Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Saved from soup - but the bear trade goes on

Saved from soup - but the bear trade goes on

Saved from soup - but the bear trade goes on

THE chance rescue of a 6 week-old sun bear cub by Global Witness (GW) investigators

in Mondulkiri province, close to the Vietnamese border, has turned a spotlight on

the rampant trade in wildlife in Cambodia - and the difficulties the country faces

in protecting its endangered species.

En route to the Dac Dam border checkpoint to investigate illegal logging, GW members

Charmian Gooch and Simon Taylor stopped at a roadside dwelling where they were shown

the young cub imprisoned in a box.

"The woman there said she had been breast-feeding the bear. We were told that

a small boy had found the bear in the forest, but we felt dubious," recalled


The proximity of the bear to the border and the presence of a Chinese wildlife trader

in the area - who, as the GW later discovered, was also on the hunt for 24 baby elephants

- convinced Gooch and Taylor that the bear was bound for the soup pot.

"We felt the outcome for this bear was to become cooked in various ways,"

Taylor said wryly.

The Malaysian Sun Bear (helarctos malayanus) - protected from hunting and export

by a 1992 Ministry of Agriculture order and included on the Convention on the International

Trade in Endangered Species, which Cambodia is also set to join - is considered a

delicacy by Chinese consumers in particular, for its paws and gall bladder.

Extraction of these parts from the bear often involves great cruelty, according to

Taylor, who explained that the gall bladder and the bile are viewed as a "highly

esteemed Chinese medicine". Bear bile reportedly sells at about $100 per gram

in China.

"Often a steel tube is inserted into the gall bladder and the bear is literally

tapped for bile," said Taylor, who has also seen documentary footage of bears

whose paws were amputated while the animal was still alive.

Nevertheless, rescuing the bear cub posed a dilemma for the GW team, who said they

"agonized" over the decision. "We were very aware that you should

never buy a bear," said Taylor, noting that purchasing endangered wildlife,

even with good intentions, reinforces the illegal trade.

Despite their misgivings, Taylor and Gooch went ahead with their decision - at the

cost of $190 and a small bribe to get the bear cub by plane to Phnom Penh - in the

hope that their action would help expose the illegal wildlife trade in Cambodia's

remote northeast.

The head of Conservation at the government's Wildlife Protection Office (WPO), Sun

Hean, said he believes the trade, which includes bears, tigers and elephants, is

rampant. But he laments that a lack of funds has prevented the authorities from evaluating

the extent of the trade and the populations of endangered species.

"We have no idea how much is going on ... I'm very sad about that."

Hean cited weak legislation, corruption, and little education on the importance of

conservation as factors which allow the trade to flourish.

Stronger legislation - a 100-article Wildlife Management Law has been drafted by

Hean's office - and better enforcement would stop the trade at its source, but until

that comes about Hean urges confiscation of illegally traded wildlife by the authorities,

rather than purchasing the animals on the market.

Confiscated animals are taken to Ta Mao Zoo, 44 km south of Phnom Penh in Takeo province,

which currently holds more than 200 animals, from 60 species, including five adult

sun bears.

According to Hean, there are currently three private initiatives run by expatriates

involved in rescuing bears and other endangered wildlife.

One of these operations, run by Randy Steed, an American casino consultant, and partly

funded by the Australian organization Free the Bears Fund, has so far rescued five

sun bears, all which were purchased from Phnom Penh shops and restaurants at market

rates of $400 to $800.

Steed's menagerie, on the banks of the Mekong an hour and half by boat north of the

capital, currently holds two gibbons and a 15-month old sun bear.

With the permission of Cambodian authorities, Steed shipped three bears to Australia

in January, where they have helped kickstart a captive breeding program at Sydney's

Taronga Park Zoo. In return, the zoo is currently training three Khmers in wildlife


"You can only be so green," said Steed, adding that the argument against

purchasing bears "makes perfect sense in 95 percent of the world".

"If we didn't purchase them, they would have been eaten or died of stress and

abuse. We know it perpetuates the trade but there is no stopping the trade in Cambodia."

The efforts of Steed and the Free the Bears Fund have also touched a raw nerve in

Australian hearts - so far, A$40,000 has been raised through poster sales, much of

which has been channeled to support the WPO's Ta Mao Zoo.

