Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Sentences heavy in 'unfair' trial

Sentences heavy in 'unfair' trial

Sentences heavy in 'unfair' trial

EIGHTEEN men and one woman were sentenced to lengthy jail terms ranging between five

years and life in the Phnom Penh Municipal Court February 28 in the latest of a series

of trials of the outlawed Cambodian Freedom Fighters.

"The court understands that the suspects are a network under the guidance and

orders of Chhun Yasith, the CFF ring leader outside the country since 11 October

1998," said Judge Sek Sethamony handing down his sentence.

The 20 on trial were drawn from the 64 alleged CFF members arrested in September

and October 2001. Authorities claimed that the CFF was preparing a further assault

on Cambodia.

Cambodian American Sao Gilbert, who was named in documents as the CFF's deputy minister

for information, was sentenced to ten years in prison. Gilbert, who had worked with

Chhun Yasith in California, said just one word while being lead away from the trial:


Observers of the trial agreed and labeled the trial 'unfair' and no improvement on

the previous two heavily criticized CFF trials.

"The issues are the same as the last two trials," said Naly Pilorge, acting

director of human rights NGO Licadho.

Licadho, which has sent observers to each trial, criticized the lack of access to

lawyers, lack of adequate medical care for the accused, the absence of arrest warrants

in some cases, and the breaching of both the Cambodian Constitution and international

conventions regarding suspects' rights.

Yin Ngim, accused of being the director of the CFF's Thai headquarters, was sentenced

to 20 years in prison on charges of terrorism and membership of an armed group. Ek

Chan Ee, also accused of a leadership role, received a life sentence. David Chan

and Sry Sreng both received 20 years and Me Sam Oeun, a former Funcinpec commune

candidate, received 15 years.

Self-confessed CFF leader Chhun Yasith was tried in absentia for the second time

and was sentenced to 20 years in addition to his previous life sentence.

One man, Sok Khy, was not sentenced but the judge said he would remain under investigation.

The men accused of bombing the Vietnamese embassy in Phnom Penh in April 2001 were

both given eight years and the four men accused of bombing Funcinpec headquarters

and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs were sentenced to between eight and 15 years.

Francesca Marotta of the UN's Human Rights office said the trial revealed "the

structural problems of Cambodian justice".

"We have some serious concerns on the fairness and adequacy of the evidence,

the use of confessions and the defense rights of the accused. A serious shortcoming

was the right to an adequate defense," she said.

In previous trials human rights groups had access to the accused and were able to

refer them to lawyers from Cambodian Defenders Project and Legal Aid Cambodia. But

no access was granted to the 64 people arrested on CFF charges since September 2001.

The court appointed Puth Theavy as their defense lawyer.

Recognizing the inherent conflict of interest, the judge informed both the lawyer

and the accused that the suspects could be provided with a new lawyer at any time.

Despite the fact that numerous suspects accused each other of CFF involvement, none

took up the offer to change representation.

Theavy denied that conflict of interest was an issue because his clients were convicted

on documentary evidence and not on each other's accusations.

"There were two kinds of evidence," he said. "Testimony written by

the police and the documents from Richard Kiri Kim's computer. I protested about

this in the court because there are around 20,000 names in the computer. If the government

convicted them all they could not afford the rice to feed them in the prison."

Time and again during the trial the suspects rejected their written statements, saying

confessions were forced or claiming they did not recognize them.

"Sixty percent of the statements were wrong," said Theavy.

However, the majority of the court's time during the five-day trial was taken up

by the judge interrogating the various suspects. The defense lawyer and the prosecutor

confined themselves to only a few minutes of questioning.

The judge cajoled the accused to confess to terrorist activities.

"You should answer with bravery like An Mao [the CFF commander who boasted of

involvement during the first CFF trial]. You should answer like a commander,"

the judge told Yin Ngim at one point.

The court also presented 145 pages of evidence collected by Thai police in a raid

on house in Bangkok. The documents included a list of 37 people, some of whom had

been convicted in earlier CFF trials, a "battle plan" for Phnom Penh outlining

the CFF goal to attack the Ministry of Interior, CFF recruitment letters and a July

2001 faxed letter from the CFF's US-based leader Chhun Yasith.

The shortest sentence of five years was handed out to Sok Nhor, wife of convicted

CFF leader An Mao. While reading her statement during the trial the judge stopped

several times to express sympathy for her.

"This makes me want to cry," he said at one point while reading the tale

of misery that was her life.

A further 16 detainees are scheduled to go on trial in Battambang provincial court

from March 4.


  • Construction begins on $1.5B Kampot seaport

    The International Multi-Purpose Logistics and Port Centre, principally invested by Kampot Logistics and Port Co Ltd and projected to cost $1.5 billion, has officially broken ground in Bokor town, Kampot province. The multi-purpose logistics and port centre, located in Prek Tnaot commune, will be built on

  • Cambodia eyes key role in electronics, auto hubs in SEA

    Two roadmaps, part of the LDC’s economic diversification plan, were designed to see it through its migration process, but experts say the journey might be arduous, particularly in the presence of two established hubs in the region By 2028, Cambodia hopes to have exited the

  • Hun Neng, lawmaker and PM’s brother, passes away aged 72

    Hun Neng, chairman of the 4th Commission of the National Assembly, has passed away from heart disease at the age of 72 on the afternoon of May 5, according to the Ministry of Information. Hun Neng is the older brother of Prime Minister Hun Sen, and was

  • Massive stingrays may live in Mekong’s deep pools

    US scientists have suggested that unexplored deep pools in the Mekong River in an area of Stung Treng could potentially be home to significant populations of giant freshwater stingrays, one of the world’s largest freshwater fish species. This comes as a fisherman hooked a 180

  • PM meets with US business giants

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has met with a number of major US companies who have expressed interest in investing in Cambodia, in a meeting convened by the US-ASEAN Business Council (US-ABC). A delegation of companies – including Amazon, Meta, Chevron, ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil, Ford, Visa and Pernod

  • CCC team off on US business trip

    The Kingdom’s leading economists and private sector representatives have called on the US to renew its tax preferential status for Cambodian exports, as a Cambodia Chamber of Commerce (CCC) delegation departed for a weeklong business visit to the US, where they will meet with