Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Analysis: The government has announced plans to cover workers’ severance, but is it the best solution to factory disputes?

Analysis: The government has announced plans to cover workers’ severance, but is it the best solution to factory disputes?

Workers protest at the capital’s Benoh Apparel factory last month after returning from a work suspension to find the factory shuttered and the owners gone.
Workers protest at the capital’s Benoh Apparel factory last month after returning from a work suspension to find the factory shuttered and the owners gone. Pha Lina

Analysis: The government has announced plans to cover workers’ severance, but is it the best solution to factory disputes?

The government will begin to pay out of pocket for severance wages for labourers at abruptly shuttered factories whose owners have fled, effectively enacting a pro-worker policy without further burdening private businesses – albeit at the risk of discouraging good corporate citizenship, experts say.

The move was at the behest of Prime Minister Hun Sen and goes against the advice of several economists and labour activists, who have instead suggested a policy that would require companies to place deposits down before they open to discourage firms from fleeing without meeting their obligations to their employees.

The Labour Ministry is already set to pay a total of $4.6 million to workers at nine factories that were abruptly shuttered this year and whose owners absconded without paying their workers, according to ministry spokesman Heng Sour.

Prime Minister Hun Sen already approved the transfer of money from the Ministry of Economy and Finance to the Labour Ministry, after saying in a speech last week that latter ministry should “borrow” money to promptly pay laid-off workers, Sour said yesterday.

“With regards to the nine factories where the owners ran away, Prime Minister Hun Sen already provided the cash in advance,” he said. “This money will be brought to pay over 4,000 workers early next week.”

According to Article 116 of the Labour Law, an employer must pay any severance or indemnity pay to employees within two days of a contract being terminated.

But when a factory owner absconds, that legal requirement is rarely met. Instead, usually following a protest by workers, a local court often orders the sale of all the factory’s assets to pay the back wages.

However, the sale of assets often fails to cover the amount owed. The process can also take months, a serious problem for the majority of workers who live paycheck-to-paycheck and spend most of their wages on rent and food.

Ensuring workers get paid severance fits with the ruling party’s ongoing populist push to shore up support among garment workers ahead of July’s national elections, and paying the wages out of state coffers ensures that the impact on businesses is minimal, according to Miguel Chanco, lead Asean analyst at the Economist Intelligence Unit.

“Policymakers are probably wary that an additional cost burden could force some factories to reconsider their presence in the country, given the generally thin margins of the garment industry,” Chanco said in an email yesterday.

Even so, Chanco noted that while a social safety net system was necessary in Cambodia, a system whereby the government and private businesses shared responsibility would be preferable to an entirely state-run operation.

“If it was all down to the government, this would run the risk of creating moral hazard as businesses will have less of an incentive to act appropriately in such scenarios in the knowledge that the state is more than happy to clean up the mess they leave,” he said.

Ngeth Chou, a senior consultant at Emerging Markets Consulting, called the government’s plan a “temporary solution” and suggested a plan similar to the one described by Chanco, which Chou said would be more sustainable.

“In the long term, for prevention, the government needs to make sure that they create the strategy to prevent the investors from escaping easily, and deposit the right amount of the capital when they start business operations,” he said.

A scheme requiring deposits also has the support of labour rights groups. Esther Germans, program manager at Better Factories Cambodia, suggested a similar scheme last week, noting that “deposits of factories can be used to pay workers their missed wages, severance pay and indemnity payments when owners run away”.

Ben Gehrt, Southeast Asia field director of Workers Rights Consortium, backed the deposit scheme as well, saying that “money needs to be paid on a regular basis by factories and buyers into some kind of escrow account or public insurance scheme” in order to pay severances in the case of closure.

But Sour from the Labour Ministry rejected the deposit scheme yesterday, while also saying the ministry needed additional time to craft a policy.

“It’s not really the right solution,” Sour said, noting 98 percent of employers were following the Labour Law properly. “It may impact them, and to make one policy specifically to prevent this case requires time to discuss with our business partners.” He also noted that neighbouring countries do not have such a policy, potentially hurting Cambodia’s competitiveness, adding the “government is discussing the prevention strategy with stakeholders, but we need more time”.

Stephen Higgins, a managing partner at Mekong Strategic Partners, agreed that a scheme requiring deposits could spook potential investors in the country.

“Requiring companies to pay a deposit up front isn’t the solution, as it will only make Cambodia a less attractive investment destination,” he said.

He said it made sense for the government to provide a safety net for workers in these cases, pointing to Australia, which has a similar policy whereby the government covers some guaranteed wages and benefits if they were not fulfilled by a bankrupt company.

“[A] reality of life is that sometimes businesses go bankrupt and are unable to pay,” he said, adding that while the government should make it difficult for owners to flee, the payments to workers would not overburden the national budget.

Yang Sophorn, president of the Cambodian Alliance of Trade Unions, also suggested the government use its resources to prevent the factory owners from fleeing the country in the first place, noting the factory owners provided documents, addresses and passports when they first register a company.

“If they flee, the government must know very clearly that they need to catch that employer, either at the airport or any other border,” Sophorn said. “From my understanding, if they don’t want to let them go, they can always find them.”

MOST VIEWED

  • Joy as Koh Ker Temple registered by UNESCO

    Cambodia's Koh Ker Temple archaeological site has been officially added to UNESCO’s World Heritage List, during the 45th session of the World Heritage Committee held in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on September 17. The ancient temple, also known as Lingapura or Chok Gargyar, is located in

  • Famed US collector family return artefacts to Cambodia

    In the latest repatriation of ancient artefacts from the US, a total of 33 pieces of Khmer cultural heritage will soon return home, according to the Ministry of Culture and Fine Arts. In a September 12 press statement, it said the US Attorney’s Office for the

  • Tina rebuffs ‘false claims’ over falling paddy price

    Agriculture minister Dith Tina has shed light on the trade of paddy rice in Battambang – Cambodia’s leading rice-producing province – in a bid to curb what he dubs a “social media fact distortion campaign” to destabilise the market. While acknowledging that the prices of paddy

  • Kampot curfew imposed to curb ‘gang’ violence

    Kampot provincial police have announced measures to contain a recent spike in antisocial behaviour by “unruly’ youth. Officials say the province has been plagued by recent violence among so-called “gang members”, who often fight with weapons such as knives and machetes. Several social observers have

  • Cambodia set to celebrate Koh Ker UNESCO listing

    To celebrate the inscription of the Koh Ker archaeological site on UNESCO’s World Heritage List, the Ministry of Cults and Religion has appealed to pagodas and places of worship to celebrate the achievement by ringing bells, shaking rattles and banging gongs on September 20. Venerable

  • PM outlines plans to discuss trade, policy during US visit

    Prime Minister Hun Manet is set to meet with senior US officials and business leaders during his upcoming visit to the US for the UN General Assembly (UNGA), scheduled for September 20. While addressing nearly 20,000 workers in Kampong Speu province, Manet said he aims to affirm