Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Try Ieng Sary again



Try Ieng Sary again

Try Ieng Sary again

The Editor,

A

ccording to international media, King Norodom Sihanouk has granted amnesty to

the Khmer Rouge dissidents' chief Ieng Sary.

As we are getting to know crimes committed by the Khmer Rouge towards the people

of Cambodia, it is worthwhile to find out how far this decision could reach.

Amnesty is usually defined as a measure to leave behind a public prosecutor's action

over offense to specific laws, but leave intact [the possibility] of civil action;

then anyone who suffers any harm is granted permission to claim legal redress.

Amnesty is not given to individuals mentioned by name; it is related to offenses

which are supposed to be pardoned. Anyone who is in that case can benefit from its

generosity.

Then - according to that amnesty - after putting Cambodia to sword and fire from

1975 to 1979, the Khmer Rouge are supposed to be cleared of charges. Everything is

going as if they were untarnished of any crime. The public prosecutor's action is

off, the Department of Public Prosecution is not able to re-educate offenders to

normal behavior. Only civil action for legal redress is still available.

Therefore any person who had members of their family killed or wounded, or houses

destroyed under the Khmer Rouge rule is allowed to make claims for compensation.

The millions of dollars (from illegal trafficking of logs and gems) kept by the KR,

whose treasurer was Ieng Sary, could be used as compensation for the losses suffered

by these people.

If Cambodia is really a lawful state, its leaders should take necessary and sufficient

measures to permit these claims to be brought to a successful conclusion. They cannot

avoid their responsibility for they pretend to be the sole legitimate authorities

for all the country, and should detain the treasurer of the Khmer Rouge. If they

abstain from doing so, they would take the risk of being accused of being accomplices

of Ieng Sary, who controls the Khmer Rouge gem mines.

As a matter of fact, the consequences of that kind of amnesty should be evaluated

in accordance with Cambodian civil society. If horrible crimes committed by the KR

are granted amnesty, there will be no reason to refuse amnesty for crimes ranging

from murder to robbery (which are seen every day in Cambodia). This performs the

deadlock of the Royal Amnesty.

As for the instant effect expected from this move - the cease-fire with part of the

Khmer Rouge - amnesty will not benefit the state of Cambodia or its chief. For the

rebels are convinced that they stop fighting only if they are granted impunity. Then,

amnesty becomes a pawn of the war game. It is no more an act of magnanimity from

the man who grants it, as it lowers him to the same level as pariahs in desperation.

In any case, bloody crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide, may not be faded

by amnesty without wounding society's ethics, and the nation's spirit and cohesiveness,

which are essential to the state's existence. At best, repentant criminals should

be granted a reprieve after a trial establishing all their deeds and ruling equitably

on their penalties.

Neither amnesty nor reprieves should be given without following the legal procedure.

Of course, by means of amnesty, the Parliament can wipe off retroactively crimes

defined by a law on amnesty, whoever its authors. Then, all the Khmer Rouge, even

the most cruel can enjoy impunity. Nobody can punish them, even though they are always

liable to repair they damage they caused to others; their civil responsibility is

preserved entirely.

Do they intend to reprieve only Ieng Sary, in exchange for his cease-fire? A reprieve

wipes off only the penalty, not the crime. In the past, Ieng Sary was condemned,

by a court ruled by Vietnam. Even though this trial is considered valid, it covered

only a period from 1975 to 1979. After 1979 until recently, the Khmer Rouge continued

their crimes in Cambodia: massacres at Phnom Vour, Kampot, Battambang, Anlong Veng,

Siem Reap...

Ieng Sary has to be tried again and to be kept in custody, in order to stop him from

continuing his deeds and to allow the judiciary to question him. When his case is

clarified, the court can sentence him according to all his behavior, with aggravating

or extenuating circumstances. Once his penalty is passed, the convict will be returned

to custody from where he can ask for a reprieve by arguing that he is repentant.

According to legal procedures, he could be summoned by his victims to answer his

civil responsibility, and has to meet any lawsuit by giving up his Khmer Rouge funds.

After clearing up this situation, he can be granted a reprieve and be returned to

civil life without prejudice to civic incapacity, like ineligibility to carry out

certain functions.

Any amnesty or reprieve which fails to follow the above procedure is invalid, null

and void and grossly violates human and citizen rights.

- Douc Rasy, Ligue Cambodgienne des Droits de l'Homme et du Citoyen (LCDHC).

France.

MOST VIEWED

  • Ministry mulls ASEAN+3 travel bubble

    The Ministry of Tourism plans to launch a travel bubble allowing transit between Cambodia and 12 other regional countries in a bid to resuscitate the tourism sector amid crushing impact of the ongoing spread of Covid-19, Ministry of Tourism spokesman Top Sopheak told The Post on

  • ‘Kingdom one of safest to visit in Covid-19 era’

    The Ministry of Tourism on January 12 proclaimed Cambodia as one of the safest countries to visit in light of the Kingdom having been ranked number one in the world by the Senegalese Economic Prospective Bureau for its success in handling the Covid-19 pandemic. In rankings

  • Courts’ decisions now published as reference source

    The Ministry of Justice has published 44 verdicts from civil litigation cases which can be used as models for court precedents and for study by the public and those who work in pertinent fields. Publication of the verdicts on December 31 came as the result of joint

  • Quarantine site in north Phnom Penh inaugurated

    A four-building quarantine centre in Phnom Penh’s Prek Pnov district was formally inaugurated on January 6. The centre can house up to 500 people, according to Phnom Penh municipal governor Khuong Sreng. At the inauguration ceremony, Sreng said the municipal hall had cooperated with the Ministry

  • Reeling in Cambodia’s real estate sector

    A new norm sets the scene but risks continue to play out in the background A cold wind sweeps through the streets of Boeung Trabek on an early January morning as buyers and traders engage in commerce under bright blue skies. From a distance, the

  • China firm to develop Mondulkiri airport

    Tourism to the Kingdom’s northeast corridor could experience a remarkable metamorphosis after the government decided in principle of a Chinese company to study and develop a proposal to build a regional-level airport in Mondulkiri province, according to industry insiders. The Council of Ministers said