The indignation of William Shawcross and Steve Heder (Post, Oct 18-30) in both
cases is characterized by the straining at gnats with which liberal defenders of
the status quo typically try to distract attention from their breakfast of a camel
and a water buffalo or two.
Shawcross reads non-existent "sneers at King Sihanouk" into the letter
of Craig Etcheson of the Cambodia Genocide Program (Post, Sept 20-Oct 3) but that
fiction pales before his description of Julio Jeldres as someone who "has contributed
much to the restoration of civil society in Cambodia."
If true, that would only be compensation of a sort for Jeldres' past role as a supporter
of the Khmer Rouge - before they lost power. (Jeldres was made an "honorary"
- what a word - member of the KR's FUNK in 1971, and was still boasting of this fact
and defending the KR in letters in 1978). Unfortunately, his consistent role in Cambodian
politics since then has been to attack anyone and everyone who appears as a serious
opponent of the KR - often doing so in the guise of "attacking" the KR.
He does this with more fervor than intelligence, thus producing the absurd inconsistencies
of the sort referred to in Etcheson's letter.
Etcheson's mentioning of these inconsistencies is, according to Shawcross, "deeply
unprofessional conduct" and will enhance the "doubts" about the CGP
"which have been voiced". Voiced by whom, Mr Shawcross? Can't you spare
even a footnote? Was it perhaps Julio Jeldres? Or is this a reference to that other
scholar, Stephen Morris, whose previous claim to professional fame was the discovery
in Kremlin archives of "evidence" of US prisoners of war still held in
For his part, Heder uses a column and a half of your paper attacking the CGP for
not yet having delivered results it promised to produce in 1997. Those of us with
a satirical and "unprofessional" streak would suggest that someone give
Heder a current calender. No doubt Shawcross would praise Heder as "contributing
much to the restoration of chronology".
- Allen Myers, Sydney, Australia.
Contact PhnomPenh Post for full articlePost Media Co Ltd
The Elements Condominium, Level 7
Hun Sen Boulevard
Phum Tuol Roka III
Sangkat Chak Angre Krom, Khan Meanchey
12353 Phnom Penh
Tel: +855(0) 23 888 161 / 162
Fax: +855(0) 23 214 318