While private initiatives have raised international awareness and much needed funds

for Cambodia's own efforts to protect its endangered wildlife, Hean maintained that

such efforts, in addition to reinforcing the illegal wildlife market, detract from

government moves to curb the trade.

"If they really want to help Cambodia and they really want to work with wildlife

conservation, they should come to my zoo where we have many confiscated animals,"

said Hean, adding that the draft legislation covers current loopholes which have

allowed endangered animals to be kept as pets in houses and in private menageries.

David Marks, a veterinary consultant with World Society for the Protection of Animals

(WSPA) which is providing technical assistance to the WPO, agrees that rescuing bears

by buying them at restaurants or market is a double-edged sword, but concludes that

there is a general agreement in animal conservation circles against the strategy.

"The consensus of opinion is (that) there is never any excuse or sound reason

to buy a bear from an illegal market," wrote Marks in a faxed message to the

Post from Thailand, where WSPA has built a sanctuary for the Asiatic Black Bear.

"If a bear is in a restaurant/market, a market for that bear exists - by buying

the bear without removing the market, the trader/restaurant requires another bear

to satisfy the original market."

"If an individual buys a bear, it is usually at a high price which further escalates

and encourages the trade," explained Marks.

For every bear bought from a restaurant or illegal market, an estimated 5-10 bears

are killed or removed from the wild, he estimated.

The WSPA veterinarian acknowledged that bear "rescue", and their shipment

to zoos outside Cambodia, remain "highly contentious" issues - last ditch

efforts to "save the species" in a country which is still a long way from

effective protection of its endangered species in the wild.

"Captive bears can play an important role as a focus for education and awareness,"

wrote Marks, but warned that a sun bear in a zoo makes a "limited" contribution

to conservation of the species.

"Until Cambodia can protect its natural resources in a broader sense, bears

will continue to be hunted."

As for the bear saved by GW, it is proving something of a headache for its foster

mother, expatriate Bree Fitzgerald, who volunteered to look after it in the meantime.

"My entire house has been turned into an obstacle course," said Fitzgerald,

describing the banana trees, straw mats and the wading pool set up to entertain her


Fitzgerald and the GW team are "collecting options" for the bear, which

include the more leafy surrounds of Steed's Mekong enclosure, the Ta Mao Zoo or bear

sanctuaries in Thailand. The director of Melbourne Zoo also expressed interest in

the bear on a recent visit to the capital.

"Keeping the bear in Cambodia would be ideal, but the situation in Cambodia

is not yet ideal for housing bears," Fitzgerald said.


  • Hun Sen: Full country reopening to be decided in two weeks

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has announced that if the Covid-19 situation remains stable for 15 consecutive days from the end of the October 5-7 Pchum Ben public holiday, Cambodia will reopen fully, albeit in the context of Covid-19 whereby people have to adjust their lives to

  • Cambodia sets new Covid-19 quarantine rules

    The government has modified Covid-19 quarantine requirements, shortening the duration for, among others, Cambodian officials, foreign diplomats and delegations, investors and inbound travellers in general. According to an official notice signed by Minister of Health Mam Bun Heng late on October 16, quarantine length for Cambodian

  • Cambodia unveils new quarantine regulations

    The government has modified Covid-19 quarantine requirements, shortening the duration for, among others, Cambodian officials, foreign diplomats and delegations, investors and inbound travellers in general. According to an official notice signed by Minister of Health Mam Bun Heng late on October 16, quarantine length for Cambodian

  • Will Evergrande change the way Chinese developers do business in Cambodia?

    China’s property sector policy has exposed the grim financial condition of real estate developers including those operating in Cambodia, which raises questions over the viability of their projects and business going forward The dark blue netting draping over one of Yuetai Group Co Ltd’

  • Hun Sen: Cambodia set to fully reopen

    Prime Minister Hun Sen concludes that the October 5-7 Pchum Ben public holiday, during which many people either flocked to their hometowns for family reunion or gathered at tourist attractions across the country, has not caused an outbreak of Covid-19. In a special address to

  • Phnom Penh governor: Show Covid-19 vaccination cards, or else

    Phnom Penh municipal governor Khuong Sreng late on October 5 issued a directive requiring all people aged 18 and over and the parents of children aged 6-17 to produce Covid-19 vaccination cards when entering schools, markets, malls, marts, eateries and other business establishments that have been permitted