exploit the situation," said one official.

"But we don't need all kinds of workers...The importation of workers has to

be regulated."

Some Cambodians, he said, just ended up begging on Bangkok streets.

The official disputed that illegal workers were put in jail, claiming they were just

charged with illegal immigration and returned to Cambodia.

In Chom Nom in Battambang - where about 10 families have got members who have tried

to work in Thailand - Ra is happy. His success in earning money in Bangkok makes

others envious.

"If you are careful, you can avoid being sent to jail. I am lucky, I know a

bit of Thai and that way there is no problem," he says.

Ra prepared his crossing into Thailand well, and had known his middleman for some


He says he crossed at night at Bang Trakuon, about 30km north of Poipet, where refugees

used to cross to reach the camps in the 1980s.

"We were escorted by five soldiers and there where three middlemen, one Thai

and two Cambodians. Altogether, maybe there were 60 of us in total," said the

young man.

The group rested in some hills after walking for three days and two nights, before

cars were arranged to pick them up.

They were taken to Bangkok, where Ra was given a job carrying bags of fertilizer.

"One bag, 50 kilograms, 1 baht. Sometimes, in twelve hours, I could earn 600

baht," he says.

A nearby factory with Khmer workers got raided by police, he says, but his own factory

was safe: "You know, the boss paid the police."

Ra paid for his food, and slept in the factory to save money. He worked there for

three months, with 10 days off.

He earned 10,000 baht ($400). Each month, he would send 1,000 baht ($40) back to

his family in Cambodia via friends, who he would pay $4 for the service.

Back in Chom Nom, Ra is sure he will return to Thailand.

"Here, even if we work hard, we do not earn enough of a living for our children."

Suon, after his jail experience, is unlikely to return: "Pol Pot was like a

jail but we could go out to find food. In Bangkok, that was impossible."


  • Hun Sen: Stop Russia sanctions

    Prime Minister Hun Sen said sanctions against Russia as a result of its military offensive in Ukraine should be stopped as they have produced no tangible results, and predicted that a global food crisis would ensue in 2023 as a consequence. Speaking to an audience at

  • Chinese tourists 2.0 – Coming anytime soon?

    Regional tourism is grappling with the absence of the prolific travellers and big spenders – the Chinese tourists. Cambodia, which has welcomed over two million Chinese tourists before Covid-19, is reeling from the economic loss despite being the first to fully open last November ‘To put

  • PM reflects on shoe throwing: Free speech or act of violence?

    Prime Minister Hun Sen on May 17 questioned whether a man who threw a shoe at him while he was in the US was exercising freedom of expression or if it was an act of hostility. Hun Sen was referring to an incident last week when

  • Siem Reap’s Angkor Botanical Garden opens

    The Angkor Botanical Garden was officially opened on May 19 with free entry for both local and international visitors for the first six weeks. The garden was established on a nearly 15ha plot of land in Siem Reap. “After the first six weeks, Angkor Botanical Garden

  • Pub Street on the cards for Battambang

    The Battambang Provincial Authority has announced that it is considering establishing a Pub Street in the area around the heritage buildings in Battambang town in a bid to attract more tourists. Battambang provincial governor Sok Lou told The Post that the establishment of a Pub

  • Hun Sen: Don’t react to hostility

    Prime Minister Hun Sen urged tolerance and thanked members of the Cambodian diaspora for not reacting to the hostility on display towards him by others while he was in the US to attend the May 12-13 ASEAN-US Special Summit in Washington, DC. In an audio