Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - "The struggle is dead - and for no meaning at all"



"The struggle is dead - and for no meaning at all"

"The struggle is dead - and for no meaning at all"

HOUR CHENG REFUGEE CAMP, Thailand - At the same time as the Khmer Rouge forces were

defecting to the government last weekend, the resistance forces under General Nhiek

Bun Chhay were contemplating their futures.

But unlike the KR, which appears united and committed to returning to the fold, there

is still a vein of mistrust in the minds of resistance forces and their families

- mainly, they say, because of the sidelining of Bun Chhay.

Bun Chhay commands strong personal loyalty and the govern-ment's refusal to give

him an appointment is seen by many of his followers as a warning that they too will

be abandoned.

And the approbation seems more directed towards Prince Ranariddh than Hun Sen.

One Funcinpec supporter living in the Prasat district of the Thai province, Surin

- at the refugee camp belonging to those who fled from O'Smach - condemned Ranariddh,

saying that as soon as he got into the government he abandoned his supporters.

"We are like the used sugar cane stick. Once the juice has been sucked out he

threw us away," he said.

He said that the Prince should be supporting them now more than ever because they

were the only ones who fought for democracy after the coup.

"The Prince should come and encourage us. He should not abandon us because we

were the people who struggled for democracy and helped him get back into power,"

he said. "Most of the people will not now trust him."

He added that the people believe they need Bun Chhay to protect them when they did

return because "the people need the strong man to go against the strong man".

The cause of the discontent relates to the Dec. 3 communiqué from Bun Chhay

ordering his forces to reintergrate with RCAF.

It is not the integration that is the issue - rather, it is the failure of the government

to find any role for Bun Chhay. Many here see this as a betrayal by Ranariddh of

one of his most loyal supporters.

Bun Chhay's communiqué left no room for doubt about his current position.

It says: "The complete responsibility and full right is given to General Khan

Savoeun and General Hun Phoeun to arrange the reintegration."

His own role in the process was, according to his communiqué, none. He added

his own future was up to the government to decide.

Deputy leader of the Hour Cheng camp, Pim Sambou, said that people were pleased Bun

Chhay had been amnestied but unhappy he had no official role. "Because Bun Chhay

has no appointment there will be no balance," he said. "Nhiek Bun Chhay

is a patriot. He has no faults."

Preap Tan, an officer in RCAF general staff, said this week that all former resistance

fighters who previously belonged to RCAF would be eligible to reintegrate with the

army.

He said RCAF had computerized personnel records that would allow them to check that

applicants for reintegration had been soldiers before July 1997. Those who were not

on record would not be accepted. The only exception to this decision is Bun Chhay.

Choeun Ny, the commander of Battalion 24, asked why Bun Chhay gave his forces over

to Savoeun and Phoeung, said: "[Bun Chhay] may be disappointed with his struggle

so he gave all the power to other people, and he now just stays in a quiet place."

He was told that Ranariddh rang Bun Chhay and told him to keep a low profile till

the next election, in five years time, at which point Ranariddh would look after

him.

Ny believes that the negotiations had been badly handled and had simply backed the

resistance forces into a corner. He added that many people had apparently wasted

their lives fighting for the resistance.

"We have to go back to the government," he said. "We cannot struggle

here because no one will support us any more even [US Congressman] Dana Rohrabacher.

Now all the opposition parties have joined to form the government no-one, like Thailand,

will support us. They will not give us land to live on and Rohrabacher cannot do

anything for us because he sees no point in helping us anymore.

"And now everything is finished. The struggle is dead - and for no meaning at

all."

Meanwhile the families of the soldiers in the refugee camp are uncertain that reintegration

will mean a better life for them.

Man San, 44, a village chief, said that he was concerned about going back to Cambodia

because he believed some people there still harbored resentment against the resistance

and might try and take revenge. "I do not trust them. What they say is right

but what they practice is different."

He added that the biggest concern for most of the families was the treatment of Bun

Chhay. "We use to work together but now we have lost one. We don't know the

reason. So now we are not living happily."

He said if Ranariddh did not protect someone like Bun Chhay, it seemed unlikely he

would do much more to look after those lower down.

However others said that they would probably risk a return, mainly because of poor

conditions at the camp. About 7,600 people are cramped in here and there is very

little land around it.

Till recently there had been 500 extra people for whom no rice was provided. People

say that some of those were people who had fled Phnom Penh during the demonstrations,

and who had since gone to O'Smach.

Many people try to make a living from trading or by producing handicrafts. There

are a full range of shops and services available here but few people have money to

shop.

Sok Chin, 44, who runs a store, says his income from trading is usually about 20

baht a day (2000 riel, or less than 50 cents).

Chin is one of the few in the camp who said he was still unconditionally loyal to

Funcinpec, however he admitted he did not understand the political changes happening

at the moment.

"But I believe that they will work together and I trust the Funcinpec leader."

The camp - which, if poor, is nevertheless well maintained - was moved to its present

site in April after flooding made conditions impossible at the previous site.

Most of those spoken to looked forward to the time when they would not have to rely

on the UN High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR) for hand-outs of rice.

"The people have to steal away to be laborers even though there is metal wire

around the camp and the practice is banned by the Thai guards. We have to go out

to find some cash to make up for the shortage of food," said Chin.

There is also a constant fear that the camp - made of wood and dried palm thatch,

and surrounded by barbed wire - could become a death trap.

Saroeun said if a fire caught hold it would spread quickly and many people would

die because there was no way to escape through the wire. Even the Thai guards acknowledge

that a fire in the camp would be fatal for many.

MOST VIEWED

  • Phnom Penh curfew starts today

    A two-week curfew from 8pm to 5am starts today in Phnom Penh, a day after a sub-decree detailing administrative measures to contain Covid-19 was issued by Prime Minister Hun Sen. “Travelling in Phnom Penh is temporally banned between 8pm and 5am,” said Phnom Penh governor

  • Cambodia on the verge of national tragedy, WHO warns

    The World Health Organisation (WHO) in Cambodia warned that the country had reached another critical point amid a sudden, huge surge in community transmission cases and deaths. “We stand on the brink of a national tragedy because of Covid-19. Despite our best efforts, we are

  • Cambodia gears up for muted New Year festival

    The recent curfew and restrictions imposed in the capital and other Covid-19 hotspots were intended to break the chain of transmission, Ministry of Health spokeswoman Or Vandine said as municipal and provincial authorities issued new directives banning certain activities during the upcoming Khmer New Year

  • Vaccination open to foreigners in Cambodia

    The Ministry of Health on April 8 issued an announcement on Covid-19 vaccination for foreigners residing and working in Cambodia, directing the Ministry of Labour and Vocational Training and local authorities to register them. Health minister Mam Bun Heng, who is also head of the inter-ministerial

  • Time to Rise by rapper, chapei legend is viral hit with ancient-modern mix

    Kong Nay is known internationally as the master of the chapei dang veng, a traditional Cambodian instrument resembling a long-necked lute or guitar with two nylon strings that he was already playing professionally by the age of 15. Nay is sometimes referred to as the Cambodian

  • Cambodia set for large-scale vaccination campaign as Covid spreads

    Prime Minister Hun Sen has instructed all provincial authorities to get ready for a large-scale vaccination campaign, with at least one million doses to be administered per month. “We will roll out at least one million doses. The vaccines we have purchased and received as