T HIRTEEN Vietnamese who ran into the US Embassy March 15 were told to seek asylum
there by a California-based group called the International Missing Persons Foundation
The thirteen - along with some 38 others who didn't make it in before the gates shut
- say they were part of the "Free Vietnam" anti-communist movement.
They say the IMPF - apparently a group founded by US veterans - gave money each month,
and had done so since a "special agent" visited Phnom Penh and started
the movement in August 1994.
They say they have been harrassed and watched by Cambodian police and "Hanoi
spies." Three of their members have recently been deported from Cambodia to
Vietnam - although no extradition treaty exists between the two neighbors - and
friends and relative say they've "disappeared."
Their Phnom Penh offices - called "CFC" - a construction company, cum 24-hour
legal advise, photocopying, typing and fax agency, and soon-to-be-opened restaurant
- were looted and locked by police "with cocked guns" on March 13.
On March 14 they got word from a man named An Mai, the IMPF's "special agent,
Bureau of Investigations" in California, to gather at the US embassy at 4pm
the following day.
"We were told [the Americans] would take care of us," said one of the asylum
Asylum was refused the 13 after charge d'affaires Bob Porter got "assurances"
from co-Interior Ministers Sar Kheng and You Hockry that the Vietnamese would not
be deported as long as they obeyed the law.
That satisfied the Americans and the UN High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR), who
got the "political squatters" to leave the embassy around midnight. The
Vietnamese however are far from reassured.
Interviewed outside the UNHCR on March 18, most of the group were worried about their
safety. They said they feared to go home.
In hushed tones they pointed out someone they described as a "Hanoi" man
mingling with their group outside the UNHCR offices - apparently a Chinese national
who showed the Post a Spanish Ministry of Interior identification card with his photo
and name. He claimed in broken English only to speak Spanish and Chinese.
The group were waiting to be interviewed by UNHCR staff, who at press time "had
not yet made up our mind whether they are people of concern to the UNHCR," according
to senior protection officer Walter Hoffmann.
Hoffmann said that many of them "had different agendas... and backgrounds."
He explained people had to demonstrate that they were outside their country of origin,
and had well-founded fears of persecution based on their political opinion, to be
considered political refugees.
Group members made no secret that their company - CFC - was funded from California.
The Post confirmed that CFC rented office space at $1,000 a month, "... and
look at us," said one of the group, "we don't have that sort of money."
CFC (Cambodia and Five Continents) also gave the Tudo newspaper up to $500 a month
and operated the "Vinalab" labor union and the Tudo political movement
that claims, according to its members, more than 1,000 supporters in Cambodia.
Most of the group also belong to the California-based Brotherhood Rally of All Veterans
Organization (Bravo) - whose laminated cards tell its members they are all "media
commandos" belonging to a "vehicle for veteran related activities, opportunities
Ly Chandara, the editor of Tudo, was arrested at dawn on March 9 by Cambodian police
and driven in a convoy to the Vietnamese border, according to his wife Chieu Mei.
There he was met by Vietnamese officials, and she says she does not know what happened
to him afterwards.
She said she did not expect to see him again.
A spokesman at the Vietnamese Embassy in Phnom Penh said he knew nothing about Tudo
or the deportations, other than what he had read in the papers.
The Ministry of Interior has said that a fourth wanted man was still in hiding, and
a ministry official said that "they cannot, on a whim, use Cambodian soil to
conduct political activities against another country."
Chieu Mei claimed that her husband was not political.
She said she had business dealings on behalf of the newspaper with the boss of CFC,
Ly Thara, who was deported along with Chandara and a third person.
She said Thara would give her around $300 to $500 a month for the paper. She also
said that on Nov 29 Thara organized three computers and a fax machine to be sent
from California for the paper to use.
The equipment was seized and three Vietnamese with US papers were arrested at Potchentong
- later to be released and deported back to the US. US Information Service (USIS)
director Frank Huffman said he was not aware of the incident.
Chieu Mei said: "Indeed, CFC was political but they told us not to get involved.
"They told us to continue to arrange help for the poor, for example when CFC
were going to make a donation of money to poor Vietnamese, we should advertize,"
Along with her four children, Chandara's wife was among those locked out from the
US Embassy on March 16. When told that those who made it had not been given asylum,
she said: "I should be angry, because some people are not involved in [politics],
including my husband. But maybe because my newspaper helped spread the charity of
CFC, that's why we got into trouble.
"But for the people inside, why didn't the US Embassy help?"
When told that Porter had assurances from Hockry and Kheng about the safety of the
asylum seekers, she reiterated others' comments: "No, I don't believe that.
I absolutely don't."
When asked on the night why the Vietnamese had picked the US for asylum, Porter said
his embassy had simply been a "target of opportunity."
USIS director Huffman said that the embassy had heard of the Bravo movement, but
not of IMPS nor CFC.
Huffman pointed out that the the US had full diplomatic relations with Phnom Penh
and Hanoi "and we don't support any extra judicial movement that would cause
trouble" between Cambodia, Vietnam and the United States.
"Obviously we don't support [Bravo's] activities that we understand to be anti
the Vietnamese government," he said.
He said he was not aware of any investigation into Bravo "but that's not to
say if we continue to get drawn into it we might not say hey, what's going on with
these people continuing to cause problems."
Huffman said that it was "not an option" to seek political asylum in US
embassies "unless someone runs in hot pursuit and they're in danger of losing
their lives... only then would we allow them to stay. These people didn't come into
The Post meanwhile interviewed Bravo Chief Executive Officer Tony Donovan in California,
who said he knew nothing about the IMPF.
Donovan said one Bravo officers - Tony Chan, who had since been sacked - had been
misusing Bravo membership cards in Cambodia for some time.
"I have no idea where [Chan] is, or where he has gone. I haven't seen him,"
"When we found out he was into extra curricular activities, we fired him. That
was about 18 months ago," he said.
Donovan said there were many legitimate members of Bravo in Cambodia. The head of
Bravo South East Asia - a former ARVN special forces colonel, Ho Dai Chan - was presently
in the United States "clarifying misconceptions about Chan's time in Cambodia."
Dai Chan was in charge of Bravo's activities in Vietnam and Cambodia.
Bravo was a veterans' organization that was not party to any political movement,
and was not "anti-Hanoi" or anti any government, he said. "We are
just tired of seeing people die," he said. "We help people."
Contact PhnomPenh Post for full articlePost Media Co Ltd
The Elements Condominium, Level 7
Hun Sen Boulevard
Phum Tuol Roka III
Sangkat Chak Angre Krom, Khan Meanchey
12353 Phnom Penh
Tel: +855(0) 23 888 161 / 162
Fax: +855(0) 23 214 318