Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - South China Sea consensus? Not so fast

South China Sea consensus? Not so fast

South China Sea consensus? Not so fast


Philippine President Benigno Aquino attends an ASEAN meeting in Phnom Penh yesterday, Monday, Nov. 19, 2012. Photograph: Pha Lina/Phnom Penh Post

As Cambodia struggles to keep this week’s ASEAN Summit as smooth as possible following its often-criticised performance at the July meeting, one day in, rifts have already begun to appear regarding the South China Sea issue.

Yesterday, a day after Cambodia announced that regional leaders were in agreement not to “internationalise” disputes within the resource-rich sea, the Philippines said the claim was simply inaccurate.

“Various views were expressed on ASEAN unity that were translated by the chair into an ASEAN consensus. This was not the understanding of both the Philippines and at least one other country,” Filipino Secretary of Foreign Affairs Albert del Rosario told reporters during an interview that took place on the sidelines of yesterday’s meet.

A formal letter was sent to the chair and ASEAN foreign ministers outlining the Philippines’ position, added del Rosario.

One of the chief claimants in the South China Sea, the Philippines has long sought to counter China’s claim by seeking assistance from third-party states – particularly the US.

That position has put them at odds with China, and, at times, China’s supporters within ASEAN, which has pushed for bilateral resolutions.

Discord over the two viewpoints led to fallout during the last summit, when the bloc was unable to agree upon a joint communiqué for the first time in its 45-year-history.

A cautious six-point agreement was later endorsed, but only following intense shuttle diplomacy efforts by Indonesian Foreign Minister Marty Natalegawa.

Whether those same tensions will undermine this week’s meet is not yet clear.

If the South China Sea does not come up during today’s East Asian Summit, however, the Philippines would definitely raise it, members of the Filipino delegation confirmed yesterday.

Japan and the US, meanwhile, also took hard lines on the issue of the South China Sea, with both of them raising it in meetings with ASEAN member states, stressing concerns over the security threats posed by tensions in the sea.

In a press briefing given late last night, Ministry of Foreign Affairs Secretary of State Kao Kim Hourn confirmed that US President Barack Obama raised the issue in yesterday’s ASEAN-United States leaders meeting, but said there was no immediate response from the regional leaders.

“Each country’s leaders is free to raise any issues,” he said.

The Japanese government, meanwhile, issued a statement following the ASEAN-Japan leaders meet, saying: “Prime Minister Noda raised the issue of the South China Sea, noting that this is of common concern for the international community, and would have a direct impact on peace and stability of the Asia-Pacific.”

But the growing clamour from abroad and disagreements within ASEAN over how to address those outside voices appeared to have fallen on deaf ears for China, which yesterday thanked ASEAN for its commitment to not internationalise the discussion.

“For many years, peace and stability have been maintained in the South China Sea, this is a proof that discussion and communication between China and ASEAN countries are effective and should be valued,” said Qin Gang, spokesperson for the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

All of which puts ASEAN at a delicate impasse. ASEAN officials as well as those from Thailand and Indonesia yesterday cautiously sidestepped questions about whether there had indeed been a consensus among leaders regarding the issue of internationalisation.

After one reporter asked, for the third time, a point blank question as to whether the Cambodian statement regarding consensus was accurate, a Indonesian presidential spokesman, Teuku Faizasyah, would only reply: “I can’t comment on what Cambodia said.”

To contact the reporter on this story: Cheang Sokha at [email protected]
With assistance from Abby Seiff


  • Prince injured, wife dies after accident

    THE wife of former First Prime Minister Prince Norodom Ranariddh, Ouk Phalla, 39, died while the prince was “severely” injured following a road accident in Preah Sihanouk province’s Prey Nub district on Sunday morning, officials said. Rananriddh, who is also the president of the Funcinpec

  • Guards protest dismissals, reject claims of sharing naked photos of child

    Some 20 former security guards at the US Embassy in Phnom Penh protested on Tuesday against their dismissal. They accused their employers of falsely claiming they had viewed and shared child pornography from their mobile phones as grounds for their termination. In total, 32 personnel were dismissed

  • Bun Heang mocks US, threatens its citizens in scathing open letter

    After being hit with sanctions from the US Department of Treasury, Cambodian General Hing Bun Heang said he would retaliate against any US national who does not respect his country’s sovereignty, has ambitions to invade Cambodia or incites “traitors” in the Kingdom to do

  • Funcinpec urges probe into deadly Preah Sihanouk accident

    THE Funcinpec party has urged the government, especially the Ministry of Interior, to investigate the traffic accident in Preah Sihanouk province which left Prince Norodom Ranariddh badly injured and his wife Ouk Phalla dead. Funcinpec Vice President You Hokry told reporters at Botum Votey pagoda